ADMINISTRATIVE LITIGATION COURT Central Office 2545-0003. Fax 2545-0033. Email ...01 Second Judicial Circuit of San José, Annex A (Former Motorola Building) ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CASE FILE: 20-003688-1 027-CA PROCEEDING: PRE-SUIT PRECAUTIONARY MEASURE FILED BY: CÁMARA NACIONAL DE LA INDUSTRIA PALANGRERA RESPONDENT: INSTITUTO COSTARRICENSE DE PESCA Y ACUICULTURA (INCOPESCA) INTERESTED PARTY: ORGANIZACIÓN GLOBAL FISHING WATCH ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ N°459-2020 ADMINISTRATIVE LITIGATION COURT OF THE SECOND JUDICIAL CIRCUIT OF SAN JOSÉ - ANNEX A - Goicoechea, at sixteen hours and thirty minutes on día ocho de Setiembre del año dos mil veinte.- Application for a pre-suit precautionary measure (medida cautelar ante causam), filed by CÁMARA NACIONAL DE LA INDUSTRIA PALANGRERA against INSTITUTO COSTARRICENSE DE PESCA Y ACUICULTURA (INCOPESCA), with ORGANIZACIÓN GLOBAL FISHING WATCH having entered an appearance in the proceeding as an interested third party.- BACKGROUND:
- I)REGARDING THE DEFENSES RAISED AND GLOBAL FISHING WATCH INC.’S APPEARANCE IN THIS APPLICATION FOR PRECAUTIONARY RELIEF. Counsel for Instituto Costarricense de Pesca y Acuicultura (INCOPESCA) requested the joinder of Nombre3175 in relation to Organización Global Fishing Watch Inc., and also raised the defense of lack of standing on the part of both the applicant and the respondent. Nevertheless, it cannot be overlooked that this is a precautionary measure; it is the view of this Judge that, pursuant to sections 66 and 90 of Código Procesal Contencioso Administrativo, certain defenses need not be analyzed in advance because their assertion and resolution belong to other stages of the principal proceeding rather than to an anticipatory precautionary measure (medida cautelar anticipada). However, the applicant’s claim could potentially involve the party whose joinder is sought, hence the need for this Court to afford the respondent an opportunity to be heard and to address in advance whether such joinder is proper. As is evident, the applicant has opposed bringing Organización Global Fishing Watch Inc. into the proceeding as a respondent; that organization, however, has entered an appearance and requested recognition as a party to this matter, whether as an intervenor or as an interested third party. On that basis, this Judge can only state that, under the terms proposed, it is improper to recognize the cited party as an intervenor, since that procedural status does not permit a direct interest in the outcome of the proceeding, whereas in this case it is more than evident that such a direct interest does exist (see, in this regard, section 13 of Código Procesal Contencioso Administrativo). As for recognizing counsel for Organización Global Fishing Watch Inc. as an interested party in this matter, that status may indeed be admitted, not only because of the request timely made by counsel for the co-respondent Institute concerning joinder in the litigation (integración a la litis), but also because of the application submitted directly by Organización Global Fishing Watch Inc. requesting recognition as an interested party in this matter pursuant to section 15, subsection 1). b), of Código Procesal Contencioso Administrativo. That provision not only permits the assertion of independent claims but also affords the party an opportunity to enter an appearance in the proceeding either on the Court’s own motion or at a party’s request, taking the matter in its current procedural posture. Accordingly, pursuant to section 15 of Código Procesal Contencioso Administrativo, Organización Global Fishing Watch Inc. shall be recognized as an interested third party in this matter. Because it has entered an appearance in the proceeding, this Judge, pursuant to subsection 2) of the cited section, sees no impediment to immediately considering and deciding the present application in the interest of issuing the timely ruling required in proceedings of this nature. With respect to lack of standing on the part of both the applicant and the respondent, this Court declines to analyze that defense. If counsel for Instituto Costarricense de Pesca y Acuicultura considers it appropriate to maintain that argument, counsel must raise it in the principal action, should the applicant deem it appropriate to file such an action in due course. The foregoing ruling is fully supported by the prior analysis of the Second Section of Tribunal Contencioso Administrativo, which has developed this issue and stated, insofar as relevant to this ruling, as follows: “(...) From a technical standpoint, defenses cannot be raised as they may be in merits proceedings (procesos de conocimiento), except, of course, those relating to jurisdiction—which must be heard and specially ruled upon in advance because they suspend jurisdiction to continue hearing the case file, other than to decide that particular application—those relating to legal capacity and formal requirements—the latter of which would be considered when the application is decided on the merits—or those relating to joinder of the litigation (integración de la litis). Under those terms, any defense or objection submitted serves no purpose; however, if one is raised, it must be reserved for consideration together with the merits of the precautionary measure and not decided on an interlocutory basis. An interlocutory ruling (resolución interlocutoria) is inappropriate in this type of proceeding because it would permit a summary application to be converted into an ordinary proceeding, thereby distorting its essential nature. (...)” (boldface and underlining are ours). (See ruling N° 314-2020-II TRIBUNAL DE APELACIONES DE LO CONTENCIOSO ADMINISTRATIVO Y CIVIL DE HACIENDA DEL SEGUNDO CIRCUITO JUDICIAL DE SAN JOSÉ, SECCIÓN SEGUNDA, issued at siete horas y treinta minutos del once de junio de dos mil veinte.). In view of the foregoing, the Court declines to conduct a preliminary analysis of the lack of standing of either the respondent or the applicant raised by counsel for the respondent Institute.-
- II)GENERAL PRINCIPLES FOR GRANTING AN INTERIM MEASURE (MEDIDA CAUTELAR). As the Constitutional Chamber has explained, interim justice (justicia cautelar) responds to the need to guarantee the constitutional principle of prompt and effective justice by preserving the factual conditions essential for rendering and enforcing the judgment. (Resolución 7190-1994, de las 15:24 horas del 6 de diciembre). In this same regard, Article 19 of the Code of Administrative Judicial Procedure (Código Procesal Contencioso Administrativo) provides that the purpose of ordering an interim measure is to provisionally protect and guarantee the subject matter of the proceedings and the effectiveness of the judgment. Legal scholarship has indicated that the purpose of interim justice is not to declare a fact or liability, establish a legal relationship, enforce an order and satisfy an undisputed right, or resolve a dispute, but rather to prevent the harm that litigation may cause or that may arise from an abnormal situation (Gallegos Fedriani, Pablo. Interim Measures Against the Public Administration. 2nd ed. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Ábaco, 2006). With the foregoing clearly established, the adjudicator, in compliance with Article 21 of the aforementioned procedural code, must determine whether an application for an interim measure is admissible, verifying for that purpose that the claim in the proceedings on the merits (proceso de conocimiento) is neither reckless nor manifestly lacking in seriousness; this constitutes a preliminary assessment of the merits to determine whether the case presents what legal scholarship and case law have called a likelihood of success on the merits (apariencia de buen derecho), or fumus boni iuris. The provision under analysis also establishes that an interim measure is appropriate when the implementation or continuation of the conduct subject to the proceedings causes serious actual or potential harm or loss, a situation defined in legal scholarship as periculum in mora, or danger in delay (peligro en la demora); that is, where, due to the pathological delay inherent in judicial proceedings, there is a present, real, and objective danger that the moving party will suffer serious harm (Jinesta Lobo, Ernesto. Manual of Administrative Judicial Proceedings. 1st ed. San José, Costa Rica, Editorial Jurídica Continental, 2008). Following the same reasoning, Article 22 of the Code of Administrative Judicial Procedure requires the adjudicator, in light of the principle of proportionality, to balance the interests at stake—that is, the individual’s circumstances, on the one hand, against the public interest and the interests of third parties that may be affected by the adoption of the interim measure, on the other. Additionally, the cited Article 22 requires the interim measure to be ancillary and provisional.-
- III)ESSENTIAL REQUIREMENTS FOR ADMITTING AN INTERIM MEASURE. In this regard, it has been stated that, to provide interim relief (tutela cautelar), as a fundamental right derived from Article 41 of the Constitution—namely, the right to prompt and effective justice—the court must assess, for its effective realization, not only compliance with the requirements known in legal scholarship as Likelihood of Success on the Merits (Apariencia de Buen Derecho) (Fumus Boni Iuris), Danger in Delay (Peligro en la demora) (Periculum in Mora), and the balancing of the interests at stake, which will be detailed below, but also whether the characteristics referred to as the structural characteristics of the interim measure are present. The foregoing refers to its ancillary nature (instrumentalidad), provisional nature (provisionalidad), urgency (urgencia), and summary examination (summaria cognitio), or the summary nature of the proceedings (sumariedad del procedimiento). Both the stated requirements and the identified characteristics must be present for the requested measure to be granted for the purpose of provisionally protecting and guaranteeing the subject matter of the proceedings and the effectiveness of the judgment. The requirements necessary for granting the interim measure are as follows: a) Likelihood of Success on the Merits: for the interim measure to be appropriate, there must be “seriousness in the claim,” that is, such a probability of success that the claim does not appear, at first glance, manifestly lacking in seriousness or, as the case may be, reckless. According to legal scholarship, this is nothing more than the probable subsequent recognition in the judgment of the claimant’s substantive right (derecho material), based on the analysis characteristic of highly expedited proceedings (proceso sumarísimo), which cannot and must not in any way determine the merits of the matter presented, but instead constitutes only an approximation thereof based on the evidence available when the ruling granting or denying the measure is issued; b) Danger in Delay: this consists of the objectively well-founded and reasonable fear that the asserted substantive legal position (situación jurídica sustancial) will be seriously harmed or gravely and irreparably prejudiced during the time required to render judgment in the principal proceedings. This requirement calls for two elements: serious harm or loss and delay in the proceedings on the merits, without overlooking, of course, that this requirement includes what legal scholarship has called the “Bilateral Nature of Periculum in Mora” (Bilateralidad del Periculum in Mora), commonly known as the balancing of the interests at stake. The requirement refers to the characteristic that the alleged harm must possess: it must be capable of occurring—actually or potentially—if the requested measure is not adopted. Such harm must be established as serious and must also be shown to arise from the alleged situation. The alleged injuries must at least be demonstrated through the principle of a rational evidentiary basis (principio racional de prueba); therefore, it is not enough merely to allege harm in those terms, but the circumstances necessary for it to be considered harm, and serious harm at that, must be established. In that regard, it must be emphasized that merely alleging the existence of serious, actual, or potential harm or loss is insufficient; it must be proven, which, as stated above, is a procedural burden (carga procesal) that must be borne by the interested party seeking to prove its assertions, Article 317 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Código Procesal Civil). Regarding delay in the proceedings on the merits: This requirement refers to the situation arising from judicial proceedings that, for their conduct and subsequent conclusion, require a series of procedural acts through which not only due process (debido proceso) is guaranteed, but also the issuance of a decision that, even if it cannot be rendered promptly, is at least fair. Bringing proceedings on the merits to an end takes time, and this is precisely where interim relief acquires particular importance, because while the decision in the case is pending, serious harm is being prevented that, if it occurred, would render the claimed right ineffective. The entry into force of the Code of Administrative Judicial Procedure largely resolved the problem of proceedings that took years and even decades; today, despite all the efforts made, proceedings—although shorter due to the benefits of oral proceedings (oralidad)—must still pass through different stages and scheduling requirements, amid heavily congested dockets and other circumstances that cause proceedings to take a reasonable amount of time, but time nonetheless. Regarding the bilateral nature of periculum in mora: This term refers to the balancing of the interests at stake, associated with any public interest that may require protection, as weighed against the interests of third parties and, of course, the interests of the person seeking an interim measure. These interests must be comparatively assessed, and the measure must be denied when the harm suffered, or potentially suffered, by the community or third parties is greater than the harm that the applicant for the measure might experience.-
- IV)STRUCTURAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE INTERIM MEASURE: As previously indicated, in addition to the requirements already stated, the measure to be adopted must structurally possess the following characteristics: ancillary nature, meaning that such measures have a pronounced accessory relationship (relación de accesoriedad) to the final judgment because, ultimately, they serve as an instrument for preserving the subject matter of the proceedings as presented; provisional nature, meaning simply that whatever is ordered with respect to the interim measure will remain in effect subject to the resolution of the proceedings on the merits. It should be emphasized that the measure may also be terminated or modified at any time due to changes in the conditions that originally justified it, or a measure previously rejected may be adopted, as provided in Article 29 of the Code of Administrative Judicial Procedure. Its effectiveness therefore expires when the judgment on the merits (sentencia de mérito) is rendered, or, in other words, its effects are contingent upon the decision adopted in the principal proceedings; urgency, to avoid danger in delay; and summary examination, meaning that measures of this type are adopted by virtue of a highly expedited review conducted by the court without prejudging the merits of the matter, which could in no way replace the stages of the proceedings on the merits. Based on the foregoing legal framework for analysis and the elements required to grant an interim measure, the specific case will now be examined.
- V)ARGUMENT OF THE CLAIMANT (PARTE ACCIONANTE): Insofar as relevant to deciding this interim measure (medida cautelar), counsel for the CÁMARA NACIONAL DE LA INDUSTRIA PALANGRERA has stated that this application for interim relief (gestión cautelar) is filed against Resolution AJDIP/145-2020 of July 10, 2020, issued by the Board of Directors of INCOPESCA, asserting that the resolution provides for the disclosure to the private foreign organization Global Fishing Watch of information constituting the fishers’ traditional knowledge (conocimiento tradicional), contrary to the protection afforded to such information by the Ley de Biodiversidad. It reports that, since 2009, Costa Rica has been a member of the Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission (CIAT) as a result of the enactment of law 8712, Convention for the Strengthening of the Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission Established by the 1949 Convention Between the United States of America and the Republic of Costa Rica (“Antigua Convention”). Accordingly, the country is a member of that Commission and is required to comply with the resolutions it issues. Within the framework of CIAT, there are resolutions regulating access to data generated by fishing vessels, which that body classifies as confidential. Consequently, CIAT member countries have undertaken to comply with the guidelines established by the Commission regarding the manner in which such information may be accessed. It adds that Resolution C-15-07 of July 2015, entitled Rules and Procedures on the Confidentiality of Data, is currently in force on this matter. It states that, in that resolution, CIAT recognizes “the need for commercial and organizational confidentiality of the data submitted to CIAT.” Accordingly, it provides, among other matters, that vessel-location data must be supplied by quadrants rather than by exact position, and establishes a formal procedure for requesting such data. At the national level, the legal system requires medium-scale and advanced commercial fishing vessels to carry satellite-tracking devices and transmit their location data to INCOPESCA. Those obligations are governed by Decreto Ejecutivo N° 38681-MAG-MINAE of October 9, 2014, and the recently approved Reglamento para el seguimiento, control y vigilancia de embarcaciones pesqueras de las flotas nacionales y extranjeras (AJDIP/077-2020). It asserts that the latter regulation recognizes the confidential nature of this information, providing, for example, that “The information collected through the location, tracking, and control system for each vessel is for the exclusive use of INCOPESCA” (art. 6), and that “With respect to third parties, Nombre2819 shall determine the confidentiality of the information in accordance with the regulations in force” (art. 27). It reports that the confidential nature of the information is also expressly established in the contracts between the tracking-service provider (the company CLS) and the fishers who purchase satellite beacons from it. It adds that, in this regard, the contracts state verbatim: “13. CONFIDENTIALITY Neither Party shall disclose to third parties, and each shall use its best efforts to ensure that its directors, officers, employees, contractors, and suppliers keep confidential all proprietary information disclosed by the other Party, including, without limitation, documents marked confidential, technical information, documentation, software, processes, know-how, and other unpublished information, except as authorized in writing by the disclosing party. CNIP shall not make copies of the documentation without CLS’s prior written authorization.” It adds that, through Board Resolution AJDIP/145-2020 of July 10, 2020, Nombre2819 approved a Specific Cooperation Agreement (Convenio Específico de Cooperación, CEC) with the nongovernmental organization Global Fishing Watch Inc., entitled Convenio Específico de Cooperación Entre el Instituto Costarricense De Pesca Y Acuicultura - Nombre2819 - y Global Fishing Watch, Inc., Sobre la Plataforma de Intercambio de Datos del Sistema de Monitoreo de Embarcaciones. Under the CEC, Nombre2819 is to provide the foreign NGO with all information concerning national vessels operating in national waters, and that organization will make all such information public. They report that the CEC contains a clause stating that data concerning the locations where vessels fish will be released to the public. They contend that this publicly discloses information of commercial interest to fishers that they have acquired through traditional knowledge. They assert that, in the case of purse-seine vessels, this is inconsistent with the legal framework established by CIAT; they therefore contend that the CEC fails to comply with the regulations in force and is affected by defects relating to fundamental rights (derechos fundamentales).
With regard to the likelihood of success on the merits (apariencia de buen derecho), they consider it important to note that the fishers’ information forms part of their traditional knowledge, generated through their productive activities, life experience, and close relationship with the sea. They point out that traditional knowledge is protected in Costa Rica by the Ley de Biodiversidad and by international instruments governing the subject. The Ley de Biodiversidad recognizes the existence of knowledge, innovation, and practices of a traditional nature and also assigns value to them insofar as they are associated with natural resources. They cite article 77 and transcribe the following: “The State recognizes the existence and validity of forms of knowledge and innovation and the need to protect them through the use of the appropriate legal mechanisms for each specific case.” They consider that this provision must be analyzed together with section 78, transcribing the following: “The State shall grant the protection indicated in the preceding article through, among other means, patents, trade secrets (secretos comerciales), plant breeders’ rights, sui generis community intellectual rights, copyrights, and farmers’ rights.” They explain what, in their view, is provided by the International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture (TIRFA), which provides for the protection of traditional knowledge created by, among other groups, farmers and sectors of the population engaged in the production or extraction of food.
They transcribe article 9) and state that, although that article addresses traditional knowledge under the heading of farmers’ rights, they contend that it must be construed broadly rather than restrictively, because it encompasses practices related to the conservation of food biodiversity and is not limited solely to agriculture. Based on the foregoing, they assert that the knowledge generated by fishers is protected under both national and international law. They emphasize that it may indeed be regarded as traditional knowledge, on the understanding that it results from empirical experience in the activity, is built over time through fishing practices, and constitutes a valuable source of information for fisheries management, not only for fishers but also for the State. They therefore contend that, under the applicable legal framework, the secret and confidential nature of this information must be safeguarded, making the existence of a likelihood of success on the merits evident in this case.
They further contend that unrestricted public access to vessel geolocation jeopardizes the trade secrets underlying fishing activities. This is because each captain knows particular fishing grounds, when fishing is productive at those locations, and the methods under which the activity is most effective. Such information is confidential because it is generated through experience, and each fisher safeguards it as part of their know-how concerning fishing activities. Contrary to the assertion made in Mr. Del Valle’s legal opinion, such information may indeed be classified as undisclosed information (información no divulgada) under Ley N° 7975, Ley de información No Divulgada, and its implementing regulations. The applicant maintains that, if the article is analyzed element by element, it can be determined that the knowledge held by the fishers may indeed be included in this category because it satisfies all the elements specified in the article.
Fishers keep their preferred fishing grounds secret so that others do not learn of them and greater fishing effort is not exerted in the area. They emphasize that fishers possess this information as a result of their own fishing activities and the experience they develop over time. In other words, it is the product of the effort made by each fisher, who has discovered which areas are productive for fishing within the vast range of possibilities permitted by fisheries legislation and the limitations of their license. Finally, the purpose of this knowledge is to conduct profitable fishing trips in which a substantial quantity of fishery products is caught, subject to the limitations imposed by the authorities. As in other fields of commerce and industry, this information is kept confidential so that others cannot take advantage of it, because doing so would adversely affect the person who holds it.
The geolocation information will be provided by Nombre2819 to the NGO, which will in turn make the data available to the general public, although not in real time and while protecting the identity of each vessel. However, in the case of purse-seine vessels, there are international rules—CIAT resolutions—that do not permit this procedure to be applied. This is the case with Resolution C-15-07 of July 2015, in which CIAT established the Rules and Procedures on the Confidentiality of Data, including vessel-position data. In that resolution, CIAT recognizes “the need for commercial and organizational confidentiality of the data submitted to CIAT.” Accordingly, article 1 provides that location data must be supplied by quadrants rather than by exact position. They contend that this rule recognizes the importance of protecting not only the identities of the vessels and the persons on board, but also their exact positions, because of the clear commercial component discussed above.
Likewise, the disclosure of more detailed data requires an administrative procedure (procedimiento administrativo) and must be governed by the rules and procedures established in the resolution. The applicants understand that, throughout the regulations, any request submitted to CIAT to obtain these more detailed data must be justified and approved by CIAT’s bodies, and that several requirements must be met in order to access such information. They point out that this CIAT resolution is binding on Costa Rica and therefore consider it entirely misguided and legally untenable to approve an agreement with an NGO that completely disregards the established procedure for accessing these data.
It is asserted that the fact that Nombre2819 transmits exact vessel geolocation data to Global Fishing Watch, and that this NGO subsequently makes such information publicly available, constitutes a flagrant violation of international law and of the commitments and duties undertaken by Costa Rica within the framework of the CIAT. They conclude by stating that there are solid arguments in favor of interim relief (medida cautelar), including the need to protect the fishers’ traditional knowledge (conocimiento tradicional), the breach of the agreement concerning the protection of confidential and undisclosed information (información confidencial y no divulgada) of commercial interest to this productive sector, and the need to ensure that Costa Rica complies with its international duties and commitments. Regarding the risk in delay (Peligro en la Demora), they consider that there is indeed an imminent risk arising from the implementation of the aforementioned agreement, because publication of the data at issue to the general public would place Costa Rica in breach of international agreements (specifically, the legal framework governing the CIAT and its resolutions).
They assert that all of the foregoing means that the claim is neither reckless nor lacking in seriousness, since it is consistent with the applicable national and international legal system. They state that the objective is to enforce the existing legal protection relating to environmental protection (through the protection of traditional knowledge), undisclosed information of commercial interest, and the confidentiality established within the framework of the CIAT, as well as national regulations on satellite tracking and the contracts with the company providing the satellite-tracking service. Regarding the balancing of the interests at stake (Ponderación de los Intereses en Juego), they state that an attempt has been made in this case to set the guarantee of confidentiality against environmental protection, which is nothing more than a false dichotomy. Indeed, the regulations in force require fishing vessels to carry a satellite beacon so that Nombre2819 can monitor compliance with fisheries regulations.
The party bringing this proceeding considers that the installation and activation of this device on the vessels is what enables Nombre2819 to carry out its monitoring and surveillance activities. This institute is the only entity with the authority and legal power under current legislation to require fishers to provide this information. They consider that there is no rule, legal principle, or legal mandate of any kind within our legal system requiring the data sent to Nombre2819 to be released to the public in order for the corresponding monitoring and surveillance activities to be performed, since this authority is vested exclusively in that institute. The purported conflict between confidentiality and the right to a healthy and ecologically balanced environment is therefore entirely illusory: fishers send Nombre2819 undisclosed information derived from their traditional knowledge so that the institute may perform its functions related to the protection of natural resources, but the institute must, in turn, handle such data confidentially.
Neither the fact that the data are undisclosed eliminates the fishers’ duty to transmit their location to Nombre2819, nor does receipt of the data authorize Nombre2819 to treat them as public data. They emphasize that the fact that the information must be communicated to the authority to ensure environmental protection does not in any way eliminate the public administration’s duty of confidentiality. On the contrary, the handling of information by institutions requires that protective measures be taken so as not to disclose knowledge that is valuable to those who hold it. They assert that it has nowhere been established or demonstrated that releasing the fishers’ information to the public constitutes a matter of public-interest necessity; therefore, that consideration cannot be invoked to nullify confidentiality protections. Moreover, the Ley de Biodiversidad regards the protection of traditional knowledge as part of environmental protection.
They consider it important to mention that Article 27 of the Regulations for the Tracking, Monitoring, and Surveillance of Fishing Vessels of National and Foreign Fleets (Reglamento para el seguimiento, control y vigilancia de embarcaciones pesqueras de las notas nacionales y extranjeras) (AJDIP/077-2020) states: “The information recorded in the CSC shall be safeguarded by Nombre2819 and shall be shared on a restricted basis with the competent administrative or judicial authorities responsible for the surveillance and monitoring of fishing activities. With respect to third parties, Nombre2819 shall determine the confidentiality of the information in accordance with the regulations in force.” They consider that this demonstrates that the degree of confidentiality is not a matter left to the unfettered discretion of lNCOPESCA; rather, the institution may determine this factor in accordance with the regulations in force.
They state that this power cannot be separated from the protection of traditional knowledge provided for in the Ley de Biodiversidad and from the protection of undisclosed information. For these reasons, they consider it clear that publishing the fishers’ information produces neither a benefit nor a detriment to the public interest in environmental protection, but they assert that its publication is indeed harmful to the fishers insofar as it violates the guarantee of confidentiality established in the legal system. In addition, for the reasons stated above, giving the agreement the green light would entail noncompliance with the international commitments undertaken by the country within the framework of the CIAT, which is contrary to the public interest. They submit the following evidentiary materials: “(...) • Official Letter AL 113-07-2020 (3) dated July 9, 2020 (which also contains the agreement). • Contracts between CLS and the fishers.”.-
- VI)ARGUMENTS OF THE REPRESENTATIVE OF THE INSTITUTO COSTARRICENSE DE PESCA Y ACUICULTURA (INCOPESCA): Insofar as relevant to the resolution of this matter, it has expressed its opposition to this application for interim relief (gestión cautelar). It states that the reasons or grounds for entering into the agreement are based on Article 50 of the Constitución Política, which provides that the State has an obligation to seek the greatest well-being for all inhabitants of the country by organizing and stimulating production and the most appropriate distribution of wealth. It particularly emphasizes every person’s right to a healthy and ecologically balanced environment. It states that the foregoing constitutional guarantee entails a duty on the part of the State to organize its actions so as to ensure the fulfillment of these constitutionally rooted rights. It further reports that Ley N° 7384, the law establishing INCOPESCA, empowers the Institute, under Article 3 thereof, to coordinate activities with organizations of any kind whose combined efforts seek to promote the use of fisheries resources and the conservation of species, in order to attain the greatest social benefit. Article 5 of the same law allows the Institute to enter into cooperation agreements with national and international institutions to promote and secure financial resources for the scientific and technological development of fishing and aquaculture activities. Similarly, Ley N° 8436 (de Pesca y Acuicultura) provides that Nombre2819, as the authority responsible for implementing that Law, is entrusted, among other responsibilities, with promoting and developing fishing, marine hunting, aquaculture, and research, as well as fostering the conservation, utilization, and sustainable use of marine and aquaculture biological resources. Specifically, Article 129 entrusts the Institute with the processes of collecting, organizing, digitizing, analyzing, and disseminating statistical information, indicating that those processes are public in nature and that their principal objective is to serve as the basis for planning fishing and aquaculture activities at the national level. Consequently, the Institute is empowered to implement fisheries policies and to regulate and administer marine resources, including by entering into agreements of this nature. It reports that on 2 de mayo del 2018, the Letter of Intent was signed between the Ministerios del Ambiente y Energía y de Seguridad Pública de la República de Costa Rica and Global Fishing Watch, Inc., with the intention of improving mutual cooperation in analyzing and mapping fishing-effort intensity and fishing patterns in the waters of Costa Rica’s Exclusive Economic Zone, and of increasing the capacity of Costa Rican authorities to conduct marine and fisheries surveillance through the use of technology; this process was further strengthened by the implementation of the Agreement entered into by INCOPESCA. Through Decreto Ejecutivo N°41025-MP-MAG-MSP, published in La Gaceta 86 of 17 de mayo del 2018, the Comisión Interinstitucional sobre Pesca Ilegal, No Declarada y No Reglamentada (INDNR), in which INCOPESCA participates, was created for the purpose of developing public policies aimed at preventing, combating, and deterring illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing in all spheres—administrative, law-enforcement, and judicial—through joint and coordinated action among State institutions, in order to address this issue in Costa Rica’s Territorial Sea and Exclusive Economic Zone. On 26 de febrero del 2019, within the framework of the Comisión Interinstitucional sobre Pesca INDNR, the President of the Republic agreed to promote a national strategy against Pesca INDNR, which identified, among other measures, the imperative of entering into cooperation agreements with various International Organizations to support satellite-monitoring activities. With respect to the Agreement, it considers it important to note that its purpose is to collaborate in the sustainable use of marine resources by increasing transparency in the country’s fishing activities. To that end, it seeks to establish a collaborative framework for exchanging data from the vessel monitoring system (VMS) and from the registry maintained by Nombre2819 of vessels associated with fishing activities with GFW, so that the locations reflected by these VMS signals are displayed transparently on the public globalfishingwatch.org platform, thereby promoting joint work between the Institute and GFW. It asserts that greater fisheries transparency strengthens monitoring, control, and surveillance and supports national and regional efforts to combat illegal fishing. By signing the Cooperation Agreement with GFW, the country joins the technological advances already applied by countries such as Panamá, Perú, Chile, and Indonesia in their national fisheries systems. It asserts that the adoption of this Agreement demonstrates Costa Rica’s leadership in fisheries transparency by sharing data from the monitoring system for vessels in our fleet. This work will promote the sustainable use of our marine resources by strengthening control and surveillance measures in our jurisdictional waters, which the fishing sector considers necessary to assure international markets that our fish comes from sustainable sources, through an updated Monitoring, Control, and Surveillance system employing a modern and effective technological mechanism. It reports that, as has been promoted since 2019, the medium-scale and advanced-scale fishing sector (longline fishing (palangre)), with the support of that Institute, is promoting the first Fisheries Improvement Project (Proyecto de Mejora Pesquera), or FIP, which seeks to certify tuna, mahi-mahi, and swordfish fisheries. As its representatives have correctly stated, there is a commitment to improving fishing practices and complying with international standards for responsible fishing, an objective encompassed by the signing of this Agreement. It asserts that a legal analysis was conducted of the Agreement between Nombre2819 and GFW concerning the platform for exchanging vessel-monitoring-system data, and it was determined that the data to be collected, transmitted, and analyzed do not meet the criteria for constituting personal data under national legislation, specifically Ley No. 8968 “Protección de la Persona frente al tratamiento de sus datos personales.” It emphasizes that the data to be published under this Agreement do not pertain to natural persons and therefore do not affect the private sphere; instead, they consist of satellite geolocation data for vessels, which are required to transmit them pursuant to the licenses granted to them, the administrative authorizations for transshipment or unloading of products at national ports, and the regulations requiring such transmission. Accordingly, there is no violation of the guarantee protecting natural persons. The personal data of the owners, representatives, and shipowners of licensed vessels, as well as those of the captain and crew, will not be displayed on the public globalfishingwatch.org platform. In the view of the respondent’s representative, the claimant engages in a false and malicious equation, based on unfounded analogical reasoning, by attempting to link fishing activity to traditional knowledge under the Tratado Internacional sobre los Recursos Fitogenéticos para la Alimentación y la Agricultura. That treaty, which entails a certain degree of operational complexity and a special implementation regime because it establishes a multilateral system of access and benefit-sharing exclusively for plant genetic resources, is not applicable to this case. Plant genetic resources are defined as any genetic material of plant origin having actual or potential value for food and agriculture. It considers that continuing to elaborate on this point concerning the absurd equation drawn would trivialize the matter and show disrespect toward the Chamber. It considers it important to mention that, in 2018, the longline-fishing sector filed complaints of illegal fishing by foreign purse-seine vessels, and that the sector itself used the Global Fishing Watch, Inc. platform as a source of information. In its view, this confirms that the platform can be useful to the fishing sector generally in promoting transparency in legal fishing activities. With respect to the likelihood of success on the merits (Apariencia de Buen Derecho), it considers that granting the interim measure requested by the claimant would effectively resolve the merits of the matter without an opportunity to debate whether the relief sought is warranted, because interim-relief proceedings are not intended to satisfy the asserted right. With respect to the risk posed by delay (Peligro en la Demora), it considers that, in the case at hand, the applicants have not demonstrated the existence of serious harm or loss that would be difficult or impossible to remedy, nor have they demonstrated a possible causal link between the challenged administrative conduct and the alleged harm; consequently, it considers the adoption of the measure unwarranted. Regarding the balancing of the interests at stake (Ponderación de los Intereses en Juego), it states that, in this case, the interests to be balanced are the fishermen’s private interest in protecting the confidentiality of certain knowledge or “know-how,” on the one hand, and, on the other, the overriding public interest reflected in the legal obligation of fishing-license holders to transmit their geolocation as an indispensable requirement for engaging in fishing operations. That obligation gives rise to Nombre2819’s legal authority to use such information to fulfill its purposes, with the assistance of other organizations, as well as to the constitutional public interest (Art. 50) vested in INCOPESCA, which encompasses the State’s obligation to seek the greatest well-being for all inhabitants of the country by organizing and stimulating production and the most appropriate distribution of wealth, together with every person’s right to a healthy and ecologically balanced environment, as related to the State’s obligation to protect human life, guarantee decent work, and prevent and deter illegal, unreported, and unregulated fishing. It considers it clear that, in this matter, the public interest in safeguarding the national and international legal order for the protection of marine resources, human life, and the right to decent work must prevail over the appellant’s private and commercial interest. As part of its evidentiary materials, it submits the following: “(...) The following copies from the administrative record are attached: • Official Letter AL 029-03-2020 (1). Request for clarification from the Executive Presidency. • Legal Opinion of Lic. Edgar del Valle M., International Consultant, concerning the Specific Cooperation Agreement between Global Fishing Watch and the Instituto Costarricense de Pesca y Acuicultura. • Official Letter AL 113-07-2020 (3). Approval by Legal Counsel for the Board of Directors. • Resolution of the Nombre2819 Board of Directors AJDIP/145-2020 of 10 de julio de 2020 and formalization of the Specific Cooperation Agreement between Nombre2819 and Global Fishing Watch. • Specific Cooperation Agreement between the Instituto Costarricense de Pesca y Acuicultura—INCOPESCA—and Global Fishing Watch, ING., concerning the vessel-monitoring-system data-exchange platform, signed.”
- VII)ARGUMENTS OF THE REPRESENTATIVE OF THE ORGANIZATION GLOBAL FISHING WATCH: Insofar as relevant to the resolution of this matter, it reports that the organization it represents is a nongovernmental organization (NGO) with a global presence, operating on a nonprofit basis, whose fundamental purpose is to promote the sustainability of our ocean through greater transparency in fishing and scientific research. By transforming the monitoring and analysis of the global fishing fleet, GFW cooperates with States to address threats to marine resources, security, and coastal communities more effectively. They state that they have had active technology supporting these efforts by the international community since 2016. They affirm that they are committed to advancing ocean sustainability through greater transparency. They do so by providing, free of charge, data and monitoring of fishing activity by international fleets, supporting science and research, and promoting universal dialogue on ocean transparency. With regard to the request for provisional relief (pretensión cautelar), it considers that the request exceeds the strictly provisional nature of interim judicial protection (auxilio cautelar), whose sole purpose is to provisionally preserve the subject matter of the proceedings and ensure the effectiveness of any eventual judgment. It considers that granting the interim measure (medida cautelar) in the proposed form would amount to deciding the entire dispute on the merits without even debating whether the relief claimed is warranted. The interested party takes the position that the plaintiff chose to challenge the enforceability of the administrative act (acto administrativo) through contentious-administrative proceedings (vía contenciosa), without demonstrating, even to a standard of probability, that agreement Nombre2819 AJDIP/145-2020 of 10 de julio de 2020 contravenes agreements, laws, or regulations within the regulatory framework governing Nombre2819 and commercial fishing activity in Costa Rica. It reports that, pursuant to Article 1 of the CEC entered into between Nombre2819 and GFW, its purpose is to establish a collaborative working framework through which Nombre2819 will directly, securely, and automatically transfer VMS data or vessel geolocation data to GFW so that the data may be processed, aggregated, and redacted and subsequently placed on the public globalfishingwatch.org platform. It states that some of these data will be made available to both parties to the Agreement in a private workspace, and that only the vessel’s generic identifying name assigned by Nombre2819, the vessel’s flag, and its geolocation will be published in the public workspace after a delay of 72 hours (3 días). It adds that the handling of data relating to fishing activity is understood within the framework of the sovereign powers of the State, whether flag or coastal State, and falls within the scope of the concept of transparency. It reports that the transparency process within the fishing system comprises different stages. The first and most important is data availability. Thus, each sovereign State transforms the data into information that informs the adoption of appropriate measures and strengthens, in particular, the system’s monitoring, control, and surveillance mechanisms (mecanismos de MCV). Among all the data produced by the fishing system as a whole, the data of interest to GFW are solely those related to vessel geolocation and public-record data. This interest is based on the sovereign need of States to control the activities of vessels engaged in harvesting public resources, without interfering with the commercial operations of the entire value chain. In other words, GFW cooperates with States in exercising their sovereign right and duty to ensure appropriate conservation and management measures by technologically enhancing data analysis. It states that it must also be emphasized, within this regulatory context governed by CONVEMAR and the CDB, that vessel geolocation cannot in any way be associated with a measure that violates traditional knowledge (conocimiento tradicional), in light of the provisions of Article 8 (j) of CDB9 itself and the work of the Open-ended Ad Hoc Working Group on Article 8(j) and Related Provisions'°, and the Intergovernmental Committee of the World Intellectual Property Organization on Intellectual Property and Genetic Resources, Traditional Knowledge and Folklore (ClG)". It later states that the applicant Chamber alleges that geolocation infringes upon the traditional knowledge of fishers, while disregarding or omitting in bad faith the fact that this satellite-tracking system, which was initially designed to prevent collisions and locate vessels requiring assistance from Governments, serves the collective interest rather than an individual interest, because the State has the authority to exercise sovereignty over the waters under its jurisdiction and, for that purpose, may use the technological tools available to it, as clearly established in Article 2.6 of Ley de Pesca y Acuicultura No. 8436. With regard to the CEC, it states that Nombre2819 is not only the lawful holder of the information generated by the CSC that it safeguards, having obtained it through lawful means arising from the processes for obtaining fishing licenses or administrative authorizations for transshipment or unloading at national ports, but may also determine which portion of that information is confidential, which portion will be made public, and in what formats. It considers it important to add that another relevant aspect is that Nombre2819 is legally empowered to enter into cooperation agreements such as the CEC. It considers that the request to suspend the validity of a Board of Directors agreement and the resulting formalization of a Specific Cooperation Agreement until the courts determine whether there has allegedly been a breach of rules and an alleged failure to honor international commitments is reckless and prevents the pursuit of a relevant public interest, namely, the protection of fisheries resources. With regard to the risk arising from delay (Peligro en la Demora), it states that damages must be established through appropriate evidence, which, in its view, the applicants for the interim measure have not provided. Merely alleging the existence of actual or potential harm is insufficient; evidentiary material must be submitted on a preliminary basis, but with legal rigor. With regard to the balancing of the interests at stake (Ponderación de los Intereses en Juego), it considers that the plaintiff failed to establish appropriately the existence of serious, actual, and irreparable harm; the circumstances do not warrant giving precedence to the interests of the Cámara Nacional de la Industria Palangrera over the obligation of Nombre2819 and public entities generally to ensure compliance with Article 6 of the Constitución Política. It asserts that not only is there a clear and manifest public interest in protecting the environment, but the State is also under an obligation to organize its institutional structure so as to secure the welfare of its inhabitants and to defend and preserve citizens’ right to a healthy and ecologically balanced environment, which includes regulating and overseeing the extraction of a resource of public interest such as fisheries resources. It states that, together with the cited legal provisions, this establishes the existence of a public interest in protecting the environment that conflicts with any individual right to maintain the confidentiality of certain information, which is merely one of the many components of fishing activity.-
- VIII)ON THE SPECIFIC CASE. The Court proceeds to conduct the corresponding examination of the elements required to determine whether the interim measure (medida cautelar) presently before us should be granted, pursuant to Articles 21 and 22 of the Code of Administrative Litigation Procedure (Código Procesal Contencioso Administrativo), taking into consideration not only the parties’ arguments, but also the relevance of the evidence submitted in the proceeding, a matter that falls solely and exclusively to the party seeking to prove its assertions, as provided in Article 41 of the Code of Civil Procedure (Código Procesal Civil), by reference from Article 220 of the Code of Administrative Litigation Procedure. The elements required for granting this application are addressed below: Likelihood of success on the merits (apariencia de buen derecho). As indicated at the beginning of Considerando V) of this decision, the applicant’s counsel has stated that this application for interim relief challenges agreement AJDIP/145-2020 del 10 de julio de 2020 of the Board of Directors of INCOPESCA, asserting that it entails providing information constituting the fishers’ traditional knowledge to the private foreign organization Global Fishing Watch, which, in counsel’s view, contravenes the protection afforded to such information by the Biodiversity Law (Ley de Biodiversidad). The claimant maintains that the CEC contains a clause stating that data concerning the locations where vessels fish will be released to the public. They contend that this publicly discloses information of commercial interest to the fishers that they have obtained through traditional knowledge. In the case of purse-seine vessels (embarcaciones cerqueras), this contradicts the legal framework established by CIAT. Counsel emphasizes that the knowledge generated by the fishers is protected under both domestic and international law, considering that unrestricted public access to the vessels’ geolocation endangers the trade secrets underlying fishing activities. For these reasons, they assert that the CEC fails to comply with the applicable regulations and contains defects relating to fundamental rights, and that they have therefore appeared before this jurisdiction to request, as interim relief, the suspension of the cited agreement while the principal proceeding is adjudicated by this Court. Based solely on the evidence submitted, this Court considers it prudent to deem the element under review satisfied, for the simple reason that there is an administrative provision which, in the applicants’ view, causes them loss and damage; whether such loss and damage exists and warrants relief cannot be determined through an interim measure, but rather in the principal proceeding. Likewise, ruling on whether the CEC actually fails to comply with the applicable regulations and contains defects relating to fundamental rights would involve deciding the merits. For this Court, the opposition expressed by both the defendant and the interested party (parte interesada) in the proceeding, who defend the challenged Agreement, must also be examined in the principal proceeding, since this Court cannot, in advance, favor either position, as doing so would prejudge an issue that must necessarily be resolved in the principal proceeding. As to the ancillary nature (instrumentalidad) of the relief requested through this application in relation to the eventual merits proceeding (proceso de conocimiento), the Court notes that both the defendant and the interested party agree that granting the interim measure in the terms proposed would resolve the entire dispute on the merits without even debating whether the relief sought is warranted. This Court respects and agrees with the positions of the cited parties, but in this case only as regards the need to examine on the merits the unlawfulness of the challenged action, since its legality can be examined and determined only in the principal proceeding and not beforehand. This necessarily and logically means that the requisite likelihood of success on the merits does exist in this case, at least for the purpose of considering whether the relief sought is warranted, an issue that may properly be examined in the corresponding merits proceeding to determine which position is correct. This conclusion is reached for the simple reason that we cannot disregard the jurisdiction vested in this Court under both Article 49 of the Constitution and the Code of Administrative Litigation Procedure, which authorizes comprehensive review of the legality of administrative action and entails declaring legally noncompliant any formal or material conduct that is contrary to the body of applicable law (bloque de legalidad). Likelihood of success on the merits is itself a probability assessment made by the Judge regarding the proceeding’s eventual outcome. Because this is an application for interim relief, and particularly one made before commencement of the principal action (ante causam), it is premature to determine whether it should be granted, since the arguments and evidence supporting the merits proceeding may differ from those presently before us. At this procedural stage, the undersigned cannot venture to question whether this requirement is satisfied, in application of the constitutional principle guaranteeing that any person who considers themselves affected by administrative action may seek redress before this Jurisdiction, with access to justice also being recognized as a fundamental right (Articles 41 and 49 of the Political Constitution (Constitución Política)). Accordingly, at least prima facie, without prejudging the matter or even determining the likelihood that the action will succeed, the fact remains that it may properly be examined in the principal proceeding should the applicant’s counsel decide to file it. On those terms, the requirement under review is deemed satisfied. As to the risk arising from delay (peligro en la demora): It must be stated that this element is not satisfied with respect to the applicant’s legal position. Although it might be presumed that the situation could adversely affect the applicant in various ways, this is merely a human presumption. In that regard, it must be stated that alleging the existence of serious actual or potential loss or damage is insufficient; it must be proven, and the procedural burden (carga procesal) of proving that assertion rests with the interested party, pursuant to Article 41 of the Code of Civil Procedure, applicable to this matter by reference from Article 220 of the Code of Administrative Litigation Procedure. In this matter, the claimant submits the following evidence: “(...) • Official letter AL 113-07-2020 (3) del 09 de julio de 2020 (which also contains the agreement). • Contracts between CLS and the fishers. (see the original application for interim relief filed on 05/08/2020).” Through its filing submitted on veinticuatro de Agosto del año en curso, the claimant, among other statements, reports and submits evidence relating to GFW’s public platform, where it can be seen that data concerning vessels fishing in Costa Rican waters are already being displayed to the general public; the claimant therefore considers it necessary for this new interim measure to be granted, given the implications involved. (see filing and images submitted on 24/08/2020). It cannot be overlooked that it is precisely the evidence submitted with applications of this type that enables the Court to determine whether harm actually exists and, if so, its magnitude. If we compare the evidence submitted with the harm alleged, the evidence does nothing whatsoever to help establish whether harm actually exists or has occurred, much less the possibility of determining its magnitude. This Court could presume that harm exists, but determining its magnitude is an entirely different matter, since not just any harm may be protected through applications of this type. It bears emphasizing that the claimant has submitted no evidence demonstrating the harm that it might be experiencing, or is currently experiencing, as a result of the publication of the national fishing vessels’ geolocation data on publicly accessible websites. As indicated, the evidence submitted with the principal application for interim relief (filed on 05/08/2020) did not make it possible to ascertain the harm, much less its severity, as of the very date on which the application was considered; accordingly, the request for an urgently provisional interim measure (medida cautelar en carácter de provisionalísima) was denied by the decision issued at diecisiete horas cinco minutos del día cinco de Agosto del año dos mil veinte. Turning to the original application for interim relief, it sought interim protection so that agreement AJDIP/145-2020 del 10 de julio de 2020 of the Board of Directors of INCOPESCA would be suspended, in order to prevent information of interest to the party appearing before this jurisdiction from being published on publicly accessible websites. Because there was no evidence demonstrating the harm, the request for an urgently provisional interim measure was denied on the same day it was filed, with the result that the information has now appeared on publicly accessible websites; the claimant therefore asserts that the harm is no longer merely potential but has become actual. Turning now to the evidence submitted to substantiate the harm, we see that it is aimed at reporting or demonstrating that data or information which, in the claimant’s view, injures the fishers’ interests is now in fact appearing publicly, and that because of those publications, the incorporation of the data into the GFW platform has transformed the harm from potential to actual. On that basis, and in the absence of evidence demonstrating it, the Court must ask what has occurred since those data were published on or incorporated into the GFW platform. How have the fishers’ loss and damage manifested themselves? Has their fishing activity been prevented or diminished, and if so, to what extent? What repercussions has that disclosure of data caused for their current fishing activities? The claimant speaks of harm that is no longer even potential but actual, yet fails to submit the evidence necessary to support that assertion. Images of the publications that, in the claimant’s view, cause loss and damage are submitted—an issue going to the merits—but detailed information concerning the harm they are experiencing as a result of those publications has been omitted. Although this Court can understand that disclosing certain information to the general public might cause the applicant’s counsel some difficulties and that this could result in harm, in the absence of evidence to that effect, the Court does not find that such harm reaches the required level of severity. It bears recalling that, to receive protection through applications of this type, the harm must not only be present, but its severity must also be demonstrated, which is precisely what the submitted evidence fails to establish.
By way of illustration of the foregoing, urgency was claimed from the outset to prevent the publication of certain information that, in the applicant’s view, would cause them serious harm and damages; however, it must be understood that such adverse effects, or the damages claimed, must be proven, since the party resorting to this avenue must demonstrate them, as that party is in fact obligated to prove the harm. In this case, it is entirely unknown what harm they have experienced as a result of the information published on public websites or how the disclosure of these data has affected their activities; that is precisely what remains unknown to this day. It must be emphasized—and it is extremely important to understand—that this Court is not familiar with the Cámara Nacional de la Industria Palangrera represented herein; consequently, the harm claimed to have resulted from the disclosure of data and information cannot be established or presumed based solely on the party’s assertions, because there is no evidence of the repercussions that those data publications have caused and that the fishers are experiencing, which precludes a finding not only of harm but also of its magnitude.
This Court has identified a series of narratives, statements, and arguments that have not been supported by the necessary evidentiary material. Although a party may make assertions and/or arguments, those arguments must be accompanied by the evidence necessary for that purpose, so as to lend credibility to what is asserted; otherwise, they constitute subjective assessments and, as such, are not eligible for protection through this type of proceeding. If the moving party does not submit the evidence necessary to support its assertions (Article 41 of the Código Procesal Civil), this Court could only presume that harm is in fact being caused; however, it must be clarified that this Court was not created to presume the legal circumstances of parties that resort to this avenue, but rather to rule in accordance with law. This obviously would not permit granting relief to one party to the detriment of another without proper proof of what is requested, because doing so would create a procedural imbalance benefiting a party that should have proven what it sought to obtain from the opposing party.
The moving party must bear in mind that, when resorting to this type of application, what is protected against is the potential harm it might experience both because of the delay in obtaining a response in the proceeding on the merits (proceso de fondo) and because of the pressing situation it may be experiencing or may experience if the application is not granted. It must also be borne in mind that the harm sought to be prevented through this type of proceeding must reach a serious level, and that seriousness can be established only through the evidence necessary, relevant, and compelling for that purpose. This is why precautionary relief (tutela cautelar) suspends the execution of the challenged actions, in order to ensure that the harm does not occur or ceases to occur. It must not be overlooked that such harm cannot be unreal, hypothetical, or abstract; therefore, if the type of harm that could be caused by the implementation of an administrative action (conducta administrativa) is not clearly apparent, it must at least be established that the harm will cause a serious adverse effect such that, even if a judgment on the merits were ultimately entered in the party’s favor, that judgment would no longer be capable of restoring matters to the desired state.
It bears repeating that merely alleging the existence of harm or damages is insufficient; they must be proven. As is already known, this is a procedural burden (carga procesal) borne by the interested party, and it was not fully and properly discharged in this case, because, if the party wished to demonstrate the harm, it should have submitted the necessary and relevant supporting evidence. Although this may appear repetitive, it cannot be overlooked that anyone resorting to this type of application must bear in mind that the evidence submitted in the proceeding and identified above will be very useful for analysis in the adjudicatory proceeding (proceso de conocimiento)—should the claimant decide to institute it—but is not useful for demonstrating the harm, which is precisely what should have been established in the record. Another circumstance that draws this Court’s attention is that this application for precautionary relief (gestión cautelar) was filed on the fifth day of August of the current year and was considered and denied on a highly provisional basis (carácter de provisionalísima) in the ruling issued at seventeen hours and five minutes on the fifth day of August of the year two thousand twenty, bearing in mind that the claimant titled it “URGENT.” However, because it was denied on a highly provisional basis, a situation different from the “Urgency” claimed from the very day it was filed has become apparent: the representation of the Cámara Nacional de la Industria Palangrera has not had the benefit of a precautionary measure (medida cautelar) suspending the execution of the administrative action it challenges, and more than one month has elapsed between that date and today, when its particular situation is being decided on the merits.
Yet it has submitted nothing—no evidence that would cause this Court to conclude, or rather reconsider, that its application was well-founded and now, upon consideration of the merits, to alter the denial previously issued pursuant to Article 29(2) of the Código Procesal Contencioso Administrativo. This circumstance demonstrates that the claimant’s situation was not and has not been as pressing or urgent as alleged. It should be recalled that the urgency arose from the possible adverse repercussions the claimant might experience from the publication of the data it seeks to protect. However, it is the claimant’s own representative who has reported that, as of today, data concerning the vessels operating in Costa Rican waters have already been published, having been made available to the general public (this is demonstrated by the images submitted with its filing dated 24/08/2020). Nevertheless, in the absence of evidence demonstrating the following, this Court does not know: What harm have these publications caused the fishers?
Has their activity diminished? How have the fishers been adversely affected by the publication? How serious is the harm that they now claim has become actual? These are some of the questions for which no answer is available, because, as of today, the harmful consequences that the disclosure of the data the applicant seeks to protect has caused it remain entirely unknown. This Court cannot overlook that the reason the requirement under analysis has not been deemed satisfied lies precisely in the failure to demonstrate the harm, which cannot be established solely on the basis of the party’s assertions; rather, it should have been established through the evidence necessary, relevant, and compelling for that purpose, which is precisely what did not occur in this case. Accordingly, the requirement under analysis cannot be deemed satisfied, with the result that the precautionary measure must be denied, because all required elements must be present for it to be warranted, and the absence of any one of them results in its denial, as is hereby ordered.
Finally, regarding the balancing of the interests at stake: This Judge considers that, because the existence of serious harm has not been demonstrated, the only possible conclusion is that the private interest must yield to the public interest represented by the need for the actions of public entities and private parties to conform to the parameters of legal certainty (seguridad jurídica) and legality established by the legal system, irrespective of what may ultimately be decided on the merits in the corresponding proceeding. This Court cannot disregard the powers conferred upon the Instituto Costarricense de Pesca y Acuicultura (INCOPESCA); nor could it, through an application for precautionary relief, determine whether, in this case, the Acuerdo de Junta Directiva del Nombre2819 AJDIP/145-2020 del 10 de julio de 2020 and the execution of the Convenio Específico de Cooperación (CEC) entre Nombre2819 y Global Fishing Watch entail all the alleged drawbacks, not only for the claimant represented herein but also for the country, because these matters are reserved for determination on the merits.
It is therefore determined that, until otherwise ordered in the adjudicatory proceeding, prudence weighs against deeming the requirement under analysis satisfied, because, in the particular case under consideration, there is a complete absence of the necessary, relevant, and compelling evidence that would make it possible to establish the magnitude of the harm that the Cámara Nacional de la Industria Palangrera might experience, much less may already be experiencing, as a result of the implementation and commencement of the challenged agreement. Under those circumstances, that harm or adverse effect cannot be quantified so as to permit a balancing of which harm and/or situation should receive protection. Accordingly, there can be no doubt that the public interest, represented on this occasion by the Instituto Costarricense de Pesca y Acuicultura (INCOPESCA), must prevail over the private interest.-
- IX)COSTS (COSTAS): The representative of the Instituto Costarricense de Pesca y Acuicultura (INCOPESCA) requested that costs be awarded against the plaintiff. However, in this Judge’s view, the manner in which the events occurred in the administrative proceedings gave the applicant an opportunity to come before this Court to defend its rights and interests. It should be noted that an application for interim relief (medida cautelar) is not the proper proceeding in which to examine the merits of the matter; consequently, whether or not the applicant is correct in its assertions is something that may be determined only in the principal action, should the representative of the Cámara appearing herein decide to file it. Nevertheless, it must not be overlooked that the reason for denying this application for interim relief was different, namely, the proof of the harm that the applicant could suffer, and could already be suffering, if its request were not granted. However, upon reviewing and analyzing the requirements for interim relief (presupuestos cautelares), it was determined that the applicant has the necessary prima facie basis to bring this action in protection of its interests and rights. The requirement of likelihood of success on the merits (Apariencia de Buen Derecho) was therefore deemed satisfied, establishing that its claim—at least at this procedural stage—is neither frivolous nor lacking in seriousness and that, accordingly, it had sufficient grounds to appear before this Court. In addition, regarding costs in this type of proceeding, there are several rulings by the Tribunal de Apelaciones de lo Contencioso Administrativo which, until a different line of authority is established, lead this Court to consider that the foregoing ruling should be issued without an award of costs, precisely because of the nature of these proceedings. (See, among others, RESOLUCIÓN 009-TA-11, 010-TA-11. SENTENCIA Nº 90 -2011 bis TRIBUNAL DE APELACIONES DE LO CONTENCIOSO ADMINISTRATIVO Y CIVIL DE HACIENDA. Anexo A del Segundo Circuito Judicial de San José, Dirección01, at thirteen hours thirty minutes on March sixteenth, two thousand eleven). Accordingly, this matter is decided without any special award of costs.-
- X)DISPOSITION OF THE CASE: Therefore, because not all the necessary statutory requirements have been met, the requested interim relief must be denied as presented. It must be taken into consideration that both the requirement of likelihood of success on the merits and the balancing of the interests at stake (ponderación de intereses en Juego) are subject to analysis, verification, and examination by the Judge in order to verify compliance and determine whether the claim may be heard in an adjudicatory proceeding before this Jurisdiction (likelihood of success on the merits), and whether the determination made affects the public interest or the interests of third parties (balancing of the interests at stake). However, one of the requirements for granting interim relief rests with the party that brings this type of proceeding—risk arising from delay (PELIGRO EN LA DEMORA)—because proof of harm is inherently a matter for the person suffering it, who must substantiate the assertion with relevant and material evidence for that purpose (Article 41 of the Código Procesal Civil). It is precisely this requirement that was not supported and substantiated as was the plaintiff’s duty and obligation, and this Court has no reason to remedy the omissions identified in the corresponding section. As a logical consequence of this determination, the application for interim relief filed by the CÁMARA NACIONAL DE LA INDUSTRIA PALANGRERA against the INSTITUTO COSTARRICENSE DE PESCA Y ACUICULTURA (INCOPESCA) and the interested third party ORGANIZACIÓN GLOBAL FISHING WATCH is denied. This matter is decided without any special award of costs. The case file shall be closed and archived in due course.-
In accordance with the foregoing, the application for anticipatory interim relief (medida cautelar anticipada) filed by the CÁMARA NACIONAL DE LA INDUSTRIA PALANGRERA against the INSTITUTO COSTARRICENSE DE PESCA Y ACUICULTURA (INCOPESCA) and the interested third party ORGANIZACIÓN GLOBAL FISHING WATCH is denied. This matter is decided without any special award of costs. The case file shall be closed and archived in due course. NOTICE SHALL BE GIVEN. Lic. Rodrigo Huertas Durán. Judge.- *RRKTLDMOQP461* RODRIGO HUERTAS DURÁN - DECIDING JUDGE