CONSTITUTIONAL CHAMBER OF THE SUPREME COURT OF JUSTICE. San José, at nine hours twenty minutes on the twentieth of March two thousand twenty.
Amparo action filed by Marco Levy Vigo, of legal age, single, holder of identity card 7-069-314, in his capacity as President of the Asociación de Desarrollo para la Ecología, on behalf of the latter and the residents of the central canton; against Empresas Berthier EBI de Costa Rica S.A., the Minister of Environment and Energy, the Defensoría de los Habitantes, the Director of the Área Rectora de Salud de Limón, and the Mayor of Limón.
Whereas:
- 1By document received in the Secretariat of the Chamber at 14 hours 05 minutes on January 31, 2020, the petitioner filed an amparo action against Empresas Berthier EBI de Costa Rica S.A., the Minister of Environment and Energy, the Defensoría de los Habitantes, the Director of the Área Rectora de Salud de Limón, and the Mayor of Limón, and states that since the installation of a sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario) in El Tomatal, managed by the respondent company, the residents of Valle La Aurora have experienced the contamination of a drinking water spring (naciente). He accuses that water from the dump flows into the creek, causing contamination and foul odors. He adds that the cited spring (naciente) flows into the Río Limoncito, which is used by local residents for bathing and washing, and that, as a result, many people are suffering from allergies and, in addition, there are flies and mosquitoes. He clarifies that the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Santa Rosa reported the situation as of July 28, 2011; however, at the time of filing this amparo, the exposed problem remains latent and their efforts have not been resolved. He considers the fundamental rights of the community's residents to be harmed and therefore requests that the action be granted, with its consequences.
- 2Catalina Crespo Sancho, in her capacity as Defensora de los Habitantes de la República, reports under oath, in a document filed with the Secretariat of the Chamber on February 12, 2020, that the primary responsibility for addressing the situation raised in this amparo falls on the institutions of the active administration, given that the task entrusted to her represented office is related to the control of legality of the actions and omissions of those entities, meaning that the Defensoría is a supervisory body for the legality of public sector actions. She indicates that the resident submitted a document dated July 28, 2011, which does not contain a reference to a reporting person, but rather attaches a list of signatory persons without it being possible to identify each one of them; an address or means for notifications was also not provided; likewise, the claim of the interested person in relation to the intervention of the Defensoría was not specified, which is because the submitted document was a copy of a procedure addressed solely to MINAE as the governing body in environmental matters.She argues that, upon submission of the document, its analysis proceeded and, as it was not addressed to the Defensoría, it was archived. She contends that, such being the case, the Defensoría did not process any procedure or investigation regarding the document referred to by the petitioner because it did not meet the minimum requirements established by the legal system for the receipt of complaints and because it was a copy of a procedure filed directly with MINAE. She points out that, by virtue of this situation, the procedure submitted on September 7, 2011, as a copy, did not activate the Defensoría's investigation procedure, precisely because it did not contain a complaint that included an express and direct request to the Defensoría. Considering that no fundamental right has been harmed, they request that the action be dismissed.
- 3Patricia Campos Villagra, in her capacity as General Manager with powers of unlimited general representative of Empresas Berthier EBI de Costa Rica Sociedad Anónima, answers the hearing, in a document filed with the Secretariat of the Chamber on February 17, 2020, that her represented company has not installed nor has anything to do with any garbage dump (botadero de basura) in the community of El Tomatal. She adds that the petitioner refers to a dump, but her represented company is unaware if one existed in the area in 2011. She indicates that in the community of El Tomatal in Santa Rosa de Limón, her represented company is developing an engineering project known as Parque de Tecnología Ambiental de Limón, which is for environmental and public health protection and uses sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario) technology, which is endorsed by international organizations recognized in the field of public health and environmental protection, such as the WHO, PAHO, GTZ, among others.She warns that this project is not near or adjacent to any spring (naciente), and the only nearby surface water body is an unnamed creek, and it is into this creek that the water treated by the landfill's treatment system is discharged, having a discharge permit under file 4672-V from the Dirección de Aguas of MINAE. She warns that the project that EBI develops and operates has environmental viability (viabilidad ambiental), an operating permit from the Ministry of Health, a municipal business license, and a discharge permit. She indicates that, as part of its commitments and in compliance with current regulations, quality control is maintained for the wastewater treatment system, surface waters (creek), and groundwater; monthly, an external laboratory to the company, duly accredited and recognized by ECA and the Ministry of Health, takes samples, performs the respective laboratory analyses, and issues a report that serves as the basis for preparing the operational report of the treatment system that is submitted to the Ministry of Health.She argues that the laboratory analyses constitute an element that provides scientific certainty of the water quality and whether or not it complies with current regulations (reglamento de vertido y reuso de aguas residuales). She points out that 2011 was no exception, given that at the Limón sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario), the respective laboratory analyses were performed: at the discharge point of the treatment system, in the creek or receiving body of the treated effluent, for which a sample is taken 50 meters before and after the discharge point, and in the monitoring wells. She argues that, in this matter, the petitioner refers to the possible contamination of the unnamed creek, so it is important to know what the water quality in the creek was at the established monitoring points, that is, 50 meters before and after the discharge point. She points out that, upon conducting an objective review of the laboratory report, it can be observed that the water quality both upstream and downstream of the discharge point is practically the same, so the scientific certainty indicates that in 2011, and specifically at the date when the complaint was filed, problems such as those indicated by the petitioner were not being generated.She warns that the system, in 2011 and now in 2020, shows excellent efficiency in contaminant removal and delivers an effluent that is discharged into the creek, complying with the standard and, therefore, the petitioner is not correct, even less so when he has not provided any technical-scientific argument to support his assertions. Considering that the petitioner is not correct, she requests that the action be dismissed.
- 4Rolando Castro Córdoba, in his capacity as Acting Minister, and Cynthia Barzuna Gutiérrez, in her capacity as General Secretary of the Secretaría Nacional Ambiental, both from the Ministry of Environment and Energy (MINAE), report under oath, in documents filed with the Secretariat of the Chamber on February 17, 2020, that it is the responsibility of that Ministry, through the Dirección de Agua, to provide for and resolve matters concerning the domain, use, utilization, governance, or oversight of public-domain waters. They point out that, as reported by the representative of the Dirección de Aguas through document number DA-0285-2020 dated February 14, 2020, the sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario) located in Santa Rosa de Limón and managed by the company Bethier Ebi de Costa Rica S.A., has a discharge permit granted by that Directorate under administrative file 4672, and that, as of the date of that report, no complaint has been received from the petitioner or his represented association, as the discharge made by the company managing the sanitary landfill complies with the corresponding regulations.They point out that, for its part, in report number SETENA-SG-00266-2020 of February 17, 2020, signed by its General Secretary, it was indicated that this concerns file No. 242-2004-SETENA for the project “Relleno Sanitario de Limón El Tomatal”, located in the Province of Limón, whose current developer is Empresas Berthier EBI de Costa Rica S.A., and that in the evaluation process, the environmental impact assessment (Estudio de Impacto Ambiental, EIA) was established as the evaluation instrument, with environmental viability (viabilidad ambiental) granted through resolution No. 914-2008 at 8:00 a.m. on April 18, 2008, indicating that it involves the construction of a sanitary landfill with a capacity of 80 tons of garbage per day, on a 45-hectare farm, occupying 86,177 m²; the guarantee deposit was set at the sum of ¢7,300,000 (seven million three hundred thousand net colones); the appointment of the Environmental Manager with current registration in the SETENA Registry of Consultants was requested; a Logbook was required; and, based on the environmental characteristics of the Protected Area and its interaction with the project activities, the frequency for submitting environmental oversight reports (informes regenciales) to SETENA was established for periods of every 2 months during the construction phase and every 6 months during the Operational Phase.They add that, on the subject, it was also noted that as part of the project's mitigation measures, there is a Wastewater Treatment Plant, which is the technical means by which the leachates generated in the waste cells are treated, so the waters alleged to be discharged into the water body have been previously treated, and this has been planned for. In addition, they argue that the developer periodically submits the environmental oversight reports (informes de regencia ambiental) established by SETENA, and in the latest report, the results of the chemical analysis of the treated waters are indicated, showing that they comply with the values and parameters regulated and permitted for waters from Sanitary Landfill treatment systems according to Decreto 33601-S. They add that, from the same environmental oversight report (informe de regencia ambiental), the developer's actions to control vector problems generated by garbage, such as flies and insects, are evident, and they recall that the environmental impact assessment (evaluación de impacto ambiental) involves detecting and predicting negative impacts on the environment, and for each one, corresponding mitigation measures are established, which are monitored through the Environmental Management Plan, which must be followed up on through the Environmental Oversight reports (informes de Regencia Ambiental); additionally, regarding the Wastewater Treatment Plant, the developer's actions to control vector problems generated by garbage, such as flies, insects, odors, etc., are indicated and evident.They add that, according to the report from the Environmental Auditing and Monitoring Department SETENA-DT-ASA-164-3030, the project has the respective control and monitoring instruments duly established, and the developer has periodically submitted the environmental oversight reports (informes de regencia ambiental). They add that the project has the respective Control and Monitoring Instruments duly established, and the Developer has periodically submitted the environmental oversight reports (informes de regencia ambiental). They point out that the project, as part of the environmental measures, designed and built a Wastewater (leachate) Treatment Plant, which is in operation; it receives all leachates from the garbage cells and, through microorganisms and aeration, treats the water to levels permitted by sanitary legislation. Evidently, the treated water, at permitted levels, is discharged into the receiving water body approved by the Ministry of Health, so the water continuously observed falling into the water body has been previously treated and conditioned so as not to be an environmental problem.They add that in the latest environmental oversight report (informe de regencia) submitted by the developer, the report of results from the chemical analysis of the treated water, prepared by the company Aqylasa which is accredited by ECA, is shown. They contend that in the same report, it is observed that the treated water complies with the permitted values for the parameters regulated for waters from Sanitary Landfill treatment systems according to Decreto 33601-S. They add that the latest environmental oversight report (informe de regencia) shows the actions taken by the Developer to control vector problems naturally generated in garbage, such as flies, for which the developer applies techniques like the placement of flying insect traps. They add that, regarding odors, the developer mentions that they use the cover system, but it should be noted that the problem of odors depends on many factors, such as wind speed and direction; in the case of Limón, the humidity factor and temperature play a very important role in odor perception; another factor is when a truck unloads its waste content, which inevitably produces an odor emission, as the bags tend to break at that moment and the odor is released suddenly and strongly, but the effect generally passes or diminishes quickly as the material begins its compaction and covering work.They add that, as shown in the environmental oversight report (informe de regencia), individuals of fauna such as alligators and snakes have been found in one of the lagoons that make up the leachate treatment system, which is a good indicator of water quality, as these animals are natural indicators of quality. They indicate that no procedure, note, or document has been filed by the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Santa Rosa, so SETENA has not failed in its duty to provide a prompt and complete response. They add that, in general, good management of the sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario) is observed, and as part of environmental monitoring, an inspection visit to the project will be scheduled in the coming weeks by the Sanitary Landfill Commission, created within SETENA to verify compliance with the environmental commitments of operational sanitary landfill projects in the country.They add that the developer has submitted oversight reports (informes regenciales) prepared by the environmental manager, whose function is to ensure compliance with the environmental commitments undertaken by the activity, work, or project in accordance with the resolution that granted environmental viability (viabilidad ambiental); environmental mitigation measures were established for the project's negative impacts, and the developer complies with the control and monitoring instruments. They indicate that a field inspection will be scheduled for March 2020. Considering that fundamental rights have not been harmed, the amparo must be dismissed.
- 5Through a document filed with the Secretariat of the Chamber on February 18, 2020, the petitioner appears to reply to the response provided by the company Berthier EBI de Costa Rica Sociedad Anónima, and begins by reiterating his statements and initial arguments, emphasizing that on July 28, 2011, the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Santa Rosa, via a document duly signed by 145 residents of Valle de la Aurora, reported to the respondent agencies a case of contamination by leachates emanating from the sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario) of the company EBI, located in the central canton of Limón; a complaint which indicated that said leachates flow towards the Río Limoncito, endangering the lives and safety of the canton's general population. He considers that the respondent company tries to shield its inertia behind a series of procedural and administrative formalities and, on the alleged disinterest of those affected, by stating that approximately one calendar month was taken to act before the respondent state agencies, overlooking, first of all, that these are simple residents who do not have the logistical or intellectual resources to face the state indifference of institutions such as the Ministry of Environment and Energy, the Secretaría Técnica Nacional Ambiental, the Ministry of Health through the Área Rectora de Salud de Limón, and the Dirección de Aguas of MINAE, according to the discharge permit issued under file 4672-V of the Dirección de Aguas of MINAE.He adds that the procedural and administrative formalities in which EMPRESAS BERTHIER shields its defense are not entirely true, since, to begin with, it would make no sense for the Dirección de Aguas of MINAE to grant a discharge permit processed under file 4672-V if there were no spring (naciente) to protect; additionally, he begs to consider that the company submits follow-up reports subsequent to the cited discharge permit, which could be negligent. He adds that the municipal dump (botadero municipal) of which EMPRESAS BERTHIER boasts provides services to the Municipality of Limón, the Municipality of Matina, and the Municipality of Talamanca, and there is no evidence of the alleged endorsement by international organizations recognized in the field of public health protection. He adds that the so-called “unnamed creek” mentioned by the respondent representative of EMPRESAS BERTHIER flows directly into the Río Limoncito, crossing and supplying livestock farms that have allegedly been affected by the recurrent presence of leachates.He adds that the file contains the Police Observation Report dated September 27, 2012, carried out in “Valle de la Aurora, Santa Rosa, Limón, on a farm located 800 meters east of the School, composed of pastures,” where the officers from the Cantonal Delegation of Limón record the following: “On the farm made up of pastures, two dead cattle are located, one dark and one light colored, both in different places but at an approximate distance of 600 m from a watering hole in the creek that is observed to be amber in color; a trail or access path is also located where the cattle access to drink water” (End of literal citation). He adds that on September 28, 2012, another complaint was sent to the Head Office of the Instituto de Desarrollo Agrario located in Bataan, indicating in the relevant part the following: “We address you very respectfully, presenting an issue, since on Wednesday the 26th of this year, at about 4:00 in the afternoon, the people from the EBI dump (basurero), located in El Tomatal, released a very large amount of water, and it passes through the channels and creeks of the farms dedicated to livestock, leaving the only source of water possibly contaminated, for animal consumption, causing the death of 7 of them and leaving others intoxicated, so we request your support as this situation is not new to us, since since said dump (basurero) has been operating, the mentioned creek lost its life as all the fish and other animals that approached its banks disappeared.We have tried to resolve the problem by sending letters of complaint to the Ministry of Health, Defensoría de los Habitantes, Ministry of Environment and Energy.” He adds that the commitments of the current regulations to which the respondent representative of EMPRESAS BERTHIER refers do not include or cover the affected livestock farmers' farms, since these are private properties adjacent downstream of the sanitary landfill's (relleno sanitario) discharge point, which does not allow for certainty about the veracity of these controls, especially since they involve leachates. He adds that the organic matter present in municipal solid waste (MSW) degrades, forming a contaminating liquid, black in color and with a very penetrating odor called leachate; a liquid that carries all kinds of harmful substances: up to 200 different compounds have been found, some of them toxic and even carcinogenic; the moisture in the waste and rain are the two main factors that accelerate the generation of leachates.He adds that the adequate treatment of these toxic liquids must be a fundamental part of MSW management; if not properly controlled, leachates can contaminate soils and surface and groundwater (aquifers). He points out that, as it is a contaminating process that occurs slowly, its effects are usually not perceived until several years later. He adds that the adequate treatment of these toxic liquids must be a fundamental part of MSW management; if not properly controlled, leachates can contaminate soils and surface and groundwater (aquifers). He points out that, as it is a contaminating process that occurs slowly, its effects are usually not perceived until several years later. He adds that, for the laboratory analyses provided by the respondent to have scientific certainty of the water quality and whether or not it complies with current regulations (Reglamento de Vertido y Reúso de Aguas Residuales), they cannot be limited to the landfill area because, otherwise, an environmental crime could be being concealed, as, in his view, possibly occurs in the present case, Indubio Pro Natura.He argues that it is of the utmost importance for the processing and resolution of this matter to keep in mind that leachates are produced in sanitary landfills and are highly toxic; toxic because their substances cause and contribute to increased mortality, an increase in serious diseases of an irreversible nature. He recapitulates, saying that on July 28, 2011, the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Santa Rosa—which he represents—via a document duly signed by 145 residents of Valle de la Aurora, reported to the respondent agencies a case of contamination by leachates emanating from the sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario) operated by the company BERTHIER EBI COSTA RICA, located in the central canton of Limón (in El Tomatal). He adds that it was reported that said leachates flow towards the Río Limoncito, endangering the lives and safety of the canton's general population. He considers that the report from the General Manager of the respondent company does not contain reports from the Secretaría Técnica Nacional Ambiental (SETENA), nor does it contain the respective follow-up by the Dirección de Aguas of MINAE on the discharge permit (File 4672-V), despite it being a source of supply for the community's livestock farms and also flowing towards the Río Limoncito.He requests that the action be granted, and that by judgment, the authorities of the Secretaría Técnica Nacional Ambiental (SETENA) and the Ministry of Health, respectively, be ordered to inform the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Santa Rosa of the inspections and environmental oversight reports (reportes de regencia) that they must periodically carry out on the sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario) that is the subject of this amparo.
- 6Guiselle Lucas Bolívar, in her capacity as Director of the Área Rectora en Salud de Limón, reports under oath, in a document filed with the Secretariat of the Chamber on March 3, 2020, that on August 23, 2012, a confidential complaint was filed against EBI Relleno Sanitario, Santa Rosa, Tomatal entrance, 3 kilometers, which indicated: “They are not giving correct treatment to the water and leachates, and they throw everything into the channels that flow into the Río Santa Rosa.” She indicates that according to technical report HA-ARSL-07901-2012, it is stated that an inspection was carried out, observing an oxidation tank full of leachates (treatment of wastewater from the sanitary landfill—relleno sanitario), as well as 2 oxidation lagoons that are connected to the first lagoon, which receives the leachates, so that no water source is contaminated, and that the two oxidation lagoons are not full of leachates, so the complaint was considered addressed.She adds that through official communication HA-ARSL-08100-2012, the complainant was informed of the actions taken by that Ministry, and the complaint is considered addressed, proceeding to its closure and archiving. She points out that after that date, no new complaint has been filed by the citizen. She adds that the administrative file also contains official communication GT-40-2012 from the Technical Manager of EBI de Costa Rica, dated October 5, 2012, regarding the laboratory results of the physical-chemical and microbiological analyses carried out both in the oxidation lagoons and in the receiving water body, observing that the values do not exceed the maximum permitted parameters, so it is concluded that the company EBI, according to the water quality analyses submitted, complies with the provisions of current legislation. She adds that the quarterly operational report EBI, registered under #1778-12, was received by the Área de Salud de Limón, and according to technical report HA-ARSL-10321-2012, in response to request #1778-2012 regarding laboratory analyses performed by the company EBI, it indicated that the information provided was analyzed and it was observed that the samples taken from the receiving water body comply with the maximum permitted parameters in the Reglamento de Vertido y Reúso de Aguas Residuales, according to the parameters regulated by said decree.She states that, as reported in the Guía de Inspección de Rellenos Sanitarios Consecutivos #7146-2019, file number HC-ARS-L-2016-738, it indicates that the EBI establishment complies with said guide. She adds that in official communication MS-DRRSHC-ARSL-01217-2020, concerning the preparation of State Control Operational Reports EBI 2019 for the period from April 1, 2019, to January 31, 2020, it concludes that, having verified the submission of the reports for the corresponding period, the wastewater quality certification was prepared, which is found to be in order. She argues that it was only on January 29, 2020, that complaint #028-20 was filed before this Área Rectora de Salud against the company EBI, indicating the problem of contamination of the small stream that crosses the community, which was addressed as recorded in Technical Report MS-DRRSHC-ARSL-IT-01037-2020. She points out that on February 13, 2020, a site visit was conducted, with an ocular inspection from the locality of Valle La Aurora along the creek bank that is used for the discharge of the EBI sanitary landfill's treatment plant, and during the course of the journey to the sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario), the creek water was observed to be clear, with secondary trees along the route; no fish or other species living underwater were observed; the creek's flow at the discharge point is very minimal.She adds that the following February 14th, she went to the EBI sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario) located in Santa Rosa, and an ocular inspection was carried out, verifying that it has a valid sanitary operating permit, anti-tobacco signage, that fumigation is used for the control of noxious fauna using efficient microorganisms, EM 1 natural, with operational reports, including the state control one, within normal parameters, this being what is used to prevent contamination of water sources. She adds that in that inspection, it was verified that the leachate discharge goes to the treatment plant and not to another site. She adds that regarding the management of solid waste unloaded at the working area, it is transferred from there in an articulated tracked cart and deposited inside the current cell where it is compacted by heavy sheepsfoot roller machinery and subsequently covered, and that at that site a foul odor is indeed perceived due to the decomposition of organic matter; the stormwater has perimeter channels along the boundaries of the sanitary landfill (relleno sanitario) and discharges into the same creek; the wastewater has a septic tank and drain field for its final disposal, and the treatment plant has 3 aerators which were functioning at the time of the visit, for which reason the Area Directorate was informed of what was observed at the time of the inspection, and the support of regional engineering and a sanitary engineer from the central level was requested to carry out a comprehensive assessment of the condition presented by said landfill.
It argues that through official letter MS-DRRSHC-ARSL-01371-2020, the complainant was informed of the foregoing, and in official letter MS-DRRSHC-ARSL-01365-2020, the regional level was requested to seek support so that the sanitary engineer and the regional engineer could conduct an assessment visit to the landfill (relleno sanitario). It indicates that the new complaint filed will be followed up on and the complainant will be kept informed. It concludes by requesting that the recourse be declared without merit.
- 7In a document submitted to the Secretariat of the Chamber on March 4, 2020, the appellant appears to reply to the report of the Director of the Limón Health Area (Área Rectora de Salud de Limón) and points out that she has not demonstrated having fully addressed the complaint filed by the Santa Rosa Integral Development Association (Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Santa Rosa) on July 28, 2011, against the garbage disposal site for the cantons of Limón, Matina, and Talamanca, even though this matter is of the utmost importance for the resolution of this amparo. He points out that the procedural and administrative formalities behind which the respondent director shields her defense are not entirely true because they are not based on scientific and technical principles, and she does not provide as evidence analyses of the waters that flow from the dump (botadero) to the neighboring farms, which is illogical, since he considers that limiting oneself to the letter of the Sanitary Landfill Inspection Guide (Guía de Inspección de Rellenos Sanitarios) could be negligent because the environmental problems reported affect simple residents due to the discharge of leachate (lixiviados) onto neighboring farms, whose waters have been affected.He states that the alleged actions deployed by the Ministry of Health have never contemplated the environmental assessment of the so-called unnamed stream (quebrada sin nombre), which flows directly into the Limoncito River, crossing and supplying cattle farms that have allegedly been affected by the recurring presence of leachate, even causing the possible death of many livestock (semovientes). He indicates that in the police observation record (acta de observación policial) dated September 27, 2012, carried out in Valle de la Aurora, Santa Rosa, Limón, on a farm located 800 meters east of the School, composed of pastures, it was recorded that 2 dead cattle were located—one dark-colored and one light-colored—both in different places but at an approximate distance of 600 meters from a water trough (abrevadero) in a stream (quebrada) that is observed to be an amber color; also located is a trail or access path (bajadero) where the cattle access to drink water.He adds that in another complaint dated September 26, 2012, it was indicated that the people from the EBI dump (basurero), located in El Tomatal, dumped a very large amount of water that passes through the canals and streams of the farms dedicated to livestock, leaving the only source of water possibly contaminated for animal consumption, causing the death of 7 of them and leaving others intoxicated, for which reason support was requested since that dump has caused the stream to lose life, as all the fish and other animals that approached its banks disappeared, indicating that attempts have been made to resolve the problem by writing complaint letters to the Ministry of Health, the Ombudsman's Office (Defensoría de los Habitantes), and MINAE. He adds that the operational reports mentioned by the respondent director do not include or cover the farms of the affected cattle ranchers, since these are private properties, adjacent downstream from the landfill's discharge point, which does not allow certainty about the veracity of said controls, especially since leachate is involved.He considers that for the laboratory analyses provided by the respondent director to have scientific certainty about the water quality and whether or not it complies with current regulations (reglamento de vertido y reúso de aguas residuales), they cannot be limited to the area of the landfill, since otherwise an environmental crime could be concealed, as possibly occurs in this case in his opinion. He recaps by saying that on July 28, 2011, the Santa Rosa Integral Development Association, via a writing duly signed by 145 residents of Valle de la Aurora, denounced before the respondent director a case of contamination by leachate emanating from the landfill of the company BERTHIER EBI, located in the central canton of Limón; it being denounced that said leachate flows towards the Limoncito River, putting at risk the life and safety of residents in general, which continues to this day.
- 8Néstor Matis Williams, in his capacity as Proprietary Mayor (Alcalde Propietario) of the Municipality of Limón, reports under oath that his represented entity's competence in this matter has been reduced to granting the company EBI Berthier de Costa Rica the operating license (patente de funcionamiento) for the El Tomatal landfill, given that on June 15, 2009, the Municipal Council (Concejo Municipal) of the central canton of Limón approved the granting of the commercial license (patente comercial) for the El Tomatal landfill. He states that the municipality has not received any complaint from the petitioning Development Association that must be addressed regarding the contamination of a spring (naciente) due to poor disposal and treatment of waste from the El Tomatal landfill. He argues that they have also not received any request from the institutions sued in this matter, which should be addressed under the principle of administrative coordination, by his represented entity. He adds that there is no record that the contamination indicated in the amparo exists, nor that people bathe and wash in the Limoncito River; nor that the residents are sick due to the possible contamination. He concludes by requesting that the recourse be declared without merit.
- 9The appellant appears through a writing submitted to the Secretariat of the Chamber on March 11, 2019, to reply to the report rendered under oath by the Municipal Mayor of Limón and indicates that the residents of Santa Rosa initiated proceedings before various state entities, including the Ombudsman's Office (Defensoría de Los Habitantes) as well as the Public Force (Fuerza Pública), in order to stop the constant discharge of leachate into the waters of the Limoncito River, on which many residents depend for their affairs and for subsistence livestock farming. He adds that, faced with this serious situation, from the moment they became aware of these facts, actions were initiated in defense of their rights before the Municipality of Limón, the Ministry of Health, the Ombudsman's Office, and the Public Force, always seeking to resolve this situation and force the company BERTHIER EBI S.A. to carry out the necessary repairs to prevent the contamination of the water sources from continuing.He indicates that the magnitude of the damages is such that the Public Force prepared the “Police Observation Record” (Acta de observación policial) dated September 27, 2012, carried out in “Valle de la Aurora, Santa Rosa, Limón, on a farm located 800 meters east of the School, composed of pastures,” where it is recorded by the officers of the Cantonal Delegation of Limón that 2 dead cattle were located—one dark-colored and one light-colored—both in different places but at an approximate distance of 600 meters from a water trough in a stream that is observed to be an amber color; also located is a trail or access path where the cattle access to drink water. He adds that, at the time, the Department of Waters assessed the situation of the landfill and found anomalies that were inexplicably minimized by the Limón Health Area. He points out that the residents made different requests via telephone to the EBI Company and the Ministry of Health, represented by the Limón Health Area, one of which consisted of requesting that laboratory analyses be carried out at the landfill's discharge point into the Limoncito River in order to establish the level of contamination resulting from the leachate; a request that was not accepted by the Limón Health Area or the EBI company.He adds that in the final paragraph of the Report of the director of the Health Area, it states that the Environmental Sanitation Technician requested the intervention of the Engineering Unit of the Huetar Atlántica Region to proceed to verify the problems that gave rise to this amparo; however, he argues that there has also been no response from the health authorities. He indicates that the facts referred to in this amparo began in the year 2011 and to date there is no solution to the problem caused by the leachate emanating from the landfill of the company BERTHIER EBI, and the consequent violation of the fundamental rights of the residents of Valle de la Aurora, located in Santa Rosa of the central canton of Limón, continues. He points out that the aggrieved parties, on September 28, 2012, sent another complaint to the headquarters of the Institute of Agrarian Development (Instituto de Desarrollo Agrario) located in Bataan, indicating that the people from the EBI dump, located in El Tomatal, dumped a very large amount of water that passes through the canals and streams of the farms dedicated to livestock, leaving the only source of water possibly contaminated for animal consumption, causing the death of 7 of them and leaving others intoxicated, for which reason support was requested since that dump has caused the stream to lose life, as all the fish and other animals that approached its banks disappeared, indicating that attempts have been made to resolve the problem by writing complaint letters to the Ministry of Health, the Ombudsman's Office, and MINAE.He requests that the recourse be declared with merit and that, by judgment, the authorities of the National Environmental Technical Secretariat (Secretaría Técnica Nacional Ambiental, SETENA) and the Ministry of Health be ordered, respectively, to periodically inform the Santa Rosa Integral Development Association, during the operation of the questioned landfill, about the inspections and oversight reports (reportes de regencia) that they must carry out regarding the landfill that is the subject of this amparo.
- 10In the proceedings followed, the legal prescriptions have been observed.
Drafted by Magistrate Araya García; and,
Considering:
I.Object of the recourse. The appellant alleges that since the installation of a landfill in El Tomatal de Limón managed by the respondent company, the residents of Valle La Aurora have experienced the contamination of a water spring (naciente). He accuses that the waters coming from the dump (basurero) flow into the stream (quebrada), causing contamination and bad odors. He adds that the cited spring flows into the Limoncito River, which is used by the residents of the area for bathing and washing, and that, as a result, many people are suffering from allergies and, in addition, there are flies and mosquitoes (zancudos). He clarifies that the Santa Rosa Integral Development Association denounced the situation as of July 28, 2011; however, he points out that at the time of filing this amparo, the stated problem remains latent and their efforts have not been resolved. Considering fundamental rights harmed, he asks that the recourse be declared with merit, with its consequences.
II.Proven facts. Of importance for the decision in this matter, the following facts are deemed duly demonstrated:
- a)that by official letter dated July 28, 2011, delivered on September 7 next to the Ombudsman's Office (Defensoría de los Habitantes), the Limón Health Area, and the Ministry of Environment and Energy, as well as on December 1 next to the Municipality of Limón, several residents filed a complaint before those entities regarding the contamination they believe has been generated in the area since the installation of the El Tomatal landfill, requesting a solution to the matter (see reports rendered under oath and evidence provided to the electronic file);
- b)that the landfill located in Santa Rosa de Limón and managed by the company Bethier Ebi de Costa Rica S.A., has a discharge permit granted by the Directorate of Waters (Dirección de Aguas) of the Ministry of Environment and Energy in resolution number R-0450-2019-AGUAS-MINAE at 15 hours 14 minutes on May 8, 2019, under administrative file 4672 (see report rendered under oath by the representative of MINAE and evidence provided to the electronic file);
- c)that as of February 2020, no complaint had been received from the appellant or his represented party before MINAE or the Directorate of Waters or before SETENA (see report rendered under oath by the representative of MINAE);
- d)that in file No. 242-2004-SETENA for the project “Relleno Sanitario de Limón El Tomatal” located in the Province of Limón, whose developer is Empresas Berthier EBI de Costa Rica S.A., it was ordered that in the environmental impact assessment (evaluación de impacto ambiental) process, the Environmental Impact Study was set as the instrument, and environmental viability was granted through resolution No. 914-2008 at 8:00 a.m. on April 18, 2008, for the construction of a landfill with a capacity of 80 tons of garbage per day (see report rendered under oath by the representatives of MINAE and SETENA and evidence provided to the electronic file);
- e)that as part of the project's mitigation measures, there is a Wastewater Treatment Plant, which is in operation, which is the technical manner in which the leachate generated in the waste cells is treated, given that this plant receives all the leachate coming from the garbage cells and through microorganisms and aeration, the water is treated to levels permitted by sanitary legislation, which are then discharged into the receiving water body, so that those waters that fall onto the water body have been previously treated and conditioned so as not to be an environmental problem (see report rendered under oath by the authorities of MINAE and SETENA and evidence provided to the electronic file);
- f)that the developer of the treatment plant periodically submits the environmental oversight reports (informes de regencia ambiental) established by SETENA, with the reports indicating that the results of the chemical analysis of the treated waters comply with the regulated and permitted values and parameters for waters coming from Sanitary Landfill treatment systems (see report rendered under oath by the authorities of MINAE and SETENA and evidence provided to the electronic file);
- g)that the developer uses a coverage system for odor management, which depend on many factors such as wind speed and direction, and in Limón, the humidity factor and temperature play a very important role in the perception of odors, as also when a truck unloads its waste content, which inevitably produces an emission of odors (see report rendered under oath by the authorities of MINAE and SETENA);
- h)that in one of the lagoons that make up the leachate treatment system, fauna specimens such as alligators and snakes have been found, which is an indicator of water quality (see report rendered under oath by the authorities of MINAE and SETENA);
- i)that the Ministry of Health granted operating permit No. HC-ARS-L-2016-738 to Empresas Berthier EBI de Costa Rica S.A. for the final disposal of waste on the El Tomatal property, valid until December 20, 2021 (see evidence provided to the electronic file);
- j)that as part of the environmental monitoring, within the coming weeks of March 2020, an inspection visit to the project will be scheduled by the SETENA Sanitary Landfill Commission to verify compliance with environmental commitments of the landfill projects in operation in the country (see report rendered under oath by the authorities of MINAE and SETENA);
- k)that in the Limón Health Area, a complaint was filed in 2012 against EBI Sanitary Landfill, Santa Rosa, El Tomatal entrance 03 kilometers, which stated: “They are not providing correct treatment to the waters and leachate and they throw everything into the pipes that lead to the Santa Rosa River” (see report rendered under oath by the representative of the Limón Health Area);
- l)that according to technical report HA-ARSL-07901-2012, following the complaint, an inspection was carried out, observing an oxidation tank full of leachate (treatment of the landfill waters), as well as 2 oxidation lagoons that are connected to the first lagoon, which is the receiver of the leachate and thus no water source is contaminated, in addition to the fact that the physico-chemical and microbiological analyses carried out both in the oxidation lagoons and in the receiving water body indicated that the values do not exceed the maximum permissible parameters, so it was concluded that the EBI company, according to the water quality analyses presented, complies with the provisions of current legislation (see report rendered under oath by the representative of the Limón Health Area); ll) that through official letter HA-ARSL-08100-2012, the complainant was informed of the actions taken by that Ministry, the complaint was considered addressed, and it was closed and archived (see report rendered under oath by the representative of the Limón Health Area);
- m)that in official letter MS-DRRSHC-ARSL-01217-2020 regarding the Preparation of EBI State Control Operational Reports 2019 for the period April 1, 2019, to January 31, 2020, the wastewater quality certification for the environmental park was prepared, which is found to be compliant (see report rendered under oath by the representative of the Limón Health Area);
- n)that after that 2012 complaint, it was not until January 29, 2020, that complaint #028-20 against the EBI company was filed with the Limón Health Area, which indicates a contamination problem in the stream (riachuelo) that crosses the community, which was addressed as recorded in Technical Report MS-DRRSHC-ARSL-IT-01037-2020 (see report rendered under oath by the representative of the Limón Health Area);
- ñ)that on February 13, 2020, a site visit was conducted, with a visual inspection from the locality of Valle La Aurora, traveling along the edge of the stream (quebrada) that is used for the discharge from the EBI landfill treatment plant, and during the journey until reaching the landfill, the water of the stream was observed to be clear, with secondary trees along the way, no fish or other type of species living underwater were observed, and the flow (caudal) of the stream where the discharge is made is minimal (see report rendered under oath by the representative of the Limón Health Area);
- o)that on February 14 next, the visual inspection begun the previous day continued, but this time at the EBI landfill located in Santa Rosa, verifying that it has a valid sanitary operating permit, anti-tobacco signage, that fumigation is used for the control of harmful fauna, efficient microorganisms, EM 1 natural, with the operational reports, including the state control one, within normal parameters, this being what is available to prevent contamination of sources, also verifying that the leachate discharge goes to the treatment plant and not to another site (see report rendered under oath by the representative of the Limón Health Area);
- p)that in the inspection, it was also determined that the stormwater has perimeter channels along the boundaries of the landfill and discharges into the same stream, that the wastewater has a septic tank and drainage for its final disposal, and the treatment plant has 3 aerators which were working at the time of the visit, so the Area Directorate was informed, requesting support from regional engineering and the sanitary engineer from the central level to conduct a comprehensive assessment of the condition that said landfill presents (see report rendered under oath by the representative of the Limón Health Area);
- q)that through official letter MS-DRRSHC-ARSL-01371-2020, the complainant was informed about the inspection carried out, that the new complaint filed will be followed up on, and that he will be kept informed (see report rendered under oath by the representative of the Limón Health Area);
- r)that the Municipal Council of the central canton of Limón approved the granting of the commercial license for the El Tomatal landfill, which has been in force since 2009 (see report rendered under oath by the Municipal Mayor of Limón and evidence provided to the electronic file);
- s)that the Municipality of Limón has not received any complaint from the protected Development Association about the alleged contamination of a spring due to poor disposal and treatment of waste from the El Tomatal landfill, and that they have also not received any request from the sued institutions that should be addressed by the municipality under the principle of administrative coordination (see report rendered under oath by the Municipal Mayor of Limón); p) that the officials of the Municipality of Limón are not aware of the existence of contamination in the terms alleged in the amparo, nor that people bathe and wash in the Limoncito River, nor that the residents are sick due to the eventual contamination (see report rendered under oath by the Municipal Mayor of Limón).
III.On the merits. The appellants argue that the situation they denounce in this amparo has been brought to the attention of the respondent authorities for a long time—year 2011—but, as of the date of filing this amparo—January 31, 2020—, neither have forceful measures been adopted to eliminate the problems of bad odors and environmental contamination affecting the community of El Tomatal de Santa Rosa de Limón, nor has the complaint they filed in 2011, which they mention in the amparo, been responded to. From the reports rendered under oath and the evidence provided to the electronic file, the Chamber has been able to establish that the appellant is not correct in his claim because it is recorded that, since that complaint was filed in 2011 and 2012, the authorities that received it at the time proceeded to adopt the necessary measures to address it, conducted inspections at the site, and also responded to the residents regarding what had been consulted, as well as kept them informed of the actions being taken in relation to the “Relleno Sanitario de Limón El Tomatal” managed by the company Berthier EBI de Costa Rica S.A. The Chamber observes that, even though the appellant considers that said landfill has been failing to comply with environmental regulations and, in his view, has been contaminating the stream that passes through the area, the truth of the matter is that with the evidentiary elements contained in the file of this amparo, it can be established that he is not correct in his claim.
It is important to take into account that, to date, the garbage dump has all the necessary permits to operate: a sanitary operating permit issued by the Ministry of Health, a commercial license from the Municipality of Limón, a permit for the discharge of wastewater into the stream granted by the Directorate of Waters, as well as environmental viability granted by SETENA. It follows from the file that various visits and inspections have been carried out at the site by the competent respondent authorities, in which it has been verified that no irregularities exist, but in addition, the environmental oversight reports ordered by SETENA have shown that the results of the chemical analysis of the treated waters comply with the regulated and permitted values and parameters for waters coming from Sanitary Landfill treatment systems. Likewise, the physico-chemical and microbiological analyses carried out both in the oxidation lagoons and in the receiving water body—stream—have indicated that the values do not exceed the maximum permissible parameters, for which reason, as recorded in the file, it has long been concluded that the EBI company complies with the provisions of current legislation.
In addition to the foregoing, according to official letter MS-DRRSHC-ARSL-01217-2020 regarding the Preparation of EBI State Control Operational Reports 2019 for the period April 1, 2019, to January 31, 2020, the Ministry of Health prepared the wastewater quality certification for the dump subject to this amparo. More abundantly, the representatives of MINAE and SETENA have reported under oath that in one of the lagoons that make up the leachate treatment system of that dump, fauna specimens such as alligators and snakes have been found, which—according to their report—is a good indicator of water quality. It has been reported under oath that after those 2011 and 2012 complaints, no others had been filed, until January 29, 2020, when complaint #028-20 against the EBI company was filed with the Limón Health Area, indicating that there is a contamination problem in the stream that crosses the community.
It has been reported under oath that, on the occasion of that complaint, on February 13, 2020, a site visit was conducted, with a visual inspection from the locality of Valle La Aurora, traveling along the edge of the stream that is used for the discharge from the EBI landfill treatment plant, and the Chamber was informed that during the journey until reaching the landfill, the water of the stream was observed to be clear, with secondary trees along the way, and the flow of the stream where the discharge is made is minimal. It is recorded that said inspection continued on February 14 next, but this time it was conducted at the EBI landfill located in Santa Rosa, and according to what the respondent authorities reported, it was possible to verify that the landfill has a valid sanitary operating permit, anti-tobacco signage, that fumigation is used for the control of harmful fauna, efficient microorganisms, with the operational reports, including the state control one, within normal parameters, also verifying that the leachate discharge goes to the treatment plant and not to another site.
The respondent authorities also determined that the stormwater has perimeter channels along the boundaries of the landfill and discharges into the same stream, that the wastewater has a septic tank and drainage for its final disposal, and that the treatment plant has 3 aerators which were working at the time of the visit. It has been stated under oath that Technical Report MS-DRRSHC-ARSL-IT-01037-2020 was issued and that, in order to carry out a final comprehensive assessment of the condition in which that landfill is currently found, the Area Directorate was informed and support was requested from regional engineering and the sanitary engineer from the central level, for which purpose a visit to the site will be made again with those officials in the coming days. In addition to the foregoing, the authorities have also informed the Chamber that, through official letter MS-DRRSHC-ARSL-01371-2020, the complainant was informed about the inspection carried out and the results obtained, as well as that the new complaint filed will be followed up on and that he will be kept informed.
IV.Thus, the Chamber considers that, to date and with what is in the record, it cannot be considered that there has been any negligence or omission on the part of the respondent authorities in the attention and processing given to this matter, given that, contrary to the appellant's assertion, it has been demonstrated that concrete actions and measures have indeed been adopted to control and monitor the operation of the El Tomatal dump and the disposal of wastewater, as well as that the complainants—from 2011, 2012, and January 2020—have been duly informed of the processing given to their complaints and questions, without it having been demonstrated, from what is in the record, that any irregularity is occurring. For these reasons, even though the appellant intends for this Chamber to issue the orders of his interest to the respondent authorities or to the representatives of the company Berthier EBI, this is not possible because no harm or threat to the environment has been demonstrated in the terms claimed by the appellant. Consequently, since no inactivity or omission has been demonstrated on the part of the respondent authorities in relation to the facts denounced in the amparo, and since no irregularity has been accredited, what proceeds is to declare the recourse without merit, as is hereby ordered.
VI. DOCUMENTATION PROVIDED TO THE FILE
The parties are warned that if they have provided any paper document, as well as objects or evidence contained in any additional electronic, computer, magnetic, optical, telematic device or produced by new technologies, these must be withdrawn from the office within a maximum period of 30 business days counted from the notification of this judgment.
Otherwise, all material not removed within this period shall be destroyed, pursuant to the provisions of the "Reglamento sobre Expediente Electrónico ante el Poder Judicial", approved by the Corte Plena in session No. 27-11 of August 22, 2011, article XXVI and published in the Boletín Judicial number 19 of January 26, 2012, as well as in the agreement approved by the Consejo Superior del Poder Judicial, in session No. 43-12 held on May 3, 2012, article LXXXI.
Therefore:
The appeal is dismissed.- Fernando Castillo V.
President Paul Rueda L.
Nancy Hernández L.
Luis Fdo. Salazar A.
Jorge Araya G.
Anamari Garro V.
Ana María Picado B.
*SNAFU13NXOC61* EXPEDIENTE N° 20-002089-0007-CO Telephones: 2549-1500 / 800-SALA-4TA (800-7252-482). Fax: 2295-3712 / 2549-1633. Email: www.poder-judicial.go.cr/salaconstitucional. Address: (Sabana Sur, Calle Morenos, 100 mts.Sur de la iglesia del Perpetuo Socorro). Reception of matters from vulnerable groups: Edificio Corte Suprema de Justicia, San José, Distrito Catedral, Barrio González Lahmann, calles 19 y 21, avenidas 8 y 6 It is a faithful copy of the original - Taken from Nexus.PJ on: 08-05-2026 23:06:24.