Document Review CONSTITUTIONAL CHAMBER OF THE SUPREME COURT OF JUSTICE. San José, at nine hours thirty minutes on the twenty-second of May of two thousand twenty-six.
Amparo action processed under case file No. 26-011404-0007-CO, filed by [Nombre01], identity card CED01, against the COSTA RICAN TOURISM INSTITUTE.
WHEREAS:
- 1By brief added to the Chamber's digital case file at 17:38 hours on March 31, 2026, the petitioner files an amparo action against the Costa Rican Electricity Institute, and states that through judgment No. 2025035746 at 9:30 hours on October 31, 2025, this Constitutional Chamber ordered the ICT to conduct, within three months, a prior, free, and informed consultation of the Afro-descendant tribal people regarding the Caribbean Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of Costa Rica, an instrument covering more than 212 km of coastline and directly impacting ancestral Afro-descendant territories and the natural heritage of the State. He indicates that on March 17, 2026, he submitted communication MLV-0093-2026 to the Board of Directors of the ICT, requesting detailed official information on the status of compliance with the consultation, the legal validity of the actions taken (including that of March 24, 2026), copies of documents and communications, a copy of the Master Plan, and, especially, an exhaustive technical report on the State's natural heritage located within the Plan's area of influence. 3.On March 27, 2026, I received communication DET-026-2026 signed by the Director of Tourism Strategy, Antonio Farah Matarrita, in response to Board of Directors Agreement SJD-074-2026. Nevertheless, he claims that said response is evasive, tangential, and incomplete. Based on the arguments presented, he believes that fundamental rights are being violated by the accused actions. He requests that the action be granted with the legal consequences.
- 2Through the resolution at 15:24 hours on April 30, 2026, the Presidency of the Chamber allowed this process to proceed and granted a hearing to the executive president of the Costa Rican Tourism Institute regarding the facts alleged by the petitioner.
- 3By briefs incorporated into the digital case file on May 6, 2026, William Rodríguez López, in his capacity as executive president of the Costa Rican Tourism Institute, reports under oath the following: "I. Regarding communication MLV-0093-2026 and the right of petition. 1. Through communication MLV-0093-2026 dated March 17, 2026, Mr. [Nombre01] presented a request for public information to the Board of Directors of the Costa Rican Tourism Institute. 2. Through communication DET-026-2026 dated March 27, 2026, the Directorate of Tourism Strategy, by instruction of the Board of Directors, addressed all the inquiries made by Mr. [Nombre01] in communication MLV-0093-2026. 3. In response to the answers provided via communication DET-026-2026, Mr. [Nombre01] did not request that this Administration clarify or expand upon the answers provided. Despite having provided a specific response to each of the questions asked by Mr. [Nombre01], he argues that the response provided by the ICT violates his rights.In this regard, it must be noted that the petitioner does not indicate which documents were partially sent to him and did not submit a request for clarification or expansion of the requested answers. It is true that the petitioner was asked to cover the cost of printing the document, but it is far from the truth to state that he was not provided with real, accessible alternatives, since in DET-026-2026, he was sent the link where he could view the Master Plan digitally. The foregoing is in line with reiterated constitutional jurisprudence. See resolutions 14470-2023 and 19888-2025, issued by your authority. Regarding the technical report on the affected natural heritage, it must be stated that in communication MLV-0093-2026, the petitioner requested the following: 'e) A detailed and exhaustive technical report, prepared by the competent bodies of the Costa Rican Tourism Institute, on the Natural Heritage of the State located within the area of influence of the Caribbean Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of Costa Rica.Said report must accurately and currently identify all components of said heritage, including (but not limited to) Ramsar wetlands, national parks, biological reserves, wildlife refuges, protected areas, indigenous and Afro-descendant communities, sites of ecological interest, conservation areas, and any other environmental protection designation affected or included within the territorial scope of the Plan.' Through communication DET-026-2026, the petitioner was informed that: 'That such delimitation and identification, according to the Forest Law No. 7575, in its article 16, indicates that it is the duty of MINAE to delimit the boundaries of the areas that make up the Natural Heritage of the State, therefore, the preparation of the requested report falls outside the institutional competence, by provision of law.' It falls outside the institutional competencies of the Costa Rican Tourism Institute to provide technical reports on the Natural Heritage of the State located in a given territory, and the petitioner was so informed.Finally, he states that the institution denies agreements without further justification. In this regard, it must be stated that in communication MLV-0093-2026, the petitioner requested a complete copy of the cooperation agreement, authorization, or any legal instrument signed between the ICT and [Nombre02] for the implementation of the Tourism Master Plan on the territories that constitute the assets of JAPDEVA. In this regard, in communication DET-026-2026, he was informed that 'The requested agreement, authorization, or legal instrument does not exist.' The highlighting is ours. In the same vein, he requested a copy of each and every one of the agreements, cooperation agreements, memoranda of understanding, or any legal instrument signed by the ICT with the municipalities where it is intended to implement the Caribbean Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of Costa Rica. Said information request was addressed in communication DET-026-2026, where he was informed that 'The requested agreement, cooperation agreement, memoranda of understanding, or legal instrument does not exist.' The highlighting is ours.Despite the information request having been addressed, Mr. [Nombre01] states in the amparo action that 'Particularly serious and revealing of unacceptable administrative opacity is the ICT's response to the effect that "The agreement, authorization, or legal instrument" signed between the ICT and the Board of Port Administration and Economic Development of the Atlantic Slope (JAPDEVA) for the implementation of the Tourism Master Plan (literal b of the request) "does not exist." This denial is lapidary and is flatly contradicted by communication DPE-002-2026 dated January 27, 2026, signed by the Head of the Executive Presidency Office of JAPDEVA, Jose Lidier Azofeifa González, addressed to the undersigned, which states verbatim: "JAPDEVA does not have an agreement signed with the ICT related to the Caribbean Coastal Sector Master Plan. If information on the Caribbean Coastal Master Plan is required, you must contact the ICT directly."' The highlighting is original.The undersigned is unaware of communication DPE-002-2026; however, from what is indicated by the petitioner himself, it is confirmed that the information provided in communication DET-026-2026 is truthful and sufficient, since both [Nombre02] and this Administration told the petitioner that there is no signed agreement between both institutions related to the Costa Rican Caribbean Coastal Sector Master Plan. II. Regarding due process and effective prior consultation. In the second section, the petitioner merely states that, 'The assertion that the consultation of March 24, 2026, "is considered executed" does not analyze whether it complied with the standards of good faith, real representativeness of the Afro-descendant tribal people, sufficient information, and effective opportunity for influence, especially in light of the reasoning contained in resolution No. 2026005757.' The foregoing does not make it possible to determine a violation of a constitutional right amenable to protection through amparo.However, in accordance with the principle of good faith and transparency, your authority is informed that through amparo action processed under case file 25-028937-0007-CO, resolution No. 2025035746 was issued, ordering a consultation of the Afro-Descendant Tribal People (represented by the Integral Development Association of Cahuita) regarding the Caribbean Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan. Through communication DM-127-2026, your authority was informed of compliance with what was ordered in resolution No. 2025035746. Your authority ordered the report to be added to the record. III. Precautionary principle and protection of natural heritage (article 50 of the Political Constitution, Forest Law No. 7575, and constitutional jurisprudence): The petitioner indicates that denying the requested technical report prevents precisely identifying sensitive areas. He alleges that this violates the precautionary principle and creates a risk of irreparable damage to the environment and ancestral cultural heritage.As previously indicated, in observance of the powers granted by the Forest Law, through communication DET-026-2026, the petitioner was informed that the entity with the authority to prepare the requested technical report is MINAE. IV. Rights of a person in a condition of vulnerability. In point 4 of the amparo action, the petitioner merely states: 'As an older adult, a person with a disability, and a member of an Afro-descendant community with ancestral territories, I have the right to reinforced protection and that barriers to accessing information are not unreasonable or discriminatory.' Since no action or omission by the Costa Rican Tourism Institute is referred to, no report is provided in this regard."
- 4By brief incorporated into the digital case file on May 8, 2026, the petitioner refutes the report rendered by the respondent authority.
- 5The procedures followed have observed the legal requirements.
Drafted by Judge Salazar Alvarado; and,
WHEREAS:
I. PURPOSE OF THE ACTION
The petitioner alleges that, since March 17, 2026, he has requested information of interest from the respondent authority. However, as of the date of filing this action, he has not received a response.
II. PROVEN FACTS
The following facts, of importance for the resolution of this matter, are deemed duly proven:
- a)On March 17, 2026, the petitioner requested the following from the Board of Directors of the Costa Rican Tourism Institute: "In accordance with the recitals of the cited resolution and in exercise of my right of petition (article 27 of the Political Constitution), I respectfully request that, through a communication addressed to the undersigned, I be officially and detailedly informed of: 1. What is the current status of compliance with judgment No. 2025035746, particularly regarding the ordered prior consultation on the Tourism Master Plan. 2. Whether the actions taken to date (including the public call scheduled for March 24, 2026) constitute valid compliance with the constitutional vote, in light of the Chamber's reasoning in its resolution No. 2026005757. 3. Whether it is legally viable to execute any consultation process without the normatively regulated mechanism that guarantees collective due process. IV. Additionally, and in accordance with Law No. 9048 – Law on Access to Public Information (articles 4, 5, 6, and 13), I formally request: a) A complete and literal copy of each and every communication, official letter, email, minutes, note, public call, and procedure carried out by the Costa Rican Tourism Institute before the Integral Development Association of Cahuita (ADIC) and before the Afro-descendant Tribal Forum, in relation to the prior consultation process of the Caribbean Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of Costa Rica (including, but not limited to, communications DET-P-002-2026, DM-015-2026, DM-023-2026, DM-037-2026, and any other document exchanged from November 2025 to date). b) A complete copy of the cooperation agreement, authorization, or any legal instrument signed between the Costa Rican Tourism Institute and the Board of Port Administration and Economic Development of the Atlantic Slope (JAPDEVA) for the implementation of the Tourism Master Plan on the territories that constitute the assets of JAPDEVA. c) A complete copy of each and every one of the agreements, cooperation agreements, memoranda of understanding, or any legal instrument signed by the Costa Rican Tourism Institute with the municipalities through which it is intended to implement the Caribbean Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of Costa Rica (including, among others, the municipalities of Limón, Talamanca, Matina, Siquirres, Guácimo, and any other involved in the territorial scope of the plan). d) A complete printed copy of the official document of the Caribbean Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of Costa Rica, to be delivered to me personally at the regional offices of the Costa Rican Tourism Institute located in the city of Limón, during public service hours. e) A detailed and exhaustive technical report, prepared by the competent bodies of the Costa Rican Tourism Institute, on the Natural Heritage of the State located within the area of influence of the Caribbean Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of Costa Rica. Said report must accurately and currently identify all components of said heritage, including (but not limited to) Ramsar wetlands, national parks, biological reserves, wildlife refuges, protected areas, indigenous and Afro-descendant communities, sites of ecological interest, conservation areas, and any other environmental protection designation affected or included within the territorial scope of the Plan. Digital copies (if any) must be delivered in legible PDF format, and the printed copy of the Master Plan must be available for pickup at the Limón office within the legal term of ten business days established in article 13 of Law No. 9048, under warning of the sanctions provided in said law. V. Likewise, I request that I be formally considered as an interested party in this process and that I be previously notified of any procedure, communication, resolution, or administrative act carried out in relation to Case File No. 25-028937-0007-CO and with the execution of the ordered consultation, in order to guarantee my right of defense (articles 39 and 40 of the Political Constitution and 309 et seq. of the General Law of Public Administration)" (uncontested fact).
- b)On March 27, 2026, the respondent authority, through official letter No. DET-026-2026 signed by the Director of Tourism Strategy, replied to the appellant, stating: “The Directorate of Tourism Strategy of the Instituto Costarricense de Turismo, in response to the instructions given by the Board of Directors in Agreement SJD-074-2026, Ordinary In-Person Session No. 6366, SECTION I Generalities” Article 5, “General Management / Administrative Matters”, Subsection III, held on Monday, March 23, 2026, the following agreement was adopted, which textually reads: IT IS AGREED: To forward official letter No. MLV-0093-2026 signed by Mr. Nombre01 to the Directorate of Tourism Strategy, so that they proceed with its analysis and address the request as appropriate, within the framework of their competencies. That in relation to subsection III, the following inquiries are addressed: 1. What is the current status of compliance with judgment No. 2025035746, particularly regarding the prior consultation ordered on the Tourism Master Plan? The public consultation with the Afro-descendant Tribal People ordered in resolution No. 2025035746 was held on March 24, 2026, at 5:00 p.m. in the Cahuita Community Hall. Therefore, after having carried out the corresponding procedures on the day, time, and place of the event, the current status of compliance with what was ordered in judgment No. 2025035746 is considered to be: executed. 2. Whether the actions taken to date (including the call scheduled for March 24, 2026) constitute valid compliance with the constitutional ruling, in light of the Chamber's reasoning in its resolution No. 2026005757. The Instituto Costarricense de Turismo has fully complied with what was ordered by the Constitutional Chamber and this has been duly reported to it. 3. Whether it is legally viable to execute any consultation process without the normatively regulated mechanism that guarantees collective due process. Firstly, it must be noted that the fact that there is no normatively regulated consultation mechanism for a specific group does not, per se, imply that the consultation process does not guarantee collective due process. Note that, in the present matter, the consultation with the Afro-descendant Tribal People through the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Cahuita: (i) the Afro-descendant Tribal People were convened, through the ADI Cahuita, more than one month in advance, (ii) the agenda for the consultation was communicated with the call to the hearing, (iii) the document for consultation was delivered physically, (iv) the document for consultation was sent digitally, due to its size, and (v) the consultation was held in a physical space that allowed the attendance of all the members of the ADIC. With the foregoing, it is considered that the consultation carried out did guarantee the collective due process of the group to be consulted, as ordered by the Constitutional Chamber. That said, since the issuance of resolution 2025035746, briefs have been filed before the ICT and the Constitutional Chamber alleging that the consultation with the Afro-descendant Tribal People is improper until a mechanism for prior, free, and informed consultation applicable to the Afro-descendant tribal people is established at the legal level. In official letter DM-037-2026, signed by Mr. William Rodríguez López, in his capacity as Minister of Tourism, the Instituto Costarricense de Turismo informed the Constitutional Chamber of the legal basis under which it is considered that, in light of ILO Convention 169, it is viable to execute consultation processes without there being an established mechanism to consult a specific group. The basis for what is transcribed is Article 6 of ILO Convention 169 itself, which establishes: "1. In applying the provisions of this Convention, governments shall:
- a)Consult the peoples concerned, through appropriate procedures and in particular through their representative institutions, whenever consideration is being given to legislative or administrative measures which may affect them directly;
- b)establish means by which these peoples can freely participate, to at least the same extent as other sectors of the population, at all levels of decision-making in elective institutions and administrative and other bodies responsible for policies and programmes which concern them;
- c)establish means for the full development of these peoples' own institutions and initiatives, and in appropriate cases provide the resources necessary for this purpose. 2. (…)." The highlighting and underlining are our own. Therefore, it is considered viable to execute a consultation with a specific group, even if no special procedure applicable exclusively to said group exists, since Convention 169 itself establishes that governments shall establish the means by which the peoples concerned can freely participate, to at least the same extent as other sectors of the population. The consultation carried out with the Afro-descendant Tribal People through the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral took place under the same conditions as other sectors of the population, which is why it is considered valid in light of ILO Convention 169 and the Costa Rican legal system. That in relation to subsection IV, the following inquiries are addressed: a) A complete and literal copy of each and every communication, official letter, email, minute, note, call, and procedure carried out by the Instituto Costarricense de Turismo before the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Cahuita (ADIC) and before the Afro-descendant Tribal Forum, in relation to the prior consultation process for the Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of the Costa Rican Caribbean (including, but not limited to, official letters DET-P-002-2026, DM-015-2026, DM-023-2026, DM-037-2026 and any other document exchanged from November 2025 to date). The requested official letters, being the communications held with the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Cahuita, are attached to this communication. b) A complete copy of the cooperation agreement, authorization, or any legal instrument signed between the Instituto Costarricense de Turismo and the Junta de Administración Portuaria y Desarrollo Económico de la Vertiente Atlántica (JAPDEVA) for the implementation of the Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan on the territories that make up JAPDEVA's patrimony. The requested agreement, authorization, or legal instrument does not exist. c) A complete copy of each and every agreement, cooperation agreement, memorandum of understanding, or any legal instrument signed by the Instituto Costarricense de Turismo with the municipalities through which the Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of the Costa Rican Caribbean is intended to be implemented (including, among others, the municipalities of Limón, Talamanca, Matina, Siquirres, Guácimo, and any other involved in the territorial scope of the plan). No requested agreement, cooperation agreement, memorandum of understanding, or legal instrument exists. d) A complete printed copy of the official document of the Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of the Costa Rican Caribbean, to be delivered to me personally at the regional offices of the Instituto Costarricense de Turismo located in the city of Limón, during public service hours. In response to the request to be sent a physical copy of the official document of the Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of the Costa Rican Caribbean, I hereby inform you of the following: The document is extensive and contains a large number of renders or images of the proposed projects, which makes obtaining copies or printouts of it highly costly, as due to size and image quality issues, it cannot be printed or photocopied on institutional equipment. By virtue of the foregoing and, in observance of the right of petition, transparency, and good faith, the requested document is sent to you digitally at the following link: 260202_ICT Documento compilado completo_For Print.pdf. Should you wish to obtain it physically, you must cover the economic cost of the printing. The foregoing is based on Article 272 of the General Law of Public Administration and the jurisprudence of the Constitutional Chamber. Thus, in resolution 19888 – 2025, the constitutional body stated: "In response to the foregoing, this Court concludes that no violation of the fundamental right of access to information or of due process is established. While it is true that the municipal administration conditioned the delivery of physical or digital copies upon prior payment of the corresponding cost, it is no less true that such a requirement is neither unreasonable nor disproportionate, especially when the requested documentation is voluminous, its reproduction involves considerable operational costs, and the interested party himself maintained the possibility of reviewing and extracting the information by other more economical means, as was expressly indicated to him." The highlighting is our own. In resolution 14470-2023, the Chamber established that, if the petitioner requests the documentation in physical form, it is feasible that they must cover the cost of the copies, even when the person is a senior citizen. The Constitutional Chamber established that what is indeed unconstitutional is not giving the petitioner the option to cover the cost of the same and simply denying the request that the documentation be sent to them physically. In the cited resolution, the constitutional body established: "(…) c) the Secretariat of the Constitutional Chamber should have provided the requested material, upon prior fulfillment of the stipulated requirements and payment of the corresponding cost, in order to safeguard his right of access to justice, especially taking into account that he is a senior citizen aged 68 who asserted having no access to technological resources and; d) it is not recorded that the appellant was given the possibility of fulfilling the requirements for the issuance of the physical copies or writ of execution, as the only insistence was on providing him with a disk." In that matter, the Constitutional Chamber stated: "The appeal is granted. Mariane Castro Villalobos, in her capacity as Acting Secretary of the Constitutional Chamber, or whoever holds that position in her stead, is ordered to issue the orders within the scope of her competencies and coordinate what is necessary so that, within a maximum period of THREE DAYS, counted from the moment the protected party fulfills all the requirements established by infra-constitutional regulations for such purpose, a physical copy of the ruling issued in file No. 20-003869-0007-CO and a printed writ of execution (the cost of which must be covered by the petitioner himself) are delivered to the amparo petitioner." The highlighting is our own. Dissatisfied that the Constitutional Chamber ordered him to cover the cost of printing, the appellant filed a new petition before the constitutional body, stating: "The ruling given by the Honorable Chamber is granted, but indicates that I must pay the cost of the printed physical copies of the writ of execution. Copies. I have no economic means, I cannot do it. In other appeals, the Chamber has granted my request and ordered I be given printed copies immediately at no cost, and that is how the courts and the same respondent secretariat in San José have provided them to me." The highlighting is our own. In response to said petition, the Constitutional Chamber reiterated what was stated in resolution 14470-2023 and indicated: "On the other hand, it is necessary to indicate to the appellant that judgment No. 2023-014440 was clear in stating the following: "(…) within the maximum period of THREE DAYS, counted from the moment the protected party fulfills all the requirements established by infra-constitutional regulations for such purpose, a physical copy of the ruling issued in file No. 20-003869-0007-CO and a printed writ of execution (the cost of which must be covered by the petitioner himself) are delivered to the amparo petitioner"; from the foregoing, it is not recorded that he has fulfilled the requirements for this purpose. As such, the petition filed must be dismissed, as is hereby ordered." The highlighting is our own. It is considered that the Constitutional Chamber's jurisprudence has repeatedly established that requesting the petitioner to cover the cost of copies when requesting physical documentation does not violate the petitioner's right. Therefore, it is reiterated that, to proceed with the physical delivery of the Coastal Sector Master Plan document of the Costa Rican Caribbean, you must pay its cost, the amount of which is the sum of 533,360 colones (five hundred thirty-three thousand three hundred sixty colones). Said deposit must be made into the institutional accounts, the certifications of which are attached, and the Administration must be informed that the deposit was made, in order to proceed with the printing. The requested sum is based on a proforma invoice dated January 12, 2026, issued by the company Publiart for the printing of the Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan document of the Costa Rican Caribbean. e) A detailed and exhaustive technical report, prepared by the competent bodies of the Instituto Costarricense de Turismo, on the State Natural Heritage located within the area of influence of the Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of the Costa Rican Caribbean. Said report must accurately and currently identify all components of said heritage, including (but not limited to) Ramsar wetlands, national parks, biological reserves, wildlife refuges, protected zones, indigenous and Afro-descendant communities, sites of ecological interest, conservation areas, and any other environmental protection designation that is affected or included within the territorial scope of the Plan. Regarding your request for a technical report that accurately and currently identifies all components of the State Natural Heritage (Patrimonio Natural del Estado) within the area of influence of the Coastal Sector Master Plan of the Costa Rican Caribbean, I hereby inform you of the following: That said delimitation and identification, according to the Forest Law (Ley Forestal) No. 7575, in its Article 16, states that it is the duty of MINAE to delimit the boundaries of the areas that make up the State Natural Heritage, therefore, the preparation of the requested report falls outside the institutional competence, by legal provision. That in relation to subsection V, the following inquiry is addressed: Likewise, I request to be formally recognized as an interested party in this process and to be notified in advance of any procedure, communication, resolution, or administrative act carried out in relation to file No. 25-028937-0007-CO and with the execution of the ordered consultation, in order to guarantee my right of defense (articles 39 and 40 of the Political Constitution and 309 et seq. of the General Law of Public Administration). Resolution 2025035746 issued by the Constitutional Chamber ordered the Executive President of the Instituto Costarricense de Turismo to issue the orders within the scope of his competencies and coordinate what is necessary so that, within a maximum period of THREE MONTHS, counted from the notification of said judgment, a consultation be scheduled for the Afro-descendant tribal people (represented by the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Cahuita), related to the Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of the Costa Rican Caribbean, under the terms of Article 6 of ILO Convention 169. In strict adherence to the judicial resolution, all coordinations derived from said resolution have been coordinated directly with the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Cahuita. It is deemed improper to recognize you as an interested party in the execution of the ordered consultation, as this was not ordered by the Constitutional Chamber. However, you are informed that the consultation with the Afro-descendant Tribal People, through the Asociación de Desarrollo Integral de Cahuita, was scheduled for last Tuesday, March 24, in the Community Hall of said community. With the foregoing, the Instituto Costarricense de Turismo considers what was ordered in resolution 2025035746 to be fulfilled, unless a subsequent judicial resolution states otherwise. For the reasons set forth above, you are informed that there is no pending administrative procedure aimed at complying with resolution 2025035746 in which you can be recognized as an interested party” (see report rendered and evidence provided by the respondent authority).
- c)The resolution at 3:24 p.m. on April 30, 2026, which admitted this appeal, was notified to the respondent authority on May 4, 2026 (see notification record).
III. ON THE RIGHTS OF INFORMATION, PETITION, AND PROMPT RESPONSE
This Court has indicated that the right of petition and prompt response encompasses a dual aspect, since it implies not only the right held by every citizen to address any official or public entity, in order to present a matter of their interest, or to request specific information, but also obligates the Administration to receive and respond to them within a period of ten days, in accordance with Article 27 of the Political Constitution and numeral 32 of the Law of Constitutional Jurisdiction. Therefore, it must issue a timely response, without denial of any kind, however, the exception exists that it may be unable to fulfill the request within the referred period; consequently, it must communicate the impossibility of resolving and set a reasonable period within which it will attend to the request. For its part, Article 30 of the Political Constitution enshrines the right of individuals to access information of public interest held by the authorities and—consequently—the duty of the latter to provide said information immediately if what is requested is available, all of the foregoing without prejudice to the existence of possible exceptions in which information must be withheld in consideration of the protection of formally recognized relevant rights and interests.
IV. ON THE MERITS
In the case at hand, the appellant alleges that since March 17, 2026, he has requested information of his interest from the respondent authority. However, as of the date of filing this appeal, no response has been given.
In this regard, the respondent authority, in its report rendered under the solemnity of oath—with timely warning of the consequences, including criminal ones, provided for in Article 44 of the Law governing this Jurisdiction—assures that, on March 27, 2026, the response to what was requested was sent to the appellant. It adds that the amparo petitioner did not request clarification or expansion of the responses provided.
Having analyzed the factual framework presented, as well as the evidence on record, this Court considers that no injury has been caused to the fundamental rights of the appellant. As is evident from the list of proven facts, it was prior to the filing of this proceeding that the respondent authority sent official letter No. MLV-0093-2026 to the appellant. Therefore, it is necessary to clarify to the appellant that if he presents a disagreement with the response provided and the content of the documentation received, this does not imply, per se, a violation of his fundamental rights. Likewise, it is observed that within the request filed by the amparo petitioner, regarding petition “d) A complete printed copy of the official document of the Coastal Sector Tourism Master Plan of the Costa Rican Caribbean, to be delivered to me personally at the regional offices of the Instituto Costarricense de Turismo located in the city of Limón, during public service hours,” the respondent authority indicated to the appellant that “by virtue of the foregoing and, in observance of the right of petition, transparency, and good faith, the requested document is sent to you digitally at the following link: 260202_ICT Documento compilado completo_For Print.pdf.
Should you wish to obtain it physically, you must cover the economic cost of the printing. The foregoing is based on Article 272 of the General Law of Public Administration and the jurisprudence of the Constitutional Chamber.” As such, the present appeal must be dismissed in its entirety, as is hereby ordered.
V. DOCUMENTATION SUBMITTED TO THE FILE
This Chamber must warn the parties that, if any documents on paper have been submitted, as well as objects or evidence supported by any additional device, or by electronic, computer, magnetic, optical, telematic media, or those produced by new technologies, these must be collected from the office within a period of thirty working days after receiving notification of this judgment; otherwise, all of it will be destroyed in accordance with the provisions of the “Regulation on the Electronic File before the Judicial Branch” (Reglamento sobre Expediente Electrónico ante el Poder Judicial), approved by the Full Court in Session No. 27-11 of August 22, 2011, Article XXVI, and published in Judicial Bulletin No. 19 of January 26, 2012, as well as in the agreement approved by the Superior Council of the Judicial Branch, in Session No. 43-12 held on May 3, 2012, Article LXXXI.
THEREFORE:
The appeal is denied.- Fernando Castillo V.
President Fernando Cruz C.
Paul Rueda L.
Luis Fdo. Salazar A.
Jorge Araya G.
Anamari Garro V.
Ingrid Hess H.
Document Digitally Signed FILE No. 26-011404-0007-CO Telephones: Telf01/ ALA-4TA (Telf02). Fax: Telf03 / Telf04. Electronic address: www.poder-judicial.go.cr/salaconstitucional. Address: (Dirección01, Dirección02, 100 mts. South of the Perpetuo Socorro church).