← Environmental Law Center← Centro de Derecho Ambiental
Res. 28062-2022 Sala Constitucional · Sala Constitucional · 25/11/2022
OutcomeResultado
The Constitutional Chamber denied the amparo appeal as no imminent risk to the life, health, or physical integrity of specific persons was demonstrated, nor were vulnerable populations individualized.La Sala Constitucional declaró sin lugar el recurso de amparo por no acreditarse un riesgo inminente para la vida, salud o integridad física de personas concretas, ni individualizarse población en estado de vulnerabilidad.
SummaryResumen
The Constitutional Chamber denied an amparo action that sought to compel the District Municipal Council of Cóbano to build storm drainage infrastructure to prevent flooding in Santa Teresa. The Chamber found that the petition did not identify specific affected individuals in a state of vulnerability nor demonstrate imminent risk to the life, health, or physical integrity of concrete persons. The petitioner generically alleged violation of the right to a healthy environment and private property. The Chamber reiterated its precedent that for an environmental amparo to succeed for storm drainage works, there must be a manifest danger to the health or life of specific individuals; abstract allegations are insufficient. Consequently, the lack of a municipal response in itself did not constitute administrative delay warranting constitutional intervention, and claims for property damage or infrastructure design must be brought in the ordinary contentious-administrative jurisdiction.La Sala Constitucional rechazó un recurso de amparo que pretendía obligar al Concejo Municipal de Distrito de Cóbano a construir infraestructura pluvial para evitar inundaciones en Santa Teresa. La Sala consideró que en la solicitud no se individualizaron personas afectadas en estado de vulnerabilidad ni se acreditó un riesgo inminente para la vida, salud o integridad física de individuos concretos. El recurrente alegó genéricamente violación del derecho a un ambiente sano y a la propiedad privada. La Sala reiteró su jurisprudencia en el sentido de que para que prospere un amparo ambiental por obras de infraestructura pluvial es necesario demostrar un peligro manifiesto para la salud o la vida de personas determinadas, no bastando alegaciones abstractas. Por tanto, la falta de respuesta municipal en sí misma no constituía una mora administrativa que justificara la intervención constitucional, y los reclamos sobre daños a la propiedad o diseño de obras deben ventilarse en la vía contencioso-administrativa ordinaria.
Key excerptExtracto clave
From this perspective, in the terms in which the appeal was filed, any situation that at this time warrants the Chamber's intervention is ruled out. In the first place, what the petitioner seeks is the construction of storm drainage infrastructure to prevent flooding in a specific area; however, neither in this amparo appeal nor in the petition filed before the District Municipal Council of Cóbano did he identify the persons allegedly harmed; furthermore, he did not individualize situations of population in a state of vulnerability, nor did he set forth the magnitude of the alleged harm. Likewise, the petitioner did not allege effects on public health nor develop concrete situations of imminent risk to the physical integrity, life, or health of persons, but rather the only thing mentioned, in a general and abstract manner, was the alleged violation of the rights to a healthy environment and private property. Thus, the alleged failure to decide does not constitute an exception that this Court has jurisprudentially accepted in matters of administrative delay and, therefore, such claim must be raised, if he sees fit, in the contentious-administrative jurisdiction through an amparo de legalidad. Similarly, if the petitioner seeks the construction of storm drainage infrastructure (in the general terms in which he filed the petition), he may present his claims in the ordinary administrative or jurisdictional avenue so that in a full proceeding his position may be subjected to contradiction and he may submit the evidence he deems pertinent. For the reasons set forth, the appeal is declared without merit.Desde este panorama, en los términos en los que fue planteado el recurso, se descarta alguna situación que, en este momento, amerite la intervención de la Sala. En primer lugar, lo pretendido por el accionante es la construcción de infraestructura pluvial para evitar inundaciones en una zona determinada; empero, ni en este recurso de amparo ni en la gestión planteada ante el Concejo Municipal de Distrito de Cóbano identificó a las personas presuntamente perjudicadas; además, tampoco individualizó situaciones de población en estado de vulnerabilidad, ni expuso la magnitud de la supuesta afectación. De igual forma, el accionante no alegó afectaciones a la salud pública ni desarrolló situaciones concretas de riesgo inminente para la integridad física, vida o salud de las personas, sino que lo único que se mencionó, de forma general y abstracta, fue la presunta violación de los derechos a un ambiente sano y la propiedad privada. Así, la acusada falta de resolución alegada no constituye una excepción de las que este Tribunal ha aceptado jurisprudencialmente en materia de mora administrativa y, por ello, tal reclamo deberá plantearlo si a bien lo tiene en la jurisdicción contencioso administrativa por medio del amparo de legalidad. De igual forma, si el accionante pretende la construcción de infraestructura pluvial (en los términos generales en los que interpuso la solicitud) podrá formular sus alegatos en la vía administrativa o jurisdiccional ordinaria a fin de que en un cauce pleno se someta a contradictorio su posición y aporte la prueba que estime pertinente. Por las consideraciones expuestas, se declara sin lugar el recurso.
Pull quotesCitas destacadas
"no consta que la vida, salud o integridad física de alguna persona se encuentre en peligro manifiesto ante la situación expuesta por la amparada, ni tampoco que alguna persona en condición de vulnerabilidad hubiese resultado afectada."
"it does not appear that the life, health, or physical integrity of any person is in manifest danger due to the situation described by the petitioner, nor that any person in a condition of vulnerability has been affected."
Considerando IV (citando sentencia 2021-021928)
"no consta que la vida, salud o integridad física de alguna persona se encuentre en peligro manifiesto ante la situación expuesta por la amparada, ni tampoco que alguna persona en condición de vulnerabilidad hubiese resultado afectada."
Considerando IV (citando sentencia 2021-021928)
"Al respecto, no se observa que se haya alegado que la integridad física, la vida o la salud de alguna persona se encuentre en peligro inminente."
"In this regard, it is not observed that it has been alleged that the physical integrity, life, or health of any person is in imminent danger."
Considerando IV (citando sentencia 2021-000204)
"Al respecto, no se observa que se haya alegado que la integridad física, la vida o la salud de alguna persona se encuentre en peligro inminente."
Considerando IV (citando sentencia 2021-000204)
"Así, la acusada falta de resolución alegada no constituye una excepción de las que este Tribunal ha aceptado jurisprudencialmente en materia de mora administrativa y, por ello, tal reclamo deberá plantearlo si a bien lo tiene en la jurisdicción contencioso administrativa por medio del amparo de legalidad."
"Thus, the alleged failure to decide does not constitute an exception that this Court has jurisprudentially accepted in matters of administrative delay and, therefore, such claim must be raised, if he sees fit, in the contentious-administrative jurisdiction through an amparo de legalidad."
Considerando IV
"Así, la acusada falta de resolución alegada no constituye una excepción de las que este Tribunal ha aceptado jurisprudencialmente en materia de mora administrativa y, por ello, tal reclamo deberá plantearlo si a bien lo tiene en la jurisdicción contencioso administrativa por medio del amparo de legalidad."
Considerando IV
Full documentDocumento completo
SALA CONSTITUCIONAL DE LA CORTE SUPREMA DE JUSTICIA. San José, at nine hours twenty minutes of the twenty-fifth of November of two thousand twenty-two.
An amparo action processed in case file number 22-023814-0007-CO, filed by [Name 001], identity card [Value 001], against the CONCEJO MUNICIPAL DE DISTRITO DE CÓBANO.
Resultando:
Drafted by Magistrate Salazar Murillo; and,
Considerando:
Although in the admission resolution of this proceeding a report should have been requested from the intendente of the Concejo Municipal de Distrito de Cóbano, the truth is that the case file contains sufficient elements to resolve the action without needing to expand the parties. Likewise, in relation to the allegations of the president of the municipal council referring to legal representation and the notification made to him, due to the manner in which this proceeding is resolved, any situation of defenselessness that, at this time, merits a pronouncement by this Chamber is dismissed.
The petitioner states that on August 4, 2022, he filed a petition before the Concejo Municipal de Distrito de Cóbano, in which he requested the construction of a stormwater infrastructure in the area located between Costa Riki Apartments, Calle Casita, and Restaurante Muzza; however, he claims that he still has not received a response nor have the works been started. He mentions that he did the foregoing in defense of a healthy and ecologically balanced environment, as well as private property, since such infrastructure is necessary to address flooding in the area.
Deemed important for the decision of this matter, the following facts are considered duly proven:
In the sub lite, the petitioner states that on August 4, 2022, he filed a petition before the Concejo Municipal de Distrito de Cóbano, in which he requested the construction of a stormwater infrastructure in the area located between Costa Riki Apartments, Calle Casita, and Restaurante Muzza; however, he claims that he still has not received a response nor have the works been started. He mentions that he did the foregoing in defense of a healthy and ecologically balanced environment, as well as private property, since such infrastructure is necessary to address flooding in the area.
From the study of the case file record, it is considered proven that on August 4, 2022, the claimant sent an email to the following addresses plataforma1@municobano.go.cr and rlobo@municobano.go.cr, to which he attached a brief with the following content: “The undersigned (sic), [Name 001], of legal age, attorney, single, identity card number [Value 001], resident of Playa Santa Teresa, Cóbano, acting on behalf of i) [Name 005], residence card number [Value 003], ii) [Name 006], residence card number [Value 004], iii) [Name 007], residence card number [Value 005], iv) [Name 008], identity card number [Value 006], v) [Name 009], residence card number [Value 007], vi) [Name 010], passport number [Value 008], vii) [Name 011], passport number [Value 009], viii) [Name 012], residence card number [Value 010], ix) [Name 013], residence card number [Value 011], x), [Name 014], passport number [Value 012] and xi) [Name 015], passport number [Value 013], all of them residents of the area of Playa Santa Teresa, Cóbano, I hereby state the following: The Concejo Municipal de Cóbano must immediately construct the stormwater infrastructure for the area located between Costa Riki Apartments, Calle Casita, and Restaurante Muzza, based on articles 29 and following of the Ley de Jurisdicción Constitucional and articles 21, 27, 30, 41, 45, and 50 of the Political Constitution of Costa Rica, especially the fundamental right to a healthy and ecologically balanced environment and the protection of private property, which are affected by the omission to construct the necessary infrastructure to address flooding.
(See attached videos) Regarding the obligation to construct stormwater infrastructure that exists for this Concejo Municipal, vote number 2008-13622 of eleven hours and twenty-two minutes of September fifth, two thousand eight, by the Sala Constitucional is cited, which establishes the following: V.- ON MUNICIPAL OBLIGATIONS REGARDING STORM SEWERS. Pursuant to the provisions of article 169 of the Political Constitution, the administration of local interests and services in each canton corresponds to the municipalities. From this derives the competence of the municipalities to plan and oversee the urban development of their locality. This includes the duty to establish a comprehensive urban planning policy that guarantees urban development congruent with the efficient operation of a system for providing potable water and for the collection, treatment, and final disposal of residual waters.
As well as the obligation to adopt the measures required to provide the canton with an adequate sewage system, in order to guarantee its inhabitants the right to health and an environment free from contamination. Regarding the specific topic of municipal obligations concerning storm sewers, in judgment number 2008-04210 of 13:59 hours of March 14, 2008, this Chamber resolved: (…) This Tribunal, in reiterated jurisprudence, has recognized that the right to enjoy a healthy and ecologically balanced environment is a fundamental right derived from Article 50 of the Constitution, according to which, it not only enshrines the right of every citizen to enjoy a healthy and ecologically balanced environment, but also obliges the State to guarantee the exercise of this right, through the means established for this purpose by current legislation. Specifically, as this Chamber has stated in judgment number 2005-009900 of ten hours of July twenty-ninth, two thousand five, the Municipality must construct the necessary infrastructure to properly channel waters … build the necessary infrastructure to properly channel the waters, in order to guarantee the right to health and to an environment free of contamination and without harming third parties: “V.- On municipal obligations regarding storm drainage (alcantarillado pluvial).- It is convenient to consider that Article 169 of the Political Constitution establishes that the administration of local interests and services in each canton shall be the responsibility of the Municipal Government.
Local interests and services have been defined by the Chamber (S.) as indeterminate legal concepts where the law does not precisely resolve their content for application to specific cases, so it is necessary to resort to criteria of value and experience, on the part of whoever must apply it, to determine its content. The creation of adequate drainage means within a community for the purpose of not causing damage to property, health, or environmental problems to its neighbors is, within the terms indicated by the Political Constitution, of interest to the canton and is part of the services that the Municipality (M.) is obligated to provide. In this same sense, the General Health Law (Ley General de Salud) in its Article 285 establishes that stormwater (aguas pluviales) must be eliminated adequately and sanitarily in order to avoid soil contamination and contamination of natural water sources for human use and consumption, the formation of vector breeding sites and diseases, and air contamination through conditions that threaten its purity and quality.
For this reason, the M. of G., is obligated to assume a certain behavior for the satisfaction of its purposes, taking the required measures to provide the protected community with an efficient stormwater drainage system. Adjusted to criteria of reasonableness, the M. must build the necessary infrastructure to properly channel those waters, in order to guarantee the right to health and to an environment free of contamination and without harming third parties. As is evident from the foregoing, competence in matters of storm drainage is established, expressly and implicitly, by ordinary legislation. Although the current Municipal Code does not establish any specific provision regarding this matter, the Chamber has declared, in judgment number 2002-08696 of ten hours fourteen minutes of the sixth of September of two thousand two, that this does not exclude the obligation of the entities to develop, among other community works, that related to adequate aqueduct and sewerage systems.
Indeed, Article 4 subsection c) of the current Municipal Code establishes in general terms, as a municipal attribution, the administration and provision of municipal public services, within which, without a doubt, the sewerage system (sistema de alcantarillado) is found.” Therefore, the Municipal Council of Cóbano must immediately carry out the construction of the storm drainage infrastructure (infraestructura pluvial) in the area located between Costa Riki Apartments, Calle Casita and Restaurante Muzza; otherwise, due to violation of the constitutional rights of articles 27, 30, 41, 45 and 50 of the Political Constitution of Costa Rica, we will appear before the Constitutional Chamber (Sala Constitucional) of the Supreme Court of Justice, to thus assert these rights. I designate the email address wbrenes@elawf.com for receiving notifications.” On October 21, 2022, the coordinator of the Department of Urban Development of the District Municipal Council of Cóbano, from the address mjimenez@municobano.go.cr, sent to the email ingenieriavial@municobano.go.cr (with a copy to wbrenes@elawf.com), the following communication: “(…) I acknowledge receipt of your request and by this same means I transfer it to the Road Engineering Department (Departamento de Ingeniería Vial) as the entity in charge of the road infrastructure area so that it proceeds to provide a response to the request of Mr. [Name 001].” The official Franklin Obregón Zamora, engineer of the Road Department of the District Municipal Council of Cóbano, by official letter no. INGV-303-2022 of October 26, 2022, addressed to the mayor (intendente), stated: “SUBJECT: CONSULTATION ROUTE C6-01-001, SANTA TERESA STORM DRAINAGE Dear Sir: By this means I allow myself to respond regarding the Administrative petition, by Mr. [Name 001], of legal age, lawyer, single, identity card number [Value 001], acting on behalf of i) [Name 005], residence card number [Value 003], ii) [Name 006], residence card number [Value 004], iii) [Name 007], residence card number [Value 005], iv) [Name 008], identity card number [Value 006], v) [Name 009], residence card number [Value 007], vi) [Name 010], passport number [Value 008], vii) [Name 011], passport number [Value 009], viii) [Name 012], residence card number [Value 010], ix) [Name 013], residence card number [Value 011], x), [Name 014], passport number [Value 012] and xi) [Name 015], passport number [Value 013], residents of Playa Santa Teresa, Cóbano, regarding the construction of storm drainage (alcantarillado pluvial), therefore I allow myself to state the following: 1.
Currently, the design of the storm drainage on district route C6-01-001 is under review, which goes from chainage 0+000 at Quebrada Carmen to the final chainage 2+000 in front of La Lora Amarilla. And the finalized design exists for the section from Cruce de Playa Carmen to Quebrada Carmen, prepared by GYZ, MOPT. 2. Previously, the topographic survey, contour lines, was carried out to define the slopes of the pipes, manholes (pozos) and catch basins (tragantes). In addition to the hydraulic study to define pipe diameters. 3. Once the design is defined and completed, one can proceed with the overall budget for the construction cost of said structures. 4. Furthermore, a consultation must be made to SETENA, if environmental feasibility (viabilidad ambiental) is required, also to AYA, ICE regarding possible affectation during the construction of the storm drainage. 5. Procedure before the Federated College of Engineers and Architects of Costa Rica (Colegio Federado de Ingenieros y Arquitectos de Costa Rica).
(…) Currently, needs inventories have been carried out to provide a solution to the storm drainage problem on Route C6-01-001, from Cruce Playa Carmen to Santa Teresa. This entails hours of work to obtain a good result, without neglecting relevant aspects in the storm drainage design of that locality. This storm drain covers part of the section that goes from Hotel Selina to Restaurante Muzzo, where the residents of this sector request its construction. (…) With this design process, we hope by mid-next year 2023, to continue with contracting a natural or legal person, with technical, legal and financial capacity to carry out the maintenance and improvement works of the mentioned section. This storm drainage will solve stormwater runoff (escorrentía pluvial) problems in the Santa Teresa sector, which year after year is affected by urban growth. Therefore, it is important to carry out the Hydraulic and hydrological study to determine the hydraulic capacity and the required diameter of the pipe to install to provide a storm drainage solution.
In every project, a stormwater amortization or retention system (sistema de amortiguamiento o retención de aguas pluviales) must be implemented within the development, according to the design guidelines and parameters, if necessary. If this project is part of or a stage of another larger project where a total amortization system has already been considered, it will only be necessary to present the endorsement of the stormwater discharge (aval de desfogue pluvial) from that larger or total project towards the coastal zone. The basic hydrology study and calculation report will have the objective: i.- Demonstrating that the watercourse (cauce) where the stormwater would finally discharge possesses sufficient carrying capacity to accept an increase in surface flow. ii. Demonstrating that said watercourse does not represent a potential flood risk factor. iii. The study and calculation report must determine the capacity of the infrastructure including the runoff contribution once built, without mitigation measures (delay or amortization system), incorporating cumulative effects upstream, as well as the necessary complementary works, if required, for the appropriate operation of the storm drainage system.
To evaluate the hydraulic capacity of the storm drainage, it will be the responsibility of the developer to carry out a field survey of the system that will receive the project’s waters, up to the receiving body. In the event that the storm drainage does not possess the required hydraulic capacity to receive the generated surface runoff, the developer must manage or propose the additional works necessary to comply with the capacity and proper functioning of the works, and all associated costs and permits. iv. Sizing and calculation report of an amortization or retention system, if necessary. To determine the carrying capacity of the watercourse, the control point or gauging station of the micro-watershed shall be assigned as the town, neighborhood or civil work (bridge or culvert (alcantarilla de paso)) adjacent to the main watercourse, most susceptible to changes in the fluvial regime. To comply with this, the criterion of the professional responsible for the study shall prevail.
The increase in surface runoff of the micro-watershed at the control point or gauging station may never be greater than 10%. The hydraulic model of the watercourse must contemplate the following parameters: i.- The design flow at the control point must be calculated for a maximum flood associated with a return period of 25 years. For watersheds smaller than 1 km2, the use of the empirical rational equation method is permitted; for larger watersheds, more closely related methodologies shall be used. ii. The model starts from the topographic survey of cross-sections in the following manner: cross-sections every 20 meters, starting 100 meters upstream of the discharge structure, and 100 meters downstream. The topographic survey and study must be carried out using a total station, by a surveyor registered with the Federated College of Engineers and Architects, who must sign the corresponding report and plan. iii.
To stipulate the extension of each cross-section, the professional's criterion shall prevail, in such a way as to guarantee that the hydraulic model contains the required area. iv. Manning's coefficient must be consistent with the actual site conditions, both of the riverbed and the banks (taludes). v. Within the modeling, existing works must be incorporated, such as: bridges, culverts, among others. vi. For the analysis of hydraulic transport and carrying capacity of the watercourse in the evaluated section, it is recommended to use computational programs such as the HEC-RAS hydraulic calculation program developed by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. This program models the behavior of rivers, based on their topography and the boundary conditions imposed. vi. (Current modified) For the analysis of hydraulic transport and carrying capacity of the watercourse in the evaluated section, it is recommended to use computational programs such as the HEC-RAS hydraulic calculation program developed by the U.S.
Army Corps of Engineers, or a similar or superior one, that models the behavior of rivers, based on their topography and the boundary conditions imposed. vii. In the case of discharge to the fluvial network at sites cataloged as "Potential Flood Hazard" (Amenaza Potencial de Inundación) by the National Emergency Commission (Comisión Nacional de Emergencias) in the Maps of Potential Natural Hazards, the hydrological study and hydraulic model must be executed for a 50-year return period. Finally, the entire process described above, is what it entails and more for the design of a storm drainage, in an area affected by mountain stormwater runoff to the flat areas near the coast, which depend on rain intensity, topography, soil type and return period.” On October 26, 2022, the official Franklin Obregón Zamora, engineer of the Road Department of the District Municipal Council of Cóbano, sent to the address wbrenes@elawf.com, the following email: “Subject: Administrative petition Stormwater Infrastructure-Municipality of Cóbano Good morning Lic; [Name 001] Attached official letter INGV-303-2022, in response to your petition.” From this perspective, in the terms in which the appeal (recurso) was filed, any situation that, at this moment, warrants the intervention of the Chamber is dismissed.
In the first place, what the claimant seeks is the construction of stormwater infrastructure to prevent flooding in a specific area; however, neither in this amparo appeal (recurso de amparo) nor in the petition filed before the District Municipal Council of Cóbano did he identify the allegedly affected persons; furthermore, he also did not specify situations of a population in a state of vulnerability, nor did he expose the magnitude of the alleged affectation. Likewise, the claimant did not allege impacts to public health nor develop specific situations of imminent risk to the physical integrity, life or health of persons, but rather the only thing mentioned, in a general and abstract manner, was the alleged violation of the rights to a healthy environment and private property.
In relation to the above, the Chamber, through judgment 2021021928 of 9:50 a.m. on October 1, 2021 (Castillo, Rueda, Salazar, Araya, Garro, Esquivel and Fernández A), stated:
“From this perspective, in the terms in which the appeal was filed, any situation that, at this moment and due to its magnitude, warrants the intervention of the Chamber is dismissed. In that sense, it is not recorded that the life, health or physical integrity of any person is in manifest danger given the situation presented by the protected party (amparada), nor that any person in a condition of vulnerability has been affected. Likewise, it was not proven that, after the works carried out by the local government to address the problem, the affectation of specific population in a condition of vulnerability, or any risk situation for the life, health or physical integrity of specific persons, had been formally reported to the Municipality of Santa Bárbara.” In addition, this Court, in resolution 2021000204 of 9:15 a.m. on January 8, 2021 (Castillo, Rueda, Hernández L, Araya, Garro, Hernández G and Esquivel), ordered:
“Regarding the matter, from reading the filing brief, no situation is evident that warrants the intervention of the Chamber. In this regard, it is not observed that it has been alleged that the physical integrity, life or health of any person is in imminent danger. Although the appellant's dwelling is located in a landslide zone, it is no less true that it was declared uninhabitable with the consequence of permanent eviction and he himself acknowledged that he is residing in another place, so a priori any risk to his person is dismissed. Note that the appellant's dissatisfaction lies in an alleged poor channeling of stormwater and in the lack of work by the Municipality on a ditch (acequia) that passes through his property, which deteriorates it and prevents him from rebuilding there.
Precisely, as no serious danger situation is verified, determining aspects such as the state of the property, the damages suffered, and the causal link of what occurred, constitute legality aspects that must be aired in the ordinary administrative or jurisdictional channel, where the parties may subject their position to adversarial proceedings and evacuate the evidence they deem appropriate. Hence, if the appellant considers that what happened to his property is the responsibility of the municipality, or if he considers that the local government must place a specific type of drain in the ditch that allows him to rebuild on that property, he may raise such allegations in the ordinary channel.
For the considerations stated, the appeal is declared without merit (sin lugar).” Thus, the alleged lack of resolution alleged does not constitute an exception of those that this Court has jurisprudentially accepted in matters of administrative delay (mora administrativa) and, therefore, such a claim must be raised, if he deems it appropriate, in the contentious-administrative jurisdiction (jurisdicción contencioso administrativa) through the amparo de legalidad. Likewise, if the claimant seeks the construction of stormwater infrastructure (in the general terms in which he filed the request) he may formulate his allegations in the ordinary administrative or jurisdictional channel so that in a full proceeding his position is subjected to adversarial proceedings and he provides the evidence he deems pertinent.
For the considerations stated, the appeal is declared without merit.
The parties are warned that if they have provided any paper document, as well as objects or evidence contained in any electronic, computer, magnetic, optical, telematic device or produced by new technologies, these must be removed from the office within a maximum period of 30 business days counted from the notification of this judgment. It is warned that all material not removed within this period will be destroyed, according to the provisions of the "Regulation on Electronic Files before the Judicial Branch" (Reglamento sobre Expediente Electrónico ante el Poder Judicial), approved by the Full Court (Corte Plena) in Article XXVI of session no. 27-11 of August 22, 2011, published in Judicial Bulletin (Boletín Judicial) no. 19 of January 26, 2012, as well as in the agreement of the Superior Council of the Judicial Branch (Consejo Superior del Poder Judicial), approved in Article LXXXI of session no. 43-12 held on May 3, 2012.
Therefore (Por tanto):
The appeal is declared without merit.
Fernando Castillo V.
Fernando Cruz C.
Jorge Araya G.
Anamari Garro V.
Ronald Salazar Murillo Fernando Enrique Lara G.
Jose Roberto Garita N.
*AZNDKBNZV5S61* FILE No. 22-023814-0007-CO Telephones: 2549-1500 / 800-SALA-4TA (800-7252-482). Fax: 2295-3712 / 2549-1633. Electronic address: www.poder-judicial.go.cr/salaconstitucional. Address: (Sabana Sur, Calle Morenos, 100 mts.Sur de la iglesia del Perpetuo Socorro). Reception of matters of vulnerable groups: Edificio Corte Suprema de Justicia, San José, Distrito Catedral, Barrio González Lahmann, calles 19 y 21, avenidas 8 y 6 Is a faithful copy of the original - Taken from Nexus.PJ on: 08-05-2026 17:20:03.
Sentencia con datos protegidos, de conformidad con la normativa vigente *220238140007CO* SALA CONSTITUCIONAL DE LA CORTE SUPREMA DE JUSTICIA. San José, a las nueve horas veinte minutos del veinticinco de noviembre de dos mil veintidos .
Recurso de amparo que se tramita en expediente número 22-023814-0007-CO , interpuesto por [Nombre 001], cédula de identidad [Valor 001] , contra el CONCEJO MUNICIPAL DE DISTRITO DE CÓBANO.
Resultando:
Redacta el Magistrado Salazar Murillo ; y,
Considerando:
Si bien en la resolución de curso de este proceso se tuvo que haber solicitado informe al intendente del Concejo Municipal de Distrito de Cóbano, lo cierto es que en el expediente constan suficientes elementos para resolver el recurso sin necesidad de ampliar las partes. Asimismo, en relación con los alegatos del presidente del concejo municipal referidos a la representación legal y la notificación que se le hizo, por la forma en que se resuelve este proceso se descarta alguna situación de indefensión que, en este momento, amerite el pronunciamiento de esta Sala. II.-OBJETO DEL RECURSO. El recurrente manifiesta que el 4 de agosto de 2022 planteó una gestión ante el Concejo Municipal de Distrito de Cóbano, en la cual solicitó la construcción de una infraestructura pluvial en la zona ubicada entre Costa Riki Apartments, Calle Casita y Restaurante Muzza; sin embargo, reclama que aún no ha recibido respuesta ni se han iniciado las obras. Menciona lo anterior lo hizo en defensa de un ambienta sano y ecológicamente equilibrado, así como de la propiedad privada, toda vez tal infraestructura es necesaria para atender inundaciones en la zona. III.-HECHOS PROBADOS. De importancia para la decisión de este asunto, se estiman como debidamente demostrados los siguientes hechos:
Por tanto:
Se declara sin lugar el recurso.
Fernando Castillo V.
Fernando Cruz C.
Jorge Araya G.
Anamari Garro V.
Ronald Salazar Murillo Fernando Enrique Lara G.
Jose Roberto Garita N.
*AZNDKBNZV5S61* EXPEDIENTE N° 22-023814-0007-CO
Document not found. Documento no encontrado.