← Environmental Law Center← Centro de Derecho Ambiental
Res. 06130-2018 Sala Constitucional · Sala Constitucional · 19/04/2018
OutcomeResultado
The amparo against the Constitutional Chamber itself was dismissed on the merits, after finding no undue delay in processing the environmental amparos or in addressing the requested precautionary measures.Se rechazó por el fondo el amparo interpuesto contra la propia Sala Constitucional, al determinarse que no hubo dilación indebida en la tramitación de los amparos ambientales ni en la atención de las medidas cautelares solicitadas.
SummaryResumen
The petitioner filed an amparo against the Constitutional Chamber, alleging violation of the right to a speedy and complete justice due to delays in resolving two prior amparo actions (case files 16-012693-0007-CO and 16-017833-0007-CO) that sought to halt the construction of the University of Costa Rica's School of Dentistry on Finca 3 on environmental grounds, and due to lack of resolution of requests for precautionary measures. The Constitutional Chamber, composed of substitute magistrates following the recusal of its regular members, examined the procedural timeline and found no undue delay: the main amparo was resolved in approximately fourteen months, a reasonable period given the accumulation of cases and the matter's complexity. Regarding precautionary measures, it was shown that the initial request was partially granted on the day of admission, ordering the suspension of tree felling, and that notification was timely upon resumption of University activities. The amparo was dismissed on the merits.La recurrente interpuso un recurso de amparo contra la Sala Constitucional alegando violación al derecho a una justicia pronta y cumplida, por la demora en resolver dos recursos de amparo previos (expedientes 16-012693-0007-CO y 16-017833-0007-CO), que buscaban detener la construcción de la Facultad de Odontología de la Universidad de Costa Rica en Finca 3 por presuntos daños ambientales, y por la falta de resolución de solicitudes de medidas cautelares. La Sala Constitucional, integrada por magistrados suplentes debido a la inhibición de sus miembros titulares, analizó la cronología procesal y concluyó que no existió dilación indebida: el amparo principal fue resuelto en aproximadamente catorce meses, plazo razonable dada la acumulación de expedientes y la complejidad del asunto. En cuanto a las medidas cautelares, se acreditó que la solicitud inicial fue atendida parcialmente el mismo día de la admisión, ordenando suspender la tala de árboles, y que la notificación se realizó oportunamente al reanudarse labores en la Universidad. Se rechazó el amparo por el fondo.
Key excerptExtracto clave
III.- SPECIFIC CASE. Based on the proven facts in the preceding consideration, this Court finds that the time elapsed was not excessive or unreasonable for the processing and resolution of amparo No. 16-012693-0007-CO. Two additional amparos were consolidated into that proceeding —Nos. 16-017833-0007-CO and 17-001702-0007-CO— with all the documentation submitted and the need to analyze the arguments raised therein. [...] IV.- REGARDING PRECAUTIONARY MEASURES. [...] The Court finds that the petitioner's requests were addressed.III.- CASO CONCRETO. Con base en los hechos probados del considerando anterior, este Tribunal aprecia que el plazo transcurrido no resultó excesivo o irrazonable para la tramitación y resolución del recurso de amparo No. 16-012693-0007-CO. A dicho proceso se le acumularon dos amparos más -No. 16-017833-0007-CO y No. 17-001702-0007-CO- con toda la documentación aportada a estos y la necesidad de analizar los alegatos ahí planteados. [...] IV.- SOBRE LAS MEDIDAS CAUTELARES. [...] El Tribunal aprecia que las gestiones de la parte recurrente fueron atendidas.
Pull quotesCitas destacadas
"este Tribunal aprecia que el plazo transcurrido no resultó excesivo o irrazonable para la tramitación y resolución del recurso de amparo No. 16-012693-0007-CO."
"this Court finds that the time elapsed was not excessive or unreasonable for the processing and resolution of amparo No. 16-012693-0007-CO."
Considerando III
"este Tribunal aprecia que el plazo transcurrido no resultó excesivo o irrazonable para la tramitación y resolución del recurso de amparo No. 16-012693-0007-CO."
Considerando III
"no existió una dilación indebida en la tramitación del proceso, por lo que se impone desestimar el recurso en cuanto a este extremo."
"there was no undue delay in the processing of the case, so the motion must be dismissed on this point."
Considerando III
"no existió una dilación indebida en la tramitación del proceso, por lo que se impone desestimar el recurso en cuanto a este extremo."
Considerando III
"El Tribunal aprecia que las gestiones de la parte recurrente fueron atendidas."
"The Court finds that the petitioner's requests were addressed."
Considerando IV
"El Tribunal aprecia que las gestiones de la parte recurrente fueron atendidas."
Considerando IV
Full documentDocumento completo
CONSTITUTIONAL CHAMBER OF THE SUPREME COURT OF JUSTICE. San José, at ten hours thirty minutes on the nineteenth of April of two thousand eighteen.
Amparo action filed by [Name 001], of legal age, identity card number [Valor 001]; against THE CONSTITUTIONAL CHAMBER OF THE SUPREME COURT OF JUSTICE.
RESULTANDO:
Drafted by Magistrate Rueda Leal and,
CONSIDERANDO:
The petitioner alleges a violation of her fundamental rights due to the lack of resolution of amparo actions No. 16-012693-0007-CO and No. 16-017833-0007-CO, as well as the requests for precautionary measures formulated in those proceedings.
Of importance for the decision in this matter, the Court considers it appropriate to refer to the various actions carried out in amparo actions No. 16-012693-0007-CO, No. 16-017833-0007-CO, and No. 17-001702-0007-CO. According to information from the Judicial Desks Management Computer System, the following is recorded:
Based on the proven facts of the preceding considerando, this Court finds that the elapsed time was not excessive or unreasonable for the processing and resolution of amparo action No. 16-012693-0007-CO. Two more amparos were joined to that proceeding –No. 16-017833-0007-CO and No. 17-001702-0007-CO– with all the documentation provided therein and the need to analyze the allegations raised there. The processing ruling of amparo 16-012693-0007-CO identified the University of Costa Rica and the National Environmental Technical Secretariat as respondent authorities. Subsequently, the Investigative Magistrate included the Municipality of Montes de Oca as another respondent authority, which was required to report on the facts alleged in the amparo. From the last petition received in the case file –October 9, 2017– until the Chamber declared, by majority, the action without merit –November 10, 2017–, one month elapsed. In this Court's opinion, there was no undue delay in the processing of the proceeding, so the action must be dismissed on this point.
The petitioner claims a violation of her fundamental rights due to the lack of processing of a request for precautionary measures to prevent the felling of trees and the construction of the odontology building of the University of Costa Rica. In this regard, the Court finds that the petitioner, in the filing brief for amparo action No. 16-0017833-0007-CO –December 16, 2016– requested “as an urgent precautionary measure the immediate prohibition of continuing with the project, thus preventing the start of the construction works of the Faculty of Odontology on the so-called Finca 3, and the possible felling of the trees.” The request was accepted in the ruling that ordered the processing of that amparo –on December 21, 2016– which ordered “to suspend the felling of the trees referred to in this amparo action, located in the sports facilities or Finca 3 of the University of Costa Rica, until the Chamber resolves the action in a judgment, or orders otherwise.” Subsequently, the petitioner –briefs of December 25, 26, and 28, 2016– alleged disobedience by the University of Costa Rica to the precautionary measure granted; requested that the precautionary measures be expanded; and requested notification to the University of Costa Rica of the precautionary measures ordered by this Chamber in the processing ruling of December 21, 2016.
The processing ruling for amparo No. 16-017833-0007-CO was notified to the Rector of the University of Costa Rica on January 11, 2017. The Rector of the University of Costa Rica, when submitting his report, specified that: “5. Closure of facilities from December 16 to January 9. The aforementioned closure was not done to carry out preliminary works and tree cutting as mentioned, but rather this was the institutional recess period. The company could begin the enclosures and preliminary works because the project had been awarded and such activities could be carried out during that recess period. Regarding the felling of trees before the year-end holidays, this decision is based on the fact that the certification of origin was received the week before Christmas. It should be noted that the UCR had not received any official notification from the Constitutional Chamber indicating precautionary measures while an amparo action filed by some neighbors of Finca 3 is being evaluated, given that the institution was in a recess period.
However, the Rector, Dr. Henning Jensen, received a copy of the precautionary measures ordered by the Constitutional Chamber from a neighbor. Immediately thereafter, and despite not having any formal document, the Rector ordered the tree cutting to stop until the situation is clarified” (highlighting not from the original).
By virtue of the foregoing, this Court finds that the petitioner requested, from the filing brief, as a precautionary measure, “the immediate prohibition of continuing with the project”; in the same terms as the one formulated on December 26, 2016. However, the Presidency of the Court, in the processing ruling, only ordered, as a precautionary measure, “to suspend the felling of trees.” As for the brief of December 25, 2016, in which the petitioner alleges disobedience by the authorities of the University of Costa Rica to the mentioned precautionary measure, as of that date the processing ruling had not been notified to the University of Costa Rica; notification occurred on January 11, 2017, thus addressing the brief of December 28, 2016. The Court finds that the petitioner's petitions were addressed. Likewise, the Chamber, in judgment No. 2017-07957, at 09:20 a.m. on November 10, 2017, ordered the following:
“VI.- Regarding the alleged omission to request tree felling permits. In the sub judice, the petitioners allege that the authorities of the University of Costa Rica omitted to request the respective felling permits and ordered the felling of 74 trees of different species in the project area for the construction of the Faculty of Odontology, thereby neglecting the right to a healthy and ecologically balanced environment. However, from the report submitted by the authorities of the National Environmental Technical Secretariat and the evidence brought to the case file, this Chamber considers that the petitioners' allegations are unfounded. The foregoing, because, as was accredited, although SETENA is not responsible for granting the tree felling permit, nor is this a requirement for granting environmental viability (viabilidad ambiental), the truth is that, regarding tree cutting matters, SETENA's function is focused on guaranteeing, through the environmental impact assessment (evaluación de impacto ambiental), that compensatory measures are established, as defined by Executive Decree No. 32966-MINAE, for those irrecoverable or unavoidable impacts, which manage to somehow counteract the alteration that may be caused.
Thus, in the documentation provided by the University of Costa Rica to said Secretariat, there is the ‘Manual for Repopulating Trees on Fincas of the Rodrigo Facio University Campus,’ within which the manner in which the University will proceed to completely reforest the trees that had to be cut down to develop the project is established. Additionally, this Chamber was able to verify that the University of Costa Rica has taken sufficient precautionary and compensatory measures in relation to the tree felling issue, since the Environmental Impact Study states that two trees will be planted for every tree felled; furthermore, specialists in the field were hired to carry out the relocation of trees such as mahogany and bitter cedar, which could not be felled due to their species, and which were planted in other areas of the campus. It could also be verified that, at this moment, the University has already started the first planting stage on Finca 3 and intends to reforest 17,180 m2; additionally, there is a campaign to reforest 195 native trees as an action for the established compensation.
Likewise, it is on record, in accordance with official communication RNVS-ACCVC-005 of February 3, 2015, that the Municipality of Montes de Oca established that there is no forest within the properties where the University of Costa Rica is located, and they affirm that in areas with that characteristic, tree felling is permitted without the respective permit. Consequently, this Chamber does not consider that, in relation to this point, the fundamental rights claimed by the petitioners have been violated in any way, since it could not be verified that any permit was required to carry out the denounced action, and furthermore, it could be verified that the necessary measures have been taken to avoid a strong and irreversible impact on the environment. Additionally, determining which permit must be obtained to carry out a specific activity is a matter that it is not within the competence of this Constitutional Court to decide, for which reason, if the petitioners consider that, in the specific case, there was some omission regarding this issue, they must report it, if they deem it appropriate, before the corresponding ordinary jurisdiction.” […]
“IX.- Regarding the disagreement with the issuance of the land-use certificate (certificado de uso de suelo) and construction permits. The petitioners consider that the authorities of the Municipality of Montes de Oca granted land-use and construction permits for the Faculty of Odontology that is part of the project called 'Proyectos Varios UCR Sede Rodrigo Facio', without complying with the requirements set forth in the current regulations and, specifically, the required requisites, without taking into account that the canton of Montes de Oca has an environmental fragility zoning map, prepared by PRUGAM, and precisely, 60% of the construction coincides with zone II-G of ‘high environmental fragility’ and 20% in a zone II-G of ‘very high environmental fragility,’ which can cause a significant impact on the place. In this regard, although the authorities of the respondent municipality indicate that the PRUGAM initiative failed and that no standard was established through it that could be used at the GAM level, so that, having the environmental viability granted by SETENA, there was no impediment at the municipal level to provide the questioned permits.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, it is important to clarify to the petitioners that the analysis of the aspects claimed, in part, of a strictly technical nature, would imply ignoring the summary nature of the amparo, turning into an ordinary proceeding a process that seeks the protection and restitution of violated fundamental rights, and, on the other hand, claims regarding compliance with legality requirements for the granting of construction and land-use permits, in accordance with current legislation, is a matter of ordinary legality that must be resolved in that jurisdiction. Therefore, they must raise, if they deem it appropriate, their disagreement or claim before the respondent authorities or in the competent jurisdictional venue, venues in which they may fully discuss the merits of the matter and assert their claims.” From what was resolved by the Chamber in the judgment just transcribed, as well as the fact that precautionary measures were adopted in due time, the dismissal of the amparo is also appropriate on this point.
V.DOCUMENTATION PROVIDED TO THE CASE FILE.- The petitioner is warned that if she has provided any paper document, as well as objects or evidence contained in any additional electronic, computer, magnetic, optical, telematic, or new technology-produced device, these must be removed from the office within a maximum period of 30 business days counted from the notification of this judgment. Otherwise, all material not removed within this period will be destroyed, as provided in the "Reglamento sobre Expediente Electrónico ante el Poder Judicial", approved by the Full Court in session No. 27-11 of August 22, 2011, Article XXVI and published in Judicial Bulletin number 19 of January 26, 2012, as well as in the agreement approved by the Superior Council of the Judiciary, in session No. 43-12 held on May 3, 2012, Article LXXXI.
POR TANTO:
The action is dismissed on the merits.
Paul Rueda L. President Jorge Araya G.
Ana María Picado B.
Alicia Salas T.
Anamari Garro V.
Marta Esquivel R.
Mauricio Chacón J.
Sentencia con datos protegidos, de conformidad con la normativa vigente SALA CONSTITUCIONAL DE LA CORTE SUPREMA DE JUSTICIA. San José, a las diez horas treinta minutos del diecinueve de abril de dos mil dieciocho. Recurso de amparo interpuesto por [Nombre 001], mayor, cédula de residencia No. [Valor 001]; contra LA SALA CONSTITUCIONAL DE LA CORTE SUPREMA DE JUSTICIA. RESULTANDO: 1.- Por escrito recibido en la Secretaría de la Sala a las 11:34 hrs. del 1 de noviembre de 2017, la recurrente interpone recurso de amparo contra la Sala Constitucional de la Corte Suprema de Justicia. Manifiesta que el 19 de setiembre del 2016 Paulina Mata y otros interpusieron recurso de amparo -expediente No. 16-012693-0007-CO-, con medida cautelar, para detener la construcción del edificio de Odontología por parte de la Universidad de Costa Rica al violentarse varios derechos fundamentales, incluyendo el artículo 50 constitucional.
Añade que el 16 de diciembre del 2016 interpuso recurso de amparo -expediente No. 16-017833-0007-CO- en el mismo sentido que el anterior. Indica que el 21 de diciembre del 2016, la Sala Constitucional emitió en el expediente No. 16-017833-0007-CO medidas cautelares, donde ordenó a la Universidad de Costa Rica detener la programada tala de los arboles en la llamada Finca 3; no obstante no fue posible la notificación de dicha resolución por estar la Universidad cerrada. Precisa que la Universidad de Costa Rica, aún a sabiendas que existía una medida cautelar contra la tala, aprovecharon que, al no habérseles podido notificar el 21 de diciembre, ya habían logrado talar 59 árboles en los días previos a la navidad, y justo en esa misma zona de la tala, ignoraron la medida cautelar y continuaron a inicios de febrero con los movimientos de tierra de los suelos que sostenían dichos árboles. Señala que al día de la interposición de este amparo el expediente No. 16-017833-0007-CO no se ha resuelto por parte de la Sala Constitucional, ni el fondo del asunto, ni la nueva solicitud de medida cautelar solicitada para que se ordenara detener la construcción de los edificios de Odontología, por lo que los edificios y otras estructuras del proceso urbanístico respectivo, están llegando casi a su terminación en este momento.
Añade que ha pasado más de un año desde la presentación del amparo No. 16-012693-0007-CO y todavía no hay respuesta ni de la medida cautelar solicitada ni de la resolución de fondo. Solicita la intervención de este Tribunal para hacer valer su derecho a una justicia pronta y cumplida ya que, a más de un año de haberse iniciado el expediente No. 16-012693-0007-CO no hay resolución de la medida cautelar y menos aún de fondo; asimismo al haber transcurrido más de nueve meses de iniciado el expediente No. 16-017833-0007-CO sin haber emitido resolución de fondo alguna. Reitera que el plazo de varios meses sin resolver sus gestiones de medida cautelar es contrario a los derechos consagrados en la Constitución Política y la propia Sala Constitucional debe resolver de inmediato la gestión de medida cautelar de detención de las obras constructivas del Edificio de Odontología en la finca 3 de la UCR.
Requiere que este Tribunal establezca, jurisprudencialmente, cuál es el plazo máximo razonable para que sea resuelta una solicitud de medida cautelar. 2.- Los Magistrados Ernesto Jinesta Lobo, Fernando Cruz Castro, Fernando Castillo Víquez, Luis Fdo. Salazar Alvarado, y la Magistrada Nancy Hernández López y el Magistrado Suplente José Paulino Hernández Gutiérrez, quien se encuentra en plaza vacante, presentaron solicitud de inhibitoria. Por resolución de las 13:22 hrs. del 30 de noviembre de 2017 la Presidencia a.i. de la Sala Constitucional admitió las inhibitorias planteadas por los mencionados Magistrados, teniéndolos por separados del conocimiento de este asunto y ordenando comunicar lo pertinente a la Presidencia de la Corte Suprema de Justicia a efectos de que se procede a su sustitución. 3.- La Presidencia de la Corte Suprema de Justicia realizó los sorteos correspondientes resultando electos los Magistrados Suplentes Aracelly Pacheco Salazar, Carlos M. Estrada Navas, Alicia Salas Torres, Ricardo Madrigal Jiménez, Rosa María Abdelnour Granados y Enrique Ulate Chacón. 4.- Por haber concluido el período constitucional de nombramiento como Magistrados Suplentes Aracelly Pacheco Salazar, Carlos M. Estrada Navas, Ricardo Madrigal Jiménez, Rosa María Abdelnour Granados y Enrique Ulate Chacón se solicitó a la Presidencia de la Corte Suprema de Justicia el nombramiento de 5 Magistrados Suplentes con el fin de integrar el Tribunal resultando electos Anamari Garro Vargas, Ana María Picado Brenes, Mauricio Chacón Jiménez, Marta Esquivel Rodríguez y Jorge Araya García. 5.- El artículo 9 de la Ley de la Jurisdicción Constitucional faculta a la Sala a rechazar de plano o por el fondo, en cualquier momento, incluso desde su presentación, cualquier gestión que se presente a su conocimiento que resulte ser manifiestamente improcedente, o cuando considere que existen elementos de juicio suficientes para rechazarla, o que se trata de la simple reiteración o reproducción de una gestión anterior igual o similar rechazada.
Redacta el Magistrado Rueda Leal y, CONSIDERANDO: I.- SOBRE EL OBJETO DEL RECURSO. La recurrente alega lesión a sus derechos fundamentales por la falta de resolución de los recursos de amparo No. 16-012693-0007-CO y No. 16-017833-0007-CO, así como de las solicitudes de medidas cautelares formuladas en dichos procesos. II.- HECHOS PROBADOS. De importancia para la decisión de este asunto, el Tribunal considera oportuno referirse a las diversas actuaciones realizadas en los recursos de amparo No. 16-012693-0007-CO, No. 16-017833-0007-CO y No. 17-001702-0007-CO. De acuerdo con la información del Sistema Informático de Gestión de Despachos Judiciales consta lo siguiente:
POR TANTO:
Se rechaza por el fondo el recurso.
Paul Rueda L.
Jorge Araya G.
Ana María Picado B.
Alicia Salas T.
Anamari Garro V.
Marta Esquivel R.
Mauricio Chacón J.
Observaciones de SALA CONSTITUCIONAL votado con boleta
Document not found. Documento no encontrado.