← Environmental Law Center← Centro de Derecho Ambiental
Res. 00060-2017 Tribunal Contencioso Administrativo Sección II · Tribunal Contencioso Administrativo Sección II · 28/09/2017
OutcomeResultado
The National Registry Board, with subsidiary State liability, is ordered to pay ¢5,000,000 for subjective moral damages, while the claim for material damages is dismissed.Se condena a la Junta Administrativa del Registro Nacional, y subsidiariamente al Estado, al pago de ¢5.000.000 por concepto de daño moral subjetivo, rechazando la indemnización por daños materiales.
SummaryResumen
The Administrative Litigation Tribunal, Section II, ruled on a claim for damages brought by a creditor against the National Registry Board and the State, arising from a registry error that omitted the inscription of a life usufruct on a donated property. The registrar's omission created a false appearance of full ownership, enabling the bare owner to mortgage the property without disclosing the usufruct. Following default, the creditor initiated foreclosure and a public auction was held, but the usufructuary later denounced his omitted right, prompting the Registry to issue a warning note and later immobilize the property. The enforcement court refused to approve the auction until the registry situation was resolved, harming the creditor. The Tribunal found no proven material damage, as the debt persists and the creditor may still pursue other assets. However, it recognized subjective moral damages (in re ipsa) due to the anxiety, frustration, and helplessness experienced, awarding an equitable sum of ¢5,000,000, reduced due to concurrence of causes (fault of the debtor, notary, and court). It ordered the Registry Board, with subsidiary liability of the State, to pay that amount.El Tribunal Contencioso Administrativo Sección II conoció de una demanda por daños y perjuicios presentada por un acreedor contra la Junta Administrativa del Registro Nacional y el Estado, derivada de un error registral que omitió la inscripción de un derecho de usufructo vitalicio en una finca donada. La omisión del registrador generó inexactitud en la publicidad registral, lo que permitió que la nuda propietaria hipotecara el inmueble sin revelar la existencia del usufructuario. Tras el impago del crédito, se inició un proceso de ejecución hipotecaria y se remató la finca, pero el usufructuario denunció su derecho omitido, lo que llevó al Registro a emitir una nota de advertencia y luego una inmovilización del inmueble. El juzgado de cobro rechazó aprobar el remate hasta que se resolviera la situación registral, causando perjuicios al acreedor. El Tribunal determinó que no se acreditó un daño material efectivo, pues la deuda subsiste y el acreedor aún puede perseguir otros bienes de la deudora. Sin embargo, reconoció la existencia de daño moral subjetivo (in re ipsa) por la angustia, frustración e impotencia sufridas, fijando una indemnización equitativa de ¢5.000.000, pero reducida por concurrencia de causas (culpa de la deudora, del notario y del juzgado). Condenó a la Junta Administrativa del Registro y subsidiariamente al Estado al pago de ese monto.
Key excerptExtracto clave
In light of all the above, the court’s omission ultimately contributed — along with the failure to register the usufruct and the inaccuracy of the registry’s publicity; together with the notary’s oversight and the debtor’s omissive conduct — to the non-approval of the auction of the property in favor of the plaintiff-creditor until its legal situation was resolved. One thing is the ineffectiveness of the mortgage privilege — not in itself the subject of the economic claim — and quite another is the extinction or disappearance of the debt, which subsists. In this ordinary proceeding, no material damage has been conclusively proven beyond a doubt that would make the State or Registry liable for the payment of the principal owed under the credit, the accrued interest, or the costs of the judicial collection process. […] The existence of subjective moral damage — in re ipsa — is found. Indeed, as the plaintiff asserts, the registrar’s serious omission and failure in his duty of care, plus the Registry’s negligence in overseeing its officers’ acts, were the triggers that — concurrently with other persons and behaviors — set off a series of events that today cause the plaintiff’s situation.En razón de todo lo expuesto tenemos que, esta conducta omisiva del Juzgado también contribuyó finalmente - junto con la omisión de inscripción del usufructo, e inexactitud de la publicidad registral; junto con la inadvertencia por el Notario responsable de su inscripción, conjuntamente con la conducta omisiva de Nombre24934 -, a la no aprobación del remate del inmueble a favor del acreedor - aquí actor- señor Nombre32374, hasta tanto no se resolviera la situación legal del mismo. Más una cosa es eso, vale decir, la ineficacia del privilegio hipotecario - en modo alguno objeto - en sí y por sí-, de la pretensión material económica, y otra, distinta, la extinción o desaparición de la deuda, acreencia la cual subsiste. Sin que se haya demostrado, fehacientemente, en este proceso ordinario, más allá de toda duda, la existencia del daño material, y consecuente responsabilidad del cobro - y pago-, a cargo del Estado y del Registro de los daños y perjuicios consistentes - según la pretensión de demanda-, en el Capital debido según el crédito, los Intereses generados por ese crédito, de las Costas de Proceso de Cobro Judicial y su indexación. […] Se estima la existencia - in re ipsa-, de daño moral subjetivo. En efecto, como señala la parte actora, la grave omisión y falta al deber de cuidado del registrador en su momento, así como la negligencia del Registro a la hora de vigilar las actuaciones de sus funcionarios, fueron los detonantes que permitieron - concurrentemente con otros sujetos y conductas-, que se desencadenasen otra serie de hechos ya mencionados, y que a hoy son los causantes de la situación en que se encuentra, el actor.
Pull quotesCitas destacadas
"No cabe duda que esa omisión registral generó inexactitud de la publicidad registral, desde el 29 de julio del 2011, fecha de su inscripción, en el sentido de que Nombre24934 era dueña del dominio pleno."
"There is no doubt that this registry omission created an inaccuracy in the registry’s publicity from 29 July 2011, the date of inscription, in the sense that Nombre24934 appeared as full owner."
Valoración del caso
"No cabe duda que esa omisión registral generó inexactitud de la publicidad registral, desde el 29 de julio del 2011, fecha de su inscripción, en el sentido de que Nombre24934 era dueña del dominio pleno."
Valoración del caso
"Pese a la nota de inmovilización, subsiste la eficacia del derecho de crédito."
"Despite the immobilization note, the efficacy of the credit right subsists."
Corolario
"Pese a la nota de inmovilización, subsiste la eficacia del derecho de crédito."
Corolario
"Se estima la existencia - in re ipsa-, de daño moral subjetivo. ... en estos años los sentimientos provocados por todas esas actuaciones han representado en el señor ... un desgaste en su persona, un gran enojo, y un mar de emociones negativas."
"The existence — in re ipsa — of subjective moral damage is found. ... over these years the feelings caused by all those actions have represented for the plaintiff ... a wearing down of his person, great anger, and a sea of negative emotions."
Sobre las pretensiones: Daño moral subjetivo
"Se estima la existencia - in re ipsa-, de daño moral subjetivo. ... en estos años los sentimientos provocados por todas esas actuaciones han representado en el señor ... un desgaste en su persona, un gran enojo, y un mar de emociones negativas."
Sobre las pretensiones: Daño moral subjetivo
"Se ha de condenar a la Junta Administrativa del Registro - y subsidiariamente al Estado-, al pago de ¢5.000.000, en favor del actor, por concepto de daño moral subjetivo."
"The Registry Board — and subsidiarily the State — is ordered to pay ¢5,000,000 to the plaintiff for subjective moral damages."
Parte dispositiva
"Se ha de condenar a la Junta Administrativa del Registro - y subsidiariamente al Estado-, al pago de ¢5.000.000, en favor del actor, por concepto de daño moral subjetivo."
Parte dispositiva
Full documentDocumento completo
Having analyzed the arguments and reviewed the evidentiary content of the case file, the Court determines that the claim for compensatory damages must be declared admissible, but only partially, regarding subjective moral damages, for the following reasons: BASIC LEGAL FRAMEWORK: Articles 1 and 22 and Transitory Provision V of the Law Creating the National Registry - No. 5695 of 05/28/1975 -, in pertinent part, establish: "Article 1.- The National Registry is created, dependent upon the Ministry of Justice (...)" "Article 22.- The Administrative Board of the National Registry must indemnify users for any harm the National Registry causes them in the processing of documents. To this end, it shall carry out the pertinent procedures to acquire an individual or collective fidelity bond, issued by an insurance institution authorized by law." "Transitory Provision V.- Until such time as the provisions of Article 22 of the Law creating the National Registry are implemented, the Administrative Board of the National Registry, through a budget allocation, shall allocate the necessary resources to cover eventual damages to third parties." Articles 1, 27, and 32 of the Law on the Registration of Documents in the Public Registry - 3883 of 05/30/1967 -, in pertinent part, establish: "ARTICLE 1.- The purpose of the National Registry is to guarantee the security of registered property or rights with respect to third parties.
This shall be achieved through the publicity of these property or rights. (...)" "ARTICLE 27.- For qualification purposes, both the General Registrar and the courts shall adhere only to what arises from the title, the books, the property, commercial, or personal folios, and in general, all information available in the Registry (...)" "ARTICLE 32.- The National Registry, through the technical and technological procedures it deems secure and agile, shall establish the manner of processing and publicizing registral information. Registral entries made by these means shall produce the legal effects derived from registral publicity, regarding third parties, and shall possess the validity and authenticity that the law grants to public documents." Subsection g) of Article 34 and Article 100 of the Notarial Code - Law 7764 of April 17, 1998 -, in pertinent part, establish: "ARTICLE 34.- Scope of the notarial function.
It is incumbent upon the notary public: (...) g) To conduct registral studies (...)." "ARTICLE 100.- Appearance of parties in common mortgages. In the constitution of common mortgages, the acceptance of the creditor is not necessary (...)." Article 6 and the final paragraph of Article 14 of the Regulations of the Public Registry - Executive Decree # 26771 of February 18, 1998 -, in pertinent part, establish: "Article 6°-(Repealed by Article 1° of Executive Decree No. 27934 of May 26, 1999, 'Suppresses the organic structure of the National Registry, the Legal Advisory Offices of the Registries of Movable Property, Immovable Property, Legal Persons, and National Cadastre, as independent structures')". "Article 14.- Of the Certifications Department. (...) It is incumbent upon the Certifiers to issue the certifications requested regarding registered information contained in the different databases, which they shall do by the means available in coordination with the Directorate, with the obligation to provide efficient service." Articles 2, 3, 14, 15, 25, and 28 of the Regulation for the Organization of the Real Estate Registry - Executive Decree No. 35509 of 09/30/2009 - in pertinent part, establish: Article 2º - Definitions. For the purposes of these Regulations, the following shall be understood as: (...)
In virtue of which, doubt exists regarding the ineffectiveness of his credit right; and, therefore, regarding the existence of actual, economically assessable, individualized damage, that is, of the material or economic damage consisting of the loss of the Principal owed and Interest on the credit, and costs of the judicial collection process.
Which led, the following day, on July 23, 2015, to the issuance of an administrative registry resolution, which ordered a) Authorize the opening of the administrative file (expediente administrativo) to conduct investigations and comply with due procedure, and b) Record an "Administrative Warning" (Advertencia Administrativa) on the property in question, solely for purposes of registry publicity, while the processing of the file continued. On July 27, 2015, the plaintiff-creditor Nombre32374 requested approval of the foreclosure sale. By judicial resolution of 1:38 p.m. on August 4, 2015, the interest calculation submitted in the initial statement of claim was approved. At 2:28 p.m. on that same day, August 4, 2015, the Registry's Official Letter RIM-AJRI-802-2015, dated July 24, 2015, was filed with the Court, requesting a report on the current status of the file and the interested parties in said judicial process in order to proceed with the legally required hearings in the processing of the administrative proceeding.
Now then, in response to the request for approval of the foreclosure sale, filed on July 27, 2015, by resolution of August 10, 2015, the Heredia Collection Court ordered: "Upon review of this matter, it is noted that there is an administrative warning (within file 2015-1676-RIM, see resolution of 10:00 a.m. 07-23-2015, see also filing of 08-04-15), for which reason the foreclosure sale in question is reserved to be heard once said administrative warning is resolved...." On October 2, 2015, the Court received the copy of administrative file 2015-1676-RIM. Subsequently, by judicial resolution of October 22, 2015, the Court ordered the rejection of the appeal for reconsideration filed by the plaintiff-creditor, Nombre32374, against the aforementioned resolution of August 10, 2015. For which it considered: "Let that party note that the filing submitted on August 4, 2015, by the Real Property Registry (Registro Inmobiliario) (National Registry) clearly indicates that an investigation is currently being conducted regarding the property in question, so much so that they indicate it is possible there is a registry error that has not been corrected due to the annotation of this proceeding, which is why, considering the delicate nature of the situation, the foreclosure sale conducted in these proceedings is reserved to be heard once administrative file No. 1676-2015-RIM is resolved." Simultaneously, it rejected the appeal that had been filed.
Now then, it cannot be ignored that by Official Letter No. RIM-RE-306-2015 dated November 16, 2015, addressed to the Court—at the request of the plaintiff-creditor Nombre32374—the Registry Directorate made observations to it regarding the scope and limits of the Administrative Warning, in accordance with the aforementioned regulations, to the effect that "...it is a precautionary, preventive, and temporary measure, recorded solely for purposes of notice publicity, which does not interrupt real estate transactions, that is, it does not cause the immobilization of the asset, and therefore does not prevent the registration of new acts or contracts, and is recorded while the study of the matter under investigation is concluded...." By virtue of which, this Court understands, the plaintiff Nombre32374 once again requested the approval of the foreclosure sale, on November 24, 2015. However, by judicial resolution at 8:36 a.m. on January 6, 2016, it was ordered, in pertinent part: "...The plaintiff party shall abide by what was resolved in the order of eight hours and fourteen minutes on October twenty-second, two thousand fifteen...." On January 15, 2016, he requested an Addition and Clarification.
However, by judicial resolution of April 5, 2016, it was ordered, in pertinent part: "...The request for addition and clarification (...) is rejected, as it only proceeds when what is issued is a final judgment on the merits....." Now then, it was not until the final resolution of the administrative procedure, at 11:00 a.m. on March 1, 2016, that the Registry ordered: Maintain the Warning Notice, and proceed with the immobilization—due to registry inconsistency—and its annotation on the property. The annotation was made with its submission to the Registry Daily Log at 10:24 a.m. on March 28, 2016. Which implies, as considered in that resolution and in accordance with Article 28 of the Regulations for the Organization of the Real Property Registry, referral to the judicial courts so that, in a separate proceeding, the matter be clarified or the parties interested in or affected by the inaccuracy authorize it, by means of a suitable document duly submitted to the Real Property Registry for qualification and registration, and a resolution be issued on the matter.
The Registry's powers to resort to the measure of the Immobilization Notice cannot be called into question in cases where third parties must be made aware that a registry entry suffers from a defect. That is, in cases where, following the due administrative procedure, it detects an error or omission that entails the potential nullity of the entry, it may order said notice to be annotated in the margin of the entry, and while it is not canceled or rectified, no subsequent registry operation may be performed on the respective entry. In the present case, the immobilization notice meets the substantive requirements that any precautionary measure must fulfill to be such. That is, there is an evident present interest, as the notice proceeds upon detection of an error or omission that entails the potential nullity of the entry and its cancellation. Furthermore, as in the sub examine, there must be elements of judgment that preliminarily evidence the nullity of the entry because it is of a serious nature, irreparable, or of difficult reparation for the damage sought to be avoided.
This is why it is reasonable and proportionate for the law to empower the Registry to issue an immobilization notice to discharge its liability in matters of damages to third parties under the protection of registry publicity. This is for the purpose of preventing any subsequent registry operation from being performed on said property until such notice is canceled or the nullity affecting it is remedied, in protection of third parties. It does not matter, it has been held, that registrable documents may have even been previously submitted, because if those acts or contracts were registered, their rights would be consolidated, which is ultimately much more prejudicial than awaiting the definition of the respective ordinary trial. Therefore, in the present case, the Registry was complying with a mandate delegated by law, without the Registry itself bearing any liability for this; which rejects the reproach that it failed to resolve the situation at the administrative level and instead issued the resolution of March 1, 2016, immobilizing the property—without it—as erroneously asserted—already being his property—and referred the matter to the judicial authority to make the decision.
It is likely that said situation will become, in its case, a judicial process—cumbersome for years—that will continue to affect his interests; however, seen correctly, the claim for material or economic damages does not consist of this. That final administrative resolution was incorporated into the judicial file of the collection proceeding on April 12, 2016. It was only based on this resolution that the Heredia Collection Court ordered—by resolution of October 21, 2016—the following: "...Upon determining in said administrative proceeding the existence of a usufruct (usufructo) right which was not registered on the property to be sold at auction due to a registry error, and the notification of the usufructuary being necessary in proceedings where the property over which their right exists is to be auctioned, and said procedural act being lacking due to the situation noted above, the foreclosure sale conducted at nine o'clock and zero minutes on July twentieth of the year two thousand fifteen is disapproved (imprueba el remate)." This was notified to the creditor-plaintiff Mr.
Nombre32374 on October 31, 2016, through his attorney. And there is no record of any objection filing. Nor of the suspension of the enforcement proceeding, judicial file No. 14-006163-1158-CJ, since its electronic filing indicates it is INACTIVE. Which is different. The consequences of which will be addressed later.
Now then, as we see, between August 10, 2015, and April 5, 2016, the Collection Court rejected the requests for approval of the July 20, 2015, foreclosure sale, and instead kept its hearing reserved—suspended—due to the Administrative Warning, until it was resolved at the administrative level, in file No. 1676-2015-RIM. Without there being, at the date of the foreclosure sale—nor subsequently—any opposition, preliminary ruling, nullity incidents, or third-party claims. Notwithstanding the aforementioned regulations and Official Letter No. RIM-RE-306-2015 of November 16, 2015, stating that "...it is a precautionary, preventive, and temporary measure, recorded solely for purposes of notice publicity, which does not interrupt real estate transactions, that is, it does not cause the immobilization of the asset, and therefore does not prevent the registration of new acts or contracts, and is recorded while the study of the matter under investigation is concluded...." In short, without the Administrative Warning alone—existing from July 23, 2015, until, at least, March 28, 2016, when the immobilization was ordered—preventing—in that interim, at least—the approval of the foreclosure sale and its eventual registration.
COROLLARY: Based on all of the foregoing, we find that this omission by the Court also ultimately contributed—along with the failure to register the usufruct, and the inaccuracy of registry publicity; along with the oversight by the Notary responsible for its registration, jointly with the omission by Nombre24934—to the non-approval of the foreclosure sale of the property in favor of the creditor—plaintiff here—Mr. Nombre32374, until the legal situation of the same was resolved. But the ineffectiveness of the mortgage privilege—in no way the object—in and of itself—of the material economic claim, is one thing, and the extinction or disappearance of the debt, an obligation which subsists, is quite another. Without it having been conclusively demonstrated, in this ordinary process, beyond all reasonable doubt, the existence of material damage, and consequent liability of the State and the Registry for the payment of the damages consisting—according to the claim of the lawsuit—of the Principal owed (Capital debido) according to the credit, the Interest generated (Intereses generados) by that credit, the Costs of the Judicial Collection Process and their indexation (doctrine of Article 317 of the CPC).
Indeed, regarding the alleged strict liability for such economic damages due to illicit or abnormal activity, we reiterate, it cannot be accepted. For an indemnity to proceed for the liability of the Public Administration for its illicit acts or abnormal functioning, its action is not sufficient. A causal relationship is required between the act attributed to the administration and the damage produced, without the incidence of an external cause, such as the victim's own fault, force majeure, or the act of a third party. It being necessary, in any case, that an effective, economically assessable, and individualized damage (daño, efectivo, evaluable económicamente, individualizado) has been produced (Article 196 of the LGAP). The special nature of the damage is required, e.g., by the exceptional intensity of the injury. That is, it must entail a special sacrifice. Special not in the sense of singular, but in the sense of being particularly intense and grave. That it exceeds the common burdens borne by the general public and impacts the assets of certain individuals in a particularly intense and grave manner.
In the present case, as we have already indicated, the warning and immobilization notice—causes of the disapproval of the foreclosure sale (improbación del remate)—are the final consequence of several subjects and singular actions that concurred in its production. Furthermore, as we indicated, the invalidity or nullity and eventual order for cancellation of the property's registration entry, in the name of Nombre24934, as owner of full dominion, has not been declared, nor ordered, in an ordinary judicial process. Less, consequently, the nullity and cancellation of the mortgage registration in favor of the plaintiff here, Mr. Nombre32374. And there is no notice of its filing. Nor can—or should—anything be resolved on the matter, within this present Civil Treasury Process. Despite the immobilization notice, the effectiveness of the credit right subsists. In this sense, the documented legal act retains its status as an enforceable title capable of pursuing other assets or rights of the debtor, in the same proceeding or via the expedited payment process.
Indeed, the immobilization notice, which weakens the real guarantee, does not prevent the mortgage deed from retaining its status as an enforceable title capable of pursuing other assets or rights of the debtor—among them, e.g., the ownership of the bare ownership right, which Nombre24934 has and maintains in the property by virtue of its acquisition document. Furthermore, the judicial collection process is not suspended, but rather inactive, without the creditor—plaintiff here—Mr. Nombre32374, having attempted—and exhausted—the possibility of requesting the attachment and forced sale of other assets or rights of the debtor for the satisfaction of the debt, among them, the bare ownership right that Nombre24934 has and maintains in the property in question, within that proceeding, or in an expedited payment process. In short, without it being proven—to date—the existence of an uncollectible debt.
Any conclusion on the matter being premature. By virtue of which there is doubt regarding the ineffectiveness of their credit right; and, therefore, of the existence of effective, economically assessable, and individualized damage (daño, efectivo, evaluable económicamente, individualizado), that is, of material or economic damage consisting of the loss of the Principal owed and Interest on the credit, and costs of the judicial collection process.
The consequences of which will be addressed later.
Now then, as we see, between August 10, 2015, and April 5, 2016, the Collection Court rejected the requests for approval of the judicial sale of July 20, 2015, and instead held in reserve—suspended—its consideration, due to the *Administrative Warning*, until it was resolved in the administrative venue, in case file No. 1676-2015-RIM. Without there being, at the date of the judicial sale—nor subsequently—any opposition, prejudiciality, nullity incidents, or third-party claims. Besides the existence of the aforementioned regulations and Official Letter No. RIM-RE-306-2015 of November 16, 2015, stating that *"... it is a precautionary, preventive, and temporary measure, recorded solely for publicity-notice purposes, which does not interrupt real estate transactions, that is, it does not generate the immobilization of the property, and therefore does not prevent the registration of new acts or contracts, and which is recorded while the study of the matter under investigation is concluded. ..."* In short, without the mere Administrative Warning—existing from July 23, 2015, until at least March 28, 2016, when the immobilization was ordered—having prevented—in that interim, at least—the approval of the judicial sale and its eventual registration.
COROLLARY: By reason of all the foregoing, we have that this omission by the Court also ultimately contributed—together with the omission in registering the usufruct (usufructo), and the inaccuracy of the registry publicity; together with the oversight by the Notary responsible for its registration, jointly with the omission by Nombre24934—to the non-approval of the judicial sale of the property in favor of the creditor—plaintiff herein—Mr. Nombre32374, until such time as its legal situation was resolved. But one thing is that, that is to say, the ineffectiveness of the mortgage privilege—in no way the object—in and of itself—of the material economic claim, and another, distinct, is the extinction or disappearance of the debt, an obligation which subsists. Without it having been demonstrated, reliably, in this ordinary proceeding, beyond all doubt, the existence of material damage, and the consequent liability for collection—and payment—borne by the State and the Registry for damages and losses consisting—according to the claim in the lawsuit—of the *Principal Due* according to the credit, the *Interest Generated* by that credit, the *Costs of the Judicial Collection Proceeding* and its indexation (doctrine of article 317 of the CPC).
Indeed, regarding the alleged strict liability, for such economic damages, due to unlawful or abnormal activity, the same, we repeat, is not admissible. For indemnification to proceed based on the liability of the Public Administration for its unlawful acts or abnormal functioning, its action is not enough. The existence of a causal relationship is required between the act imputed to the administration and the damage produced, without the incidence of an extraneous cause, such as the victim's fault, force majeure, or the act of a third party. It being necessary, in any case, that a damage, effective, economically assessable, individualized has been produced (article 196 of the LGAP). The special nature of the damage is required, e.g., by the exceptional intensity of the injury. That is, it must entail a special sacrifice. Special not in the sense of singular, but in the sense of particularly intense and serious.
That it exceeds the common burdens weighing upon the generality of the administered and impacts in an especially intense and serious manner the property of specific administered persons. In the present case, as we already pointed out, the warning and immobilization notice—causing the *disapproval of the judicial sale*—are the final consequence of various subjects and singular conducts that concurred in its production. Besides, as we pointed out, the invalidity or nullity and eventual order for cancellation of the registration entry of the property, in the name of Nombre24934, as owner of the full domain, has not been declared, nor ordered, in an ordinary judicial proceeding. Even less, consequently, the nullity and cancellation of the registration of the mortgage in favor of the plaintiff herein, Mr. Nombre32374. Without there being any notice of its filing. Without it being possible—nor proper—to resolve anything in this regard, within this present Civil Hacienda proceeding.
Despite the immobilization notice, the effectiveness of the credit right subsists. In this sense, the documented legal act retains the condition of an executory title (título ejecutivo) susceptible to pursuing other assets or rights of the debtor, in the same proceeding or through the order for payment procedure (proceso monitorio). Indeed, the immobilization notice does not impede—which weakens the real guarantee—the mortgage deed retains the condition of an executory title (título ejecutivo) susceptible to pursuing other assets or rights of the debtor—among them, e.g., the ownership of the right to the bare ownership (nuda propiedad), which Nombre24934 has and maintains, in the property by virtue of the document of its acquisition. Apart from that, the judicial collection proceeding is not suspended, but inactive, without the creditor—plaintiff herein—Mr. Nombre32374, having attempted—and exhausted—the possibility of requesting the seizure (embargo) and judicial sale of other assets or rights of the debtor, for the satisfaction of the debt, among them, the right of bare ownership (nuda propiedad) that it has and maintains, in the property in question, within that proceeding, or in an order for payment procedure (proceso monitorio).
In short, without there being accredited—to date—the existence of an uncollectible debt. Any conclusion regarding it is premature. By virtue of which, there is doubt about the ineffectiveness of his credit right; and, therefore, about the existence of damage, effective, economically assessable, individualized, that is, of the material or economic damage consisting of the loss of the Principal Due and Interest of the credit, costs of the judicial collection proceeding.
´” VII.- CRITERIO DEL TRIBUNAL: Analizados los alegatos y revisado el contenido probatorio de los autos, el Tribunal determina que la pretensión de condena indemnizatoria se ha de declarar procedente, pero solo parcialmente, respecto del daño moral subjetivo, por las siguiente razones: MARCO JURÍDICO BÁSICO: Los artículos 1 y 22 y Transitorio V, de la Ley de Creación del Registro Nacional -No. 5695 del 28/05/1975 -, en lo de interés, establecen: "Artículo 1º.-Créase el Registro Nacional, dependiente del Ministerio de Justicia (...)" "Artículo 22.-La Junta Administrativa del Registro Nacional deberá indemnizar a los usuarios por cualquier perjuicio que el Registro Nacional les cause en la tramitación de documentos. Para ello, efectuará los trámites pertinentes, a fin de adquirir una póliza de fidelidad, individual o colectiva, expedida por una institución aseguradora autorizada por la ley." "Transitorio V.- Hasta tanto no se ejecute lo dispuesto en el artículo 22 de la Ley de creación del Registro Nacional, la Junta Administrativa del Registro Nacional, mediante partida presupuestaria, destinará los recursos necesarios para cubrir los eventuales daños a terceros.".
Los artículos 1, 27 y 32 de la Ley de Inscripción de Documentos en Registro Público - 3883 del 30/05/1967-, en lo de interés, establecen: "ARTICULO 1º.- El propósito del Registro Nacional es garantizar la seguridad de los bienes o derechos inscritos con respecto a terceros. Lo anterior se logrará mediante la publicidad de estos bienes o derechos. (...)" "ARTICULO 27.- Para la calificación, tanto el Registrador General como los tribunales se atendrán tan sólo a lo que resulte del título, de los libros, de los folios reales, mercantiles o personales, y en general de toda la información que conste en el Registro (...)" "ARTÍCULO 32.- El Registro Nacional, mediante los procedimientos técnicos y tecnológicos que considere seguros y ágiles, establecerá la forma de tramitar y publicitar la información registral. Los asientos registrales efectuados con estos medios surtirán los efectos jurídicos derivados de la publicidad registral, respecto de terceros y tendrán la validez y autenticidad que la ley otorga a los documentos públicos.
El inciso g) del artículo 34 y el 100 del Código Notarial - Ley 7764 del 17 de abril de 1998-, en lo conducente, establecen:"ARTÍCULO 34.-Alcances de la función notarial. Compete al notario público: (...) g) Realizar los estudios registrales (...)". ARTÍCULO 100.- Comparecencia de partes en hipotecas comunes. En la constitución de hipotecas comunes, no es necesaria la aceptación del acreedor (...)". El artículo 6 y 14 párrafo final del Reglamento del Registro Público -Decreto Ejecutivo # 26771 del 18 de febrero de 1998-, en lo conducente, establecen: "Artículo 6°-(Derogado por artículo 1° del decreto ejecutivo N° 27934 del 26 de mayo de 1999, "Suprime la estructura orgánica del Registro Nacional, las Asesorías Jurídicas de los Registros de Bienes Muebles, Bienes Inmuebles, Personas Jurídicas y Catastro Nacional, como estructuras independientes")". "Artículo 14.- Del Departamento de Certificaciones.
(...) Corresponde a los Certificadores la expedición de las certificaciones que se solicitan sobre la información registrada y que consta en las diferentes bases de datos, lo cual harán por los medios de que dispongan en coordinación con la Dirección, con la obligación de brindar un eficiente servicio.". Los artículos 2, 3, 14, 15, 25 y 28 del Reglamento de Organización del Registro Inmobiliario -Decreto Ejecutivo No. 35509 del 30/09/2009 - en lo de interés, establecen: Artículo 2º - Definiciones. Para los fines del presente Reglamento, se entenderá por: (...)
Document not found. Documento no encontrado.