← Environmental Law Center← Centro de Derecho Ambiental
Res. 00111-2016 Tribunal Contencioso Administrativo Sección VI · Tribunal Contencioso Administrativo Sección VI · 28/07/2016
OutcomeResultado
The Court rejects Grupo Mutual's claim and confirms that income from collecting vehicle circulation fees for the INS is not exempt from income tax, as prior Banhvi authorization was not proven.El Tribunal rechaza la pretensión de Grupo Mutual y confirma que los ingresos por recaudación de derechos de circulación para el INS no están exentos del impuesto sobre la renta, al no haberse acreditado la autorización previa del Banhvi.
SummaryResumen
The ruling analyzes the scope of the tax exemption provided in Articles 69 and 74 of Law 7052, the National Housing Finance System Law, in the context of a claim by Grupo Mutual Alajuela La Vivienda against tax authorities. The mutual association argued the exemption was purely subjective, universal, and immutable, covering all taxes on any activity, including secondary ones. The Court rejects this interpretation, holding instead that the exemption is both subjective and objective: granted to mutual associations, but conditioned on the best fulfilment of their aims—those of the housing finance system. For secondary activities, such as collecting vehicle circulation fees for the National Insurance Institute (INS), the exemption only applies if the Housing Mortgage Bank (Banhvi) previously authorizes and verifies that the activity generates resources for primary goals. As no such authorization was proven, the income is subject to income tax. The Court emphasizes that tax exemptions are not immutable and that the taxpayer bears the burden of proof.La sentencia analiza el alcance de la exención tributaria contenida en los artículos 69 y 74 de la Ley 7052, Ley del Sistema Financiero Nacional para la Vivienda, a propósito de una reclamación de Grupo Mutual Alajuela La Vivienda contra la Administración Tributaria. La mutual sostenía que la exención era subjetiva, universal e inmutable, cubriendo cualquier tributo de toda actividad, incluyendo las secundarias. El Tribunal rechaza esa interpretación y determina que la exención es simultáneamente subjetiva y objetiva: se otorga a las mutuales, pero está condicionada a la mejor realización de sus fines, que son los del sistema financiero para la vivienda. Respecto de actividades secundarias, como la recaudación de derechos de circulación para el INS, la exención solo opera si el Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda (Banhvi) autoriza previamente y verifica que generan recursos para los fines primordiales. Al no haberse acreditado esa autorización, los ingresos están sujetos al impuesto sobre la renta. Se subraya que las exenciones no son inmutables y que la carga de la prueba recae en el contribuyente.
Key excerptExtracto clave
This Court, in view of the foregoing and taking into account the parties' various arguments, finds that the exemption is indeed both subjective and objective, and furthermore, one that serves general social interests (see this Section's ruling No. 010-2014-VI, cited above). The exemption is thus granted to a specific subcategory of taxpayers: mutual savings and loan associations, but is also conditional on '...the best fulfilment of their aims...', which must be understood as covering activities aimed at achieving the purpose for which the Mutuals were established—namely, that of the national housing finance system, the legal framework under which they have been regulated in our country... Thus, in the case at hand, this Court finds that the gross income (commissions) earned by Grupo Mutual Alajuela La Vivienda, as economic consideration from a contractual relationship with the National Insurance Institute, constitutes a secondary activity not covered by the exemption in question, since, as stated, prior authorization from Banhvi is required for it to apply; and such authorization has not been proven, either before this Court or at the administrative stage.Este Tribunal, en vista de lo desarrollado hasta aquí y atendiendo los diversos argumentos de las partes, se decanta por considerar que, efectivamente, es al mismo tiempo una exención subjetiva y objetiva, y además, una en función de intereses generales de carácter social (sentencia de esta Sección n° 010-2014-VI, arriba citada). La exoneración se otorga así a una subcategoría concreta de contribuyentes: las asociaciones mutualistas, pero además se supedita a “…la mejor realización de sus fines…”, lo que debe entenderse que abarca las actividades dirigidas a satisfacer la finalidad para la cual se establecieron las Mutuales, que no es otro distinto al del sistema financiero nacional para la vivienda, marco legal bajo el que han sido reguladas en nuestro país... De esta manera, en el caso concreto, estima este Tribunal que la generación de rentas brutas (comisiones) por parte de Grupo Mutual Alajuela La Vivienda, como contraprestación económica proveniente de una relación contractual con el Instituto Nacional de Seguros, constituye una actividad secundaria de aquélla que no está cubierta por la exoneración en cuestión, ya que como se ha dicho, se requiere de la autorización previa del Banhvi para que opere; lo cual, sin embargo, no ha sido acreditado, ni ante este Tribunal, ni en sede administrativa.
Pull quotesCitas destacadas
"Las mutuales gozarán de exención, de tributos de toda clase, presentes y futuros."
"Mutual associations shall enjoy exemption from all kinds of taxes, present and future."
Artículo 69 Ley 7052
"Las mutuales gozarán de exención, de tributos de toda clase, presentes y futuros."
Artículo 69 Ley 7052
"Para acogerse a esta última exención, la entidad, en cada caso, deberá contar con la aprobación previa del Banco."
"To qualify for this latter exemption, the entity shall, in each case, have the prior approval of the Bank."
Artículo 74 Ley 7052
"Para acogerse a esta última exención, la entidad, en cada caso, deberá contar con la aprobación previa del Banco."
Artículo 74 Ley 7052
"La exención tributaria contenida en los artículos 69 y 74 de la Ley N° 7052, al ser de orden subjetivo y objetivo a la vez, además de que se justifica en la satisfacción de intereses generales de carácter social, requiere para operar jurídicamente la comprobación previa del vínculo entre la generación de rentas y la consecución de los fines del sistema financiero nacional para la vivienda."
"The tax exemption contained in Articles 69 and 74 of Law No. 7052, being at once subjective and objective, and justified by the satisfaction of general social interests, requires for its legal operation the prior verification of the link between income generation and the achievement of the aims of the national housing finance system."
"La exención tributaria contenida en los artículos 69 y 74 de la Ley N° 7052, al ser de orden subjetivo y objetivo a la vez, además de que se justifica en la satisfacción de intereses generales de carácter social, requiere para operar jurídicamente la comprobación previa del vínculo entre la generación de rentas y la consecución de los fines del sistema financiero nacional para la vivienda."
"Corresponde a este último, según el caso, demostrar los hechos o actos que configuren sus costos, gastos, pasivos, créditos fiscales, exenciones, no sujeciones, descuentos y, en general, los beneficios fiscales que alega existentes en su favor."
"It falls to the latter, as the case may be, to demonstrate the facts or acts that constitute its costs, expenses, liabilities, tax credits, exemptions, non-incidences, deductions, and, in general, the tax benefits it claims exist in its favor."
Artículo 185 Código de Normas y Procedimientos Tributarios
"Corresponde a este último, según el caso, demostrar los hechos o actos que configuren sus costos, gastos, pasivos, créditos fiscales, exenciones, no sujeciones, descuentos y, en general, los beneficios fiscales que alega existentes en su favor."
Artículo 185 Código de Normas y Procedimientos Tributarios
Full documentDocumento completo
III.ON THE SCOPE OF THE EXEMPTION IN ARTICLES 69 AND 74 OF LAW 7052, THE FINANCIAL SYSTEM FOR HOUSING LAW.- The legal hypothesis put forward by the representation of Grupo Mutual in its lawsuit is structured on the basis that the exemption provided in the Financial System for Housing Law is exclusively subjective in nature and, consequently, is intended to cover any tax on any type of activity undertaken by the organization; an exemption which is furthermore immutable, as it would be related to present and future taxes. Alternatively, it argues that, in any case, income from secondary activities, as in the present case, constitutes a sort of ancillary resources subject, in any event, to the main purpose of the Mutual Association, which is the provision of affordable housing. From the outset, this Court would like to point out that exemptions, just like taxes, correspond to a fiscal policy that is ultimately aimed at satisfying the public needs to which the Costa Rican State is bound.
Every exemption, by its nature as an incentive or promotional instrument, seeks to achieve extra-fiscal goals (promotion and discouragement of activities and redistribution of wealth), through the promotion of public activities or private activities of public relevance, as in this case, the provision of housing, through a specific type of private legal entity: the mutual association. However, and unlike what is maintained by the plaintiff, for the reason already indicated, every current exemption is subject to review and modification by the legislature (principle of legal reserve in tax matters –Art. 121.13 of the Political Constitution, 5 and 61 of the Tax Code and Regulations– and mutability of the legal system); it is not a universal, perpetual, and immutable benefit as has been argued. Having made this brief introduction, we proceed to the analysis of the rules involved in this matter.
Law number 7052, the National Financial System for Housing Law, entered into force on November 27, 1986, and in its articles 69 and 74, it established an exemption for Mutual Associations in the following terms: “…Article 69.- Mutual associations shall be organized and operate in accordance with the provisions in this law and in the Organic Law of the Central Bank of Costa Rica. For the better fulfillment of their purposes, mutual associations shall enjoy exemption from taxes of all kinds, present and future. [...] Article 74.- Mutual associations shall have their own legal personality, which must be registered in the Persons Section of the Public Registry, based on the public deed of their incorporation. Consequently, they shall be legally capable of acquiring rights, contracting obligations, and intervening in lawsuits and proceedings of any nature, judicial and administrative. They shall enjoy exemption from posting cost bonds and making deposits to guarantee pre-judgment attachments, as well as from the payment of all types of present and future taxes.
To avail itself of this latter exemption, the entity must, in each case, have the prior approval of the Bank….” Now, to properly understand the scope of this exemption in the specific case, firstly, it is necessary to specify the nature of mutual associations. In this way, and in general, mutual associations, or simply mutual associations, correspond to organizations of persons that, under a principle of solidarity and from an individual contribution or payment –in this case, from savings– seek the satisfaction of needs or interests common to the members, through the provision of different services for their benefit. In the Costa Rican legal system, these types of organizations have been regulated specifically through the National Financial System for Housing Law, which, in article 163, restricts the names "savings and loan association" and "mutual association," solely to those entities that have been so authorized by the Housing Mortgage Bank (hereinafter Banhvi), for the provision of financial services established under that legal framework.
We can then affirm that mutual associations or savings and loan mutual associations correspond to entities forming part of the national financial system for housing, conceived as non-bank financial entities of a private and associative nature, which share with the system the main purpose of “…promoting national and foreign savings and investment, in order to collect financial resources to seek a solution to the existing housing problem in the country…” (Articles 1 to 3, 68, 69, 74 and 75 Law No. 7052). They achieve this purpose through the provision of financial services, under the mutualism scheme, that is, using savings and loans as a mechanism for contribution and provision of services for their members, with the fundamental difference that mutual associations in Costa Rica, by forming part of the financial system for housing, additionally serve as an instrument for the channeling, allocation, and final disbursement of the resources coming from that system, specifically, from the National Housing Fund or FONAVI (articles 41 to
For this reason, the respondent Administrations are correct in considering the income obtained by Grupo Mutual through the business of collecting vehicle circulation fees that it provides to INS as not exempt, which, consequently, is indeed subject to the payment of income tax, especially when the tax consultation carried out at the time (proven fact number 7) has not been challenged [...].” Now, it is insisted that this causal relationship must be verified by the Mutuales and that the Banhvi is the competent administrative authority to certify it. Article 174 of Ley 7052 states: “*Article 174.- The powers conferred in this law upon the Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda, regarding the operation of the authorized entities, shall only correspond to the housing financing granted by them. Consequently, the other functions for which the authorized entities have authority fall outside the competence and control of the Bank.* ” (Emphasis not in original) As we noted previously, once born into legal existence, a mutualist association, as a private entity and therefore governed by the constitutional principle of autonomy of will (Art. 28 CPOL), may freely provide services of a different nature; however, insofar as those services fall within, obey, or address the purposes and activities of the national financial system for housing, or seek to avail themselves of the benefits, fiscal or otherwise, that Ley 7052 grants to authorized entities, the Mutuales will inevitably be subject to the oversight powers of the Banhvi.
This is also established in articles 6 to 9 of Decreto Ejecutivo number 25788-MP-MIVAH, “Reglamento Organización del Sistema Financiero Nacional para Vivienda,” but particularly in numerals 6 and 7: “*Article 6—Scope of the Authorized Entity declaration: The status of Authorized Entity of the System governs the respective institutions, with regard to those programs, plans, projects, and operations that they execute within the System’s regulations. These provisions shall not apply to activities that those institutions execute and that do not meet the previous requirements, and therefore they may not invoke them in any way to support or justify their actions. Article 7— Other operations of the Authorized Entities: With regard to entities that execute activities outside the System, the Bank shall be authorized to formulate observations and recommendations when they are affecting or could harm the housing programs that they execute within it.
Said observations or recommendations may also be formulated to the supervisory authorities of those entities.*” (Emphasis not in original) This last article negatively reflects the indispensability of the prior authorization of the Banhvi, since precisely the performance of secondary activities without supervision or control could rather endanger the achievement of the primary purposes of the Mutuales, as authorized entities within the financial system for housing; hence, if tax exemptions are to be generated on them, justified by the extra-fiscal (extrafiscales) purposes of that system, it would make no sense—at least for this Court—to accept a thesis in which mutualist associations could benefit from them, without a prior verification by the Banhvi of the necessary link between the income obtained from these secondary activities and the fulfillment of the primary objective of solving the “*existing housing problem in the country*,” through a special system of financial intermediation.
Thus, this Chamber having determined that the tax exemption contained in articles 69 and 74 of Ley N° 7052, being both subjective and objective in nature, in addition to being justified by the satisfaction of general interests of a social nature, requires, in order to operate legally, the prior verification of the link between the generation of income and the achievement of the purposes of the national financial system for housing by the Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda, especially in the case of the secondary activities that they may carry out according to numeral 75.f) *ibidem*. Therefore, in the specific case, this Court considers that the generation of gross income (commissions) by Grupo Mutual Alajuela La Vivienda, as economic consideration arising from a contractual relationship with the Instituto Nacional de Seguros, constitutes a secondary activity thereof that is not covered by the exemption in question, since, as stated, the prior authorization of the Banhvi is required for it to operate; which, however, has not been accredited, neither before this Court nor in the administrative venue.
For this reason, the defendant Administrations are correct in considering the income obtained by Grupo Mutual through the vehicle circulation fee collection business provided to the INS as not exempt, which, consequently, is indeed subject to income tax payment, especially when the tax consultation made at the time (proven fact number 7) has not been challenged […].” Thus, and in general, mutualist associations or simply mutuals are organizations of persons that, under a principle of solidarity and through an individual contribution or input – in this case, through savings – seek to satisfy common needs or interests of their members by providing various services for their benefit. In the Costa Rican legal system, this type of organization has been regulated precisely through the National Financial System for Housing Law (Ley del Sistema Financiero Nacional para la Vivienda), which in Article 163 restricts the designations "savings and loan association" and "mutual" exclusively to those entities that have been so authorized by the Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda (hereinafter Banhvi) for the provision of the financial services established under that legal framework.
We can therefore affirm that mutualist associations or mutual savings and loan associations are entities forming part of the national financial system for housing, conceived as non-bank financial entities of a private and associative nature, which share with the system the principal purpose of “*…promoting domestic and foreign savings and investment, in order to raise financial resources to seek a solution to the existing housing problem in the country…*” (Articles 1 to 3, 68, 69, 74 and 75 of Law No. 7052). They achieve this purpose through the provision of financial services, under the scheme of mutualism, that is, using savings and loans as a mechanism of contribution and service provision for their members, with the fundamental difference that mutuals in Costa Rica, by forming part of the financial system for housing, additionally serve as an instrument for the channeling, allocation, and final disbursement of resources from that system, specifically, from the National Housing Fund or FONAVI (Articles 41 to 45) and the Housing Subsidy Fund or FOSUVI (Articles 46 to 65), according to the rules established for each of these programs (Articles 3 and 4 of Executive Decree No. 25788-MP-MIVAH, “Regulations for the Organization of the National Financial System for Housing”).
The provision of other services, within this legal framework, constitutes an accessory or subsidiary activity, which, although it could be freely provided by the mutual in its capacity as a private entity and, therefore, governed by the constitutional principle of autonomy of will (Art. 28 of the Political Constitution, CPOL), would only be affected by the system’s benefits insofar as it is authorized by the Banhvi, as we shall see later. Executive Decree No. 25788-MP-MIVAH, “Regulations for the Organization of the National Financial System for Housing,” in its Article 11 establishes a definition of mutualist associations precisely in the sense outlined above: “*Article 11.—Definitions: Mutuals are associations under private law, of indefinite duration, non-profit, and with administrative autonomy, which perform functions of public interest and are subject to the provisions of the System Law, the Organic Law of the Central Bank of Costa Rica (Ley Orgánica del Banco Central de Costa Rica), and other related legislation.
In accordance with Article 75, subsection f) of the law, the Bank may authorize mutuals to diversify operations by carrying out activities other than their normal line of business, provided they are necessary for their strengthening and the achievement of their primary objectives, and constitute a secondary and not a principal activity.*” (Emphasis not from the original). From the foregoing, we can begin to extract the following. First, it should be noted that the link to the provisions of the Organic Law of the Central Bank (Law No. 7558), also in accordance with Article 69 of Law No. 7052, is because the principal activity performed by mutuals resides precisely in the provision of financial intermediation services; hence, Articles 115 to 117 and 150 of Law No. 7558 subject their activities of this category to the control and supervision of the Superintendencia General de Entidades Financieras.
This reinforces once again the conception we have arrived at, of Mutuals as a financial entity within the financial system for housing, since their main scope of activity is limited precisely to the financial intermediation they carry out there. It is within this context that the “functions” or economic activities of Mutuals referred to in Section 75 of Law 7052 are framed: Savings accounts (subsection a), loans for land and housing (subsection b), assignment of mortgage loans (subsection c), issuance of securities (subsection ch), trusts (subsection d), specific activities of the financial system for housing (subsection e), and any other activities, whether or not provided for in the law, previously authorized by the Banhvi (subsection f). Second, and this is directly related to the argument put forward by the plaintiff regarding the type of tax exemption (exención) contained in Articles 69 and 74 of Law No. 7052, for this Chamber it cannot be inferred from the cited provisions that an exoneration with the characteristics attributed to it by the plaintiff exists.
As we saw in the judgment of this Section No. 010-2014-VI, we can indeed classify exemptions as subjective or objective, depending on where the legal dispensation from the tax obligation falls, so that if it refers to one or more specific passive subjects, we can affirm that it is a subjective exemption; whereas if it refers to the circumstances of the taxable event, it is called objective, without both types being mutually exclusive or even exclusive with respect to other categorizations, as we shall see next. Article 62 of the Code of Tax Rules and Procedures (Código de Normas y Procedimientos Tributarios) establishes: “*Article 62.-Conditions and requirements demanded. The law providing for exemptions must specify the conditions and requirements established for granting them, the beneficiaries, the goods, the taxes covered, whether it is total or partial, the term of its duration, and whether at the end or during said period the goods may be released or whether the taxes must be settled, or whether transfer to third parties may be authorized and under what conditions.*” (Emphasis not from the original).
Now, in the case under analysis, as it concerns the same exemption regulated in two articles (69 and 74 of Law 7052), it is possible to summarize it for analysis purposes as follows: Mutualist associations “…*shall enjoy exemption from all classes of taxes, present and future…*”, “…*For the better fulfillment of their purposes*…”, for which they must “…*have the prior approval of the Banco*…” Hipotecario de la Vivienda “…*in each case…*”. This reformulation we have made is also consistent with the provisions of Article 6 of Executive Decree No. 20574-VAH-H of July 8, 1991, entitled: “Regulations on Tax Exemptions and Other Benefits of the National Financial System for Housing Law” (Reglamento de Exenciones Fiscales y otros beneficios de la Ley del Sistema Financiero Nacional para la Vivienda), which establishes the following: “…*Article 6.- Exemptions for mutuals: In accordance with Articles 69, 71 and 74 of the System Law, for the better fulfillment of their purposes, mutuals are exempt from all classes of taxes.
Said exemption covers direct and indirect, national and municipal taxes, including those on stamped paper, fiscal stamps, stamps and other charges of professional associations and registration fees (derechos registrales). In order to avail themselves of the right to exemption, mutuals shall require prior authorization from the Bank, in accordance with Article 74 of the System Law. This authorization shall not be required in cases referring to the normal and repetitive activities of the mutuals, such as: purchase of office equipment and materials (except computers and vehicles), transfer of foreclosed properties in judicial auctions or dación en pago (deed in lieu of foreclosure), formalization of other notarial acts and other similar activities at the discretion of the Bank.*” (Emphasis not from the original). From the conditions and requirements of the exemption under analysis, both in accordance with the rule just transcribed and with Articles 69 and 74 of Law 7052, first, the reference to future taxes must be excluded, as this cannot have effect, pursuant to the stipulations of Sections 63 and 64 of the Code of Tax Rules and Procedures: “*Article 63.- Limit of application.
Even if there is an express provision in the tax law, the exemption does not extend to taxes established after its creation. Article 64.- Validity. The exemption, even if granted based on certain factual conditions, may be repealed or modified by subsequent law, without liability to the State.*” (Emphasis not from the original). Consequently, a discussion sustained in the administrative proceedings regarding the temporal element of the tax obligation is rendered pointless and unnecessary, since the fact that Law 7052 provides that the exemption is for both current and future taxes is improper, as it cannot cover taxes enacted subsequently, and let us recall that Law 7092 has been in force since 1988, while Law 7052 is from 1986, without this being affected by Section 2.ñ of Law No. 7293 of 1992, the Regulatory Law of All Existing Exonerations, Their Repeal and Their Exceptions (Ley Reguladora de todas las Exoneraciones Vigentes, su Derogatoria y sus Excepciones).
Having said that, we must return to the core of the discussion: What type of exemption is the one contained in Articles 69 and 74 of Law 7052? What are its scopes? The plaintiff argues that it is solely subjective; the Administrations indicate that it is also objective, since in their reasoning they present the thesis that it is subject to the fulfillment of the purposes. This Tribunal, in view of what has been developed thus far and considering the various arguments of the parties, leans towards considering that, indeed, it is simultaneously a subjective and objective exemption, and furthermore, one based on general social interests (judgment of this Section No. 010-2014-VI, cited above). The exemption is thus granted to a concrete subcategory of taxpayers: mutualist associations, but it is also conditioned upon “…*the better fulfillment of their purposes*…”, which should be understood to encompass the activities aimed at satisfying the purpose for which the Mutuals were established, which is none other than that of the national financial system for housing, the legal framework under which they have been regulated in our country: “…*promoting domestic and foreign savings and investment, in order to raise financial resources to seek a solution to the existing housing problem in the country…*” (Articles 1 to 3, 68, 69, 74 and 75 of Law No. 7052).
In the opinion of this Tribunal, this general social interest is verified by operation of law in the case of the activities or ‘functions’ listed in Article 75 of the National Financial System for Housing Law, as they are linked to said interest, so much so that they are expressly and directly provided for by the legislator. A different case is that of secondary activities, particularly the one that was subject to withholding at the source and that has given rise to this matter, which in the opinion of the plaintiff Mutual is accessory to the primary objective of the institution and leads to considering the resources from this activity as covered by the exemption just as the financial intermediation functions for housing are. This criterion, while deserving the respect of this Chamber, is not shared by it, as it constitutes a truncated or incomplete argument, since it omits justifying the reason for that assertion.
Specifically, the party forgot to take into account that, by objectively linking the exemption to the accreditation of the fulfillment of the purposes, it entails the necessary verification of the causal relationship between the results of the secondary activity and the achievement of the main purpose of the Mutuals, and this causal nexus is reached through a fundamental element that the parties have not mentioned in this matter, despite the relevance granted to it by the cited regulatory instruments: the authorization of the Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda. Thus, Articles 74 and 75 of Law 7052: “*Article 74.- The mutuals* […] *Shall enjoy the exemption from* […] *the payment of all types of taxes* […] *In order to avail themselves of this latter exemption, the entity must, in each case, have the prior approval of the Bank*. *Article 75.- The mutuals shall have the following functions:* […] *f) In general, carry out all the operations provided for in this law and its regulations, or that, in accordance with them, are authorized by the Bank*…” (Emphasis not from the original).
Likewise, Article 11 of the Regulations for the Organization of the National Financial System for Housing: “…*In accordance with Article 75, subsection f) of the law, the Bank may authorize mutuals to diversify operations by carrying out activities other than their normal line of business, provided they are necessary for their strengthening and the achievement of their primary objectives, and constitute a secondary and not a principal activity.*…” (Emphasis not from the original). Article 6 of the Regulations on Tax Exemptions and Other Benefits of the National Financial System for Housing Law: “…*In order to avail themselves of the right to exemption, mutuals shall require prior authorization from the Bank, in accordance with Article 74 of the System Law. This authorization shall not be required in cases referring to the normal and repetitive activities of the mutuals, such as: purchase of office equipment and materials (except computers and vehicles), transfer of foreclosed properties in judicial auctions or dación en pago (deed in lieu of foreclosure), formalization of other notarial acts and other similar activities at the discretion of the Bank.*” (Emphasis not from the original).
This means that, even beyond the evidentiary work that a mutualist association may undertake to demonstrate that the secondary activity is performed to generate the financial resources necessary to undertake or strengthen the primary activities of those entities, in any case, it will always need that causal relationship to be certified by the Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda, if it wishes to extend the effects of the legal dispensation of the exemption under analysis to these activities. This is so, since in accordance with Article 185 of the Code of Tax Rules and Procedures (CNPT), the burden of proof “…*lies with the taxpayer regarding facts that impede, modify, or extinguish the tax obligation. In that sense, it is up to the latter, as the case may be, to prove the facts or acts that constitute their costs, expenses, liabilities, tax credits, exemptions, non-subjections, deductions and, in general, the tax benefits they claim exist in their favor*…” (Emphasis not from the original).
All of which the plaintiff entity has failed to demonstrate, not only in the administrative proceedings but also before this Tribunal, as can be seen in the list of unproven facts in this judgment. It is worth saying that the authorization of the Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda makes a great deal of sense within the control and supervision scheme implemented in the Organic Law of the Central Bank and in the Financial System for Housing Law itself, since in that regard said regulations granted the Banhvi an auxiliary supervisory competence over mutuals. Article 90 of Law 7052 states: “*Article 90.- The Bank shall act as an auxiliary supervisory body of the Superintendencia General de Entidades Financieras, in relation to the oversight of authorized entities, in order to ensure compliance with the provisions of this law; in accordance with the regulations to be issued by the Superintendency, after consultation with the Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda.
In accordance with the above, the Bank shall maintain broad and permanent oversight of the mutuals. For these purposes, it may, at any time, examine the books, documents, files, and contracts made. The mutuals are also obliged to provide the Bank with all the information it requests from them, and the Bank must keep that information confidentially.*” (Emphasis not from the original). Thus, as we stated at the beginning of this Considerando, insofar as Mutuals intend to participate in the national financial system for housing, or obtain its benefits – such as the exemption under study – the Banvhi shall possess the indispensable and suitable control and supervisory powers to verify that the secondary activities that the mutualist associations undertake in accordance with Article 75.f) of Law 7052, are directly related to the generation of resources that allow them to fulfill their primary objectives, and thereby achieve the extra-tax goals that justified their creation.
This is also reinforced by what is provided in other sections of Law 7052, such as, for example, Article 148: “…*Article 148.- All acts and contracts that, regarding System operations, are carried out by the Bank and the authorized entities among themselves or with other natural or legal persons, shall be exempted from the payment of all types of taxes. This exemption shall apply only with respect to taxes payable by the Bank or by the respective authorized entity. Likewise, the transfer of land – free of charge or for consideration – from public institutions to authorized entities, for the development of housing projects, shall be exempt from the payment of notarial fees…*” (Emphasis not from the original). Again, we observe how the exemptions provided in said Law are necessarily linked to an objective element: the fulfillment of the purposes of the financial system for housing. Now, it is reiterated that this causal relationship must be proved by the Mutuals, and the Banhvi is the competent administrative authority to certify it.
Article 174 of Law 7052 states: “*Article 174.- The powers conferred in this law on the Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda, regarding the operation of authorized entities, only correspond to the financing of housing granted by them. Consequently, the other functions for which the authorized entities are empowered remain outside the competence and control of the Bank.*” (Emphasis not from the original). As we pointed out previously, once it has come into legal existence, a mutualist association, as a private entity and, therefore, governed by the constitutional principle of autonomy of will (Art. 28 CPOL), may freely provide services of a different nature; however, insofar and to the extent that these services fall within the scope of, are consistent with, or serve the purposes and activities of the national financial system for housing, or seek to obtain the benefits, fiscal or otherwise, granted by Law 7052 to authorized entities, the Mutuals will inevitably be subject to the oversight powers of the Banhvi.
This is also established in Articles 6 to 9 of Executive Decree No. 25788-MP-MIVAH, “Regulations for the Organization of the National Financial System for Housing,” but particularly in Sections 6 and 7: “*Article 6°—Scope of the declaration as Authorized Entity: The condition of Authorized Entity of the System applies to the respective institutions, with respect to those programs, plans, projects, and operations they execute within the System's regulations. These provisions shall not apply to activities executed by those institutions that do not meet the aforementioned requirements, and consequently, they may not invoke them in any way to support or justify their actions. Article 7°— Other operations of Authorized Entities: With respect to entities that carry out activities outside the System, the Bank shall be authorized to formulate observations and recommendations to them when they are affecting or could harm the housing programs they execute within it.
Said observations or recommendations may also be formulated to the supervisory authorities of those entities.*” (Emphasis not from the original). This last article reflects, in a negative manner, the indispensability of the prior authorization of the Banhvi, since precisely the performance of secondary activities without supervision or control could instead jeopardize the achievement of the primary purposes of the Mutuals, as authorized entities within the financial system for housing; therefore, if tax exemptions justified by the extra-tax purposes of that system are to be generated on these activities, it would make no sense – at least to this Tribunal – to accept a thesis whereby mutualist associations could benefit from the same, without a prior verification by the Banhvi of the necessary link between the income obtained from these secondary activities and the fulfillment of the primary objective of solving the “*existing housing problem in the country*,” through a special system of financial intermediation.
Thus, this Chamber having determined that the tax exemption contained in Articles 69 and 74 of Law No. 7052, being of both a subjective and objective nature, in addition to being justified by the satisfaction of general social interests, requires, to operate legally, the prior verification of the link between the generation of income and the achievement of the purposes of the national financial system for housing, by the Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda, especially in the case of secondary activities that these may carry out according to Section 75.f) of the same law. Consequently, in the specific case, this Tribunal considers that the generation of gross income (commissions) by Grupo Mutual Alajuela La Vivienda, as economic consideration from a contractual relationship with the Instituto Nacional de Seguros, constitutes a secondary activity of the former that is not covered by the exemption in question, since as has been stated, the prior authorization of the Banhvi is required for it to operate; which, however, has not been accredited, neither before this Tribunal nor in the administrative venue.
For this reason, the defendant Administrations are correct in considering the income obtained by Grupo Mutual through the vehicle registration fee collection business it provides to the INS as not exempted, and which, consequently, is subject to the payment of income tax, all the more so when the tax consultation made at the time (proven fact number 7) has not been challenged […].
“III. SOBRE LOS ALCANCES DE LA EXENCIÓN DE LOS ARTÍCULOS 69 Y 74 DE LA LEY 7052, LEY DEL SISTEMA FINANCIERO PARA LA VIVIENDA.- La hipótesis legal planteada por la representación de Grupo Mutual en su demanda, se estructura a partir de que la exoneración dispuesta en la Ley del Sistema Financiero para la Vivienda es exclusivamente de orden subjetivo y por consiguiente, está dispuesta para abarcar cualquier tributo respecto de cualquier tipo actividad que emprenda la organización; exoneración además inmutable pues se encontraría relacionada a impuestos presentes y futuros. Subsidiariamente, aduce que en todo caso, los ingresos por actividades secundarias, como en el presente caso, constituyen una suerte de recursos accesorios sujetos en todo caso a la finalidad principal de la Asociación Mutualista, de dotación de vivienda popular. De entrada, este Tribunal quisiera apuntar que las exoneraciones al igual que los tributos, se corresponden a una política fiscal que va dirigida en última instancia a la satisfacción de las necesidades públicas a las que se debe el Estado costarricense.
Toda exención por su naturaleza de incentivo o instrumento de fomento, busca alcanzar metas de orden extra fiscal (promoción y disuasión de actividades y redistribución de riqueza), mediante la promoción de actividades públicas o particulares de relevancia pública, como en este caso, la dotación de vivienda, a través de un tipo específico de persona jurídica privada: la asociación mutualista. Sin embargo, y a diferencia de lo sostenido por la demandante, por la razón ya indicada, toda exoneración vigente está sujeta a revisión y modificación por parte del legislador (principio de reserva de ley en materia tributaria –Art. 121.13 CPOL, 5 y 61 CNPT- y mutabilidad del ordenamiento jurídico), no se trata de un beneficio universal, perenne e inmutable como se ha venido a aducir. Hecha esta breve introducción, procedemos al análisis de las normas involucradas en este asunto. La Ley número 7052, Ley del Sistema Financiero Nacional para la Vivienda, entró en vigencia el 27 de noviembre de 1986 y en sus artículos 69 y 74, estableció una exoneración a las Asociaciones Mutualistas en los siguientes términos: “…Artículo 69.- Las mutuales deberán organizarse y funcionar de acuerdo con lo establecido en esta ley y en la Ley Orgánica del Banco Central de Costa Rica.
Para la mejor realización de sus fines, las mutuales gozarán de exención, de tributos de toda clase, presentes y futuros. […] Artículo 74.- Las mutuales tendrán personalidad jurídica propia, que deberá inscribirse en la Sección de Personas del Registro Público, sobre la base de la escritura de su constitución. En consecuencia, serán legalmente capaces para adquirir derechos, contraer obligaciones e intervenir en juicios y diligencias de cualquier índole, judicial y administrativa. Gozarán de la exención de rendir fianzas de costas y de hacer depósitos para garantizar embargos preventivos, así como del pago de todo tipo de impuestos presentes y futuros. Para acogerse a esta última exención, la entidad, en cada caso, deberá contar con la aprobación previa del Banco….” Ahora bien, para comprender adecuadamente los alcances de esta exoneración en el caso concreto, primeramente, es necesario precisar la figura de las mutuales.
De esta manera y en general, las asociaciones mutualistas o simplemente mutuales, corresponden a organizaciones de personas que bajo un principio de solidaridad y a partir de una contribución o aporte individual –en este caso, a partir del ahorro- buscan la satisfacción de necesidades o intereses comunes a los asociados, mediante la prestación de distintos servicios en beneficio de éstos. En el ordenamiento jurídico costarricense, este tipo de organizaciones se han regulado precisamente a través de la Ley del Sistema Financiero Nacional para la Vivienda, que en el artículo 163, restringe las denominaciones "asociación de ahorro y préstamo" y "mutual", únicamente para aquellas entidades que hayan sido así autorizadas por el Banco Hipotecario de la Vivienda (en adelante Banhvi), para la prestación de los servicios financieros establecidos bajo ese marco legal. Podemos afirmar entonces, que las asociaciones mutualistas o mutuales de ahorro y préstamo, corresponden a entidades integrantes del sistema financiero nacional para la vivienda, concebidas como entidades financieras no bancarias de naturaleza privada y asociativa, que comparte con el sistema la finalidad principal de “…fomentar el ahorro y la inversión nacional y extranjera, con el fin de recaudar recursos financieros para procurar la solución del problema habitacional existente en el país…” (Artículos 1 a 3, 68, 69, 74 y 75 Ley N° 7052) Esta finalidad la consiguen a través de la prestación de servicios financieros, bajo el esquema del mutualismo, esto es, utilizando el ahorro y préstamo, como mecanismo de contribución y prestación de servicios para sus asociados, con la diferencia fundamental de que las mutuales en Costa Rica, al formar parte del sistema financiero para la vivienda, sirven adicionalmente como un instrumento para la canalización, asignación y el giro final de los recursos provenientes de ese sistema, en concreto, del Fondo Nacional para Vivienda o FONAVI (artículos 41 a
Document not found. Documento no encontrado.